Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
I questioned the Sex Discrimination Commissioner, Dr Cody, regarding the Australian Human Rights Commission's intervention as an amicus curiae in the Tickle v Giggle case.
I asked Dr Cody whether the Commission could genuinely claim neutrality when participating in the legal action.
I also raised concerns regarding the official report Equal Identities, questioning whether the Commission's position treats the exclusion of trans females from sex-based spaces as unlawful discrimination under section 5B of the Sex Discrimination Act, and why the office has not actively advised teams and individuals about relevant sport exemptions under section 42.
Additionally, I queried the broader policy approach of recommending the repeal or narrowing of religious and sex-based exemptions, questioning how such positions align with an objective advisory role to the court as amicus curiae or friend of the court.
Finally, I brought up the definition of "gender identity" under the Sex Discrimination Act, specifically the wording regarding a person's characteristics with or without regard to their designated sex at birth, highlighting my concerns about how these legal definitions operate in practice.
Transcript: https://www.malcolmrobertsqld.com.au/is-the-human-rights-commission-neutral/
I questioned the Sex Discrimination Commissioner, Dr Cody, regarding the Australian Human Rights Commission's intervention as an amicus curiae in the Tickle v Giggle case.
I asked Dr Cody whether the Commission could genuinely claim neutrality when participating in the legal action.
I also raised concerns regarding the official report Equal Identities, questioning whether the Commission's position treats the exclusion of trans females from sex-based spaces as unlawful discrimination under section 5B of the Sex Discrimination Act, and why the office has not actively advised teams and individuals about relevant sport exemptions under section 42.
Additionally, I queried the broader policy approach of recommending the repeal or narrowing of religious and sex-based exemptions, questioning how such positions align with an objective advisory role to the court as amicus curiae or friend of the court.
Finally, I brought up the definition of "gender identity" under the Sex Discrimination Act, specifically the wording regarding a person's characteristics with or without regard to their designated sex at birth, highlighting my concerns about how these legal definitions operate in practice.
Transcript: https://www.malcolmrobertsqld.com.au/is-the-human-rights-commission-neutral/










