Are Humans 50% Banana? How Creationists Mix Methods and Mangle Genomes @DrJoelDuff
Are Humans 50% Banana? How Creationists Mix Methods and Mangle Genomes  @DrJoelDuff
Uploaded October 2025 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Bananas, Mice, and Memes: How to Compare Genomes Without Cheating.
In this episode of Critiquing Creationism, I take a closer look at one of the most common — and most misleading — claims in young-earth creationist circles: those famous “DNA similarity” charts that say things like “Humans share 90% of their DNA with cats, 70% with slugs, and 50% with bananas.”

You’ve probably seen these floating around social media, often used by people like Eric Hovind of Creation Today to argue that “similarity points to design, not descent.” But what do those percentages actually mean? Are humans really 98% similar to mice or chimpanzees? And if so, how is that even measured?

In this long-form breakdown, I explain — in plain English — how geneticists and molecular biologists actually calculate genome similarity. I show why creationist charts like these mix apples and oranges (and bananas) by pulling numbers from entirely different methods. Some of those numbers come from gene-by-gene comparisons, others from whole-genome alignments, and others from older techniques like DNA–DNA hybridization. Once you see what’s really going on, those clean little percentages suddenly look a lot less meaningful.

We’ll explore why a coyote and a wolf might be more genetically different (by some methods) than humans and mice — and yet are obviously much closer biologically. I’ll even pull out an extreme example from salamanders to show just how wild genome sizes can be and why bigger (or smaller) doesn’t necessarily mean “more complex.”

In the end, my point is simple: if you don’t know how a percentage was calculated, you don’t know what it means. Numbers divorced from method are worse than useless — they’re misleading.

This episode isn’t just a critique of creationist misuse of data; it’s a short course on how real genomic comparisons are done and why context, consistency, and method matter in science.

⏱️ Chapters

00:00 – Intro: Why talk about genome similarity again?

00:52 – The creationist meme: “90% cat, 50% banana”

03:00 – What those percentages really measure (or don’t)

10:00 – Wolves, coyotes, and the math of genomic alignment

17:00 – Different ways scientists compare genomes

33:00 – Salamander genomes: 67 billion base pairs!

41:00 – Why creationist calculations fail basic consistency tests

48:00 – Takeaway: Always ask how the number was made
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Joel Duff (aka Dr. Duff or The Natural Historian) resources:
About: joelduff.org
Blog: thenaturalhistorian.com
Twitter: twitter.com/NaturalHistoria
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/thenaturalhi...
Photography "Portraits of Creation:" beechnutphotography.com
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Are Humans 50% Banana? How Creationists Mix Methods and Mangle GenomesThe Lemur Problem: When Creationists Concede Too MuchIce Core Science vs The Lost Squadron: Debunking a Popular Creation ArgumentThis Week in Creationism: New Books, New Hires, and Old ContradictionsOOPS! Creationist Artificial Selection Experiment Disproves Rapid Post-Flood SpeciationWhy I Know I Am Right So Let Me Humbly Tell You Why You Are WrongAdam and Eve Naked and Not Ashamed ≠ Global Tropics: Hermeneutics 101Preparing to Speak at the Scopes Trial Centennial:  100 Years of Protestant Reactions to EvolutionBiblical Kinds: A 1946 Perspective on Young Earth CreationismMy Lecture From the Scopes Courtroom: A Century of Christian Responses to EvolutionDoes Creationist No New Information Argument Allow Too Much Evolution?Dead Sea Chronicles Part II:  The Lowest Place on Earth Keeps Getting Lower
Dr. Joel Duff |

Are Humans 50% Banana? How Creationists Mix Methods and Mangle Genomes

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER