Uploaded March 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
I questioned the Minister regarding Schedule 1 of the Health Legislation Amendment (Miscellaneous Measures No. 1) Bill 2025, specifically the automation of Medicare Provider Numbers (MPNs).
My primary concern, as always, is ensuring that "automation" isn't just a fancy word for another government digital disaster. We’ve seen the Robodebt fiasco, the Bureau of Meteorology website fiasco, Australia Post software fiasco and the Border Force Cargo management automation fiasco; my job is to make sure Australians aren't the next victims of a "government stuff-up."
I asked the Minister why legislation is needed for a process that is already using computers. She replied that this bill provides legislative support for existing practices and introduces safeguards, adding that computers will not be used to revoke or suspend provider numbers without a human request.
I asked if this automation of MPNs was a “Trojan horse” for Artificial Intelligence (AI). Despite the Explanatory Memorandum mentioning "computer programs" for non-discretionary decisions, the Minister stated on the record that there is no intention or requirement to use AI for allocating MPNs.
Finally, I sought clarification on changes to Commonwealth supported places. Under the new rules, medical students who withdraw from their
degree, even late in their studies, will no longer be forced to repay the
scholarship cost (though they remain liable for HECS). The Minister said that
this is about "fairness" rather than recouping funds from students facing hardship.
I remain sceptical of any move toward "automated" government software, and I will be monitoring these automated systems very closely.
Transcript: https://www.malcolmrobertsqld.com.au/avoiding-the-next-robodebt/
I questioned the Minister regarding Schedule 1 of the Health Legislation Amendment (Miscellaneous Measures No. 1) Bill 2025, specifically the automation of Medicare Provider Numbers (MPNs).
My primary concern, as always, is ensuring that "automation" isn't just a fancy word for another government digital disaster. We’ve seen the Robodebt fiasco, the Bureau of Meteorology website fiasco, Australia Post software fiasco and the Border Force Cargo management automation fiasco; my job is to make sure Australians aren't the next victims of a "government stuff-up."
I asked the Minister why legislation is needed for a process that is already using computers. She replied that this bill provides legislative support for existing practices and introduces safeguards, adding that computers will not be used to revoke or suspend provider numbers without a human request.
I asked if this automation of MPNs was a “Trojan horse” for Artificial Intelligence (AI). Despite the Explanatory Memorandum mentioning "computer programs" for non-discretionary decisions, the Minister stated on the record that there is no intention or requirement to use AI for allocating MPNs.
Finally, I sought clarification on changes to Commonwealth supported places. Under the new rules, medical students who withdraw from their
degree, even late in their studies, will no longer be forced to repay the
scholarship cost (though they remain liable for HECS). The Minister said that
this is about "fairness" rather than recouping funds from students facing hardship.
I remain sceptical of any move toward "automated" government software, and I will be monitoring these automated systems very closely.
Transcript: https://www.malcolmrobertsqld.com.au/avoiding-the-next-robodebt/










