China Is Not Your Activist: The Contradictions of Socialist Statecraft @RealProgressives
China Is Not Your Activist: The Contradictions of Socialist Statecraft  @RealProgressives
Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 hour ago
Why do so many of us expect China to behave like an activist, cutting ties with Israel or denouncing the West at the top of its lungs? Steve takes up that tension with Amy Yang who argues the demand is moral rather than materialist, and asks what changes when we look at China as a state with its own history, contradictions and material limits.

Amy is a Chinese student and writer based in Sweden. Her Substack articles focus on actually existing socialist countries and anti-imperialist struggles in the Third World, and she challenges Eurocentric Western Marxist narratives. She co-hosts the podcasts Resistance is for Tao and For the Masses. Amy admits she once shared the frustration, being an activist herself, until conversations with comrades and family pushed her to read the history. She traces Mao’s turn from the hard anti-imperialist rhetoric of the 1960s to trade and technology transfer in the 1970s, a response to neoliberal finance subjugating the Third World through debt and the IMF. China holds one fifth of humanity and is still a Third World country by per capita measures, so it needs peace and a multipolar order to build the productive forces that a later stage of socialism requires. Steve adds the lessons China drew from the Soviet Union, and Amy reads the Long March as a long retreat toward the goal.

Steve and Amy then take on Western Marxists and Trotskyists who aim their fire at actually existing socialism instead of their own empires. Amy separates tactical compromise from principle with the image of bamboo, which bends without breaking. Private firms can make toys and phones, but land, banks, energy, water, telecommunications and public services stay under state control, and non-interference anchors foreign policy. Steve brings in Fadhel Kaboub’s emphasis on productive, technological and energy sovereignty and asks about ownership and class power. Amy describes the shift since 2012 toward state and collective enterprise, and argues that Chinese workers still produce value for richer Western workers. Their class struggle therefore runs on two fronts, one at home against capital and one globally against imperial value transfer. They also discuss how China prepares for confrontation while playing a long game.

The last stretch turns to the imperial core. Amy argues that voting and symbolic protest will not do the work, and that every disruption of the ruling class, like the revolt in France, gives Third World nations room to breathe. She points to the Black Panther Party’s parallel institutions, to speaking with workers in their own language, and to accepting sacrifice. Steve warns against both adventurism and tailism and recalls Luxemburg on the elected socialist becoming a minister of capital rather than vice versa.

Amy Yang is a Chinese student temporarily based in Europe, whose articles mainly focus on actually existing socialist countries and anti-imperialist struggles in the third world. She seeks to challenge Western Marxist narratives and contribute a Chinese Marxist and anti-imperialist perspective to debates on global politics.

Find Amy on Substack and Instagram under her name, and find her podcasts Resistance is for Tao and For the Masses on Substack.

Chapters:

00:00 Meet Amy Yang
03:02 Why China Is Not Activist
05:22 From Mao to Opening Up
08:36 Development First Contradictions
10:39 Lessons From Soviet Collapse
13:23 Return of Socialist Values
16:17 China Versus Western Hegemony
18:11 BRI BRICS Not Empire
21:00 Performative Western Left Critique
24:33 Bamboo Compromise Principle
27:56 Commanding Heights State Control
29:32 Sovereignty Productive Forces Question
31:37 China Development Stages
33:13 Workers Rights Global Lens
34:21 Two Fronts Class Struggle
36:18 Multipolar Power Vacuums
38:47 Confrontation And Deterrence
42:02 War And Ecological Stakes
42:43 Duties In Imperial Core
45:57 Beyond Voting Organize
51:51 Masses Not Adventurism
53:21 Build Parallel Institutions
55:19 Electoralism And Power
57:51 Wrap Up And Plugs
59:37 Support The Show Outro

Weaponize Knowledge with Modern Monetary Theory (MMT)

Please help our Real Progressives efforts in spreading and become a monthly donor!

At PayPal
paypal.me/RealProgressives/25

At Patreon
patreon.com/realprogressives

Donorbox
donorbox.org/each-one-teach-one-3

Write for Real Progressives
realprogressives.org/submit-an-article

Visit our website:
realprogressives.org

Listen to our podcast:
realprogressives.org/macro-n-cheese-podcast

Subscribe to our Substack:
realprogressives.substack.com

We believe all materials used in this video fall under Fair Use as defined in Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976.

#mmt
China Is Not Your Activist: The Contradictions of Socialist StatecraftThe Billionaire PressRaising Interest Rates Worsens Economic Crises #shorts #fed #interestratesSocialism w/ Chinese Characteristics w/ Yan LiangYellow Vests Rage Against the MachineCurrency vs Bank Credit: Whats the Difference?Organizing the Working ClassGaza: We Have to Keep Telling the Truth!Judgment of Gender: How Woman Are Centered and Silenced in Pop Culture ft. Allison ButlerTowards Palestinian Liberation ft. Hamza HamoucheneThe Leviathan That Eats the World: AIs Hidden Hunger for Energy, Water & the Planet w/ Erald KolasiBlame the Billionaires!
Real Progressives |

China Is Not Your Activist: The Contradictions of Socialist Statecraft

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER