Uploaded May 2025 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Many people will remember the Oscar Award-winning movie "Moneyball," starring Brad Pitt. It was the story of trying to build a baseball team based on performance data, versus 'star' status of players. A famous line was "If he's such a good hitter, why doesn't he hit good." What happens if we apply similar principles to the thesis of human-caused global warming? We are constantly told that CO2 (carbon dioxide) emissions from human industry are responsible for all the modern day warming since ~1860. But is that true, and how can we find out? Ron Davison, P. Eng., and president of Friends of Science Society has taken a look at various data to see if the rise in CO2 concentration correlates to changes in Greenland's ice and that of Antarctica. He also shows that temperatures fluctuate without correlation to the rise in CO2 concentration. Does CO2 concentration rise correlate with sea level rise? No. CO2 concentrations also did not control the Holocene temperature changes, and so on. This is CO2's "moneyball moment" - if CO2 is such a good climate driver, why doesn't it drive climate good?" This is a shorter presentation of detailed work that is available on Davison's personal website: climatechangeandmusic.com/co2s-moneyball-moment Please like, share and subscribe! Become a member of Friends of Science Society on our website - click on "Join" friendsofscience.org
Many people will remember the Oscar Award-winning movie "Moneyball," starring Brad Pitt. It was the story of trying to build a baseball team based on performance data, versus 'star' status of players. A famous line was "If he's such a good hitter, why doesn't he hit good." What happens if we apply similar principles to the thesis of human-caused global warming? We are constantly told that CO2 (carbon dioxide) emissions from human industry are responsible for all the modern day warming since ~1860. But is that true, and how can we find out? Ron Davison, P. Eng., and president of Friends of Science Society has taken a look at various data to see if the rise in CO2 concentration correlates to changes in Greenland's ice and that of Antarctica. He also shows that temperatures fluctuate without correlation to the rise in CO2 concentration. Does CO2 concentration rise correlate with sea level rise? No. CO2 concentrations also did not control the Holocene temperature changes, and so on. This is CO2's "moneyball moment" - if CO2 is such a good climate driver, why doesn't it drive climate good?" This is a shorter presentation of detailed work that is available on Davison's personal website: climatechangeandmusic.com/co2s-moneyball-moment Please like, share and subscribe! Become a member of Friends of Science Society on our website - click on "Join" friendsofscience.org










![Remember the Carbon Tax? Zeroed. Not Gone.
Most Canadians are happy to be rid of the burdensome cost of the carbon tax, the price of which went from $80/t to zero, upon Mark Carney becoming Prime Minister. But are you aware that the Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS) central bankers have a Shadow Price on Carbon for Net Zero 2050 of ~$800/t ??? How did they come to that conclusion in their models? They chose a wildly exaggerated climate damage function which also appears to have serious conflicts of interest. Friends of Science Society has written an Open Letter to the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions in Canada, in an effort to question the quality of NGFS climate risk assessments - which affect all financial institutions and thus all major corporations - in Canada. This video explainer will walk through some key points of the letter in a plain language way. When the carbon tax was introduced in 2017 by then Minister Catherine McKenna, the cost was only supposed to be pennies a litre. By 2024, the Canadian Taxpayers Federation had made axe the tax a popular cause, as the price of $80/t was crushing peoples budgets. Some 300 economists wrote a letter claiming the carbon tax was the best way to reduce emissions, without imposing other regulations - apparently unaware that there are over 400 climate regulations that overlap and stifle business activity. On day one of Prime Minister Carney taking office, he zeroed the carbon tax. But, he did not cancel it. At the upcoming COP-30 climate conference in Brazil, there is talk of establishing a global price on carbon. [ Conference of the Parties refers to the ~192 countries that are signatory to the 1992 UNFCCC Framework Convention on Climate Change]. So it is deeply concerning that the central banks involved in NGFS are using a flawed research study that is wildly exaggerated, as the basis for their climate damage function. This is a simplified expression of economic damages, theoretically caused by climate inputs. BUT, the outcomes can be positive or negative. In the NGFS climate world, damages are only costly - therefore they established a Shadow Carbon Price of about $800/t for Net Zero 2050. In fact, Ken Gregory, Friends of Science Societys research director, has used the FUND model and found that there is a negative cost to carbon dioxide - meaning that carbon dioxide emissions have social benefits for society. Just imagine that you were paying $80/t carbon tax based on the theory that carbon dioxide emissions were causing harm but in fact, you were actually receiving a benefit of $-13.07/t from carbon dioxide. (The benefit is written mathematically with a minus sign, as negative $13.07/t, because it is not a cost.) While there are lots of estimates of the Social Costs of Carbon Dioxide out there, very few analysts include the many benefits of warming. In Canada, a slightly warmer winter means we have reduced heating costs. In summer, the CO2 fertilization effect of more CO2 makes agricultural crops more abundant. What about extreme weather events? These are not caused by carbon dioxide and there is no trend to more such events. In addition to this good news, the letter to the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions also reveals that there are serious conflicts of interest related to the wildly exaggerated paper, chosen by NGFS. Remember the carbon tax was only one destructive part of climate policies...it has only been zeroed, it is not gone. To be free of these burdensome, useless costs, we must Nix Net Zero and go back to common sense on climate and energy policies. Come and see how Net Zero policies affect Food Prices and Farming. Get your tickets for our Sept. 25, 2025 event - in-person in Calgary or via live stream: https://friendsofsciencesociety.telltix.com/events/friendsofsciencesociety/1820233 Remember the Carbon Tax? Zeroed. Not Gone.](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/s-Hx6rTfw3Y/mqdefault.jpg)