The Lemur Problem: When Creationists Concede Too Much @DrJoelDuff
The Lemur Problem: When Creationists Concede Too Much  @DrJoelDuff
Uploaded December 2025 | Updated November 2026, 2 hours ago
Lemurs After Noah's Flood: A Young-Earth Creationism Problem.
In this episode, I respond to a brand-new article published December 17, 2025 on the New Creation blog by Chad Arment titled "Lemurs After Noah's Flood." Madagascar hosts over 100 living species of lemurs across eight distinct families—all found nowhere else on Earth—ranging from 30-gram mouse lemurs to extinct gorilla-sized species. Arment makes a remarkable concession: he accepts that all these lemurs likely descended from a single pair that rafted to Madagascar after Noah's flood, then diversified into everything we see today in just 4,350 years.
Here's why the math is impossible. Molecular clock studies date lemur diversification to approximately 50-60 million years ago—a ratio of 11,000 to 1 compared to the young-earth timeline. You'd need evolution proceeding 11,000 times faster than anything ever observed. The genetics make it worse: lemur chromosome numbers range from 20 to 70 within this single "kind," requiring multiple fusion and fission events that young-earth creationists elsewhere claim are impossibly complex. Some lemurs differ by a billion base pairs in genome size. The only source for all this new variation is mutations—yet creationists simultaneously argue mutations destroy genomes through "genetic entropy." You cannot logically maintain both positions.
Arment invokes Kurt Wise's concept of "saltational diversification"—essentially hoping some undiscovered genetic mechanism allows for rapid jumps in morphology. But as Arment admits, they've "barely scratched the surface" of understanding how this might work. This isn't a mechanism; it's a placeholder for one. The fundamental contradiction is stark: young-earth creationists claim macroevolution is impossible while demanding hyper-speed macroevolution to explain lemur diversity. The evidence leads inexorably to deep time—not because scientists are biased, but because when you do the math, it simply doesn't work any other way.

Chapters
0:00 - Introduction: A New Young-Earth Creationist Article on Lemurs
2:30 - Lemur Diversity: 100+ Species Endemic to Madagascar
5:00 - Creationist Concessions: Single Dispersal Event and Hyper-Evolution
9:00 - The Math Problem: 50 Million Years vs. 4,350 Years
12:00 - Chromosomal Impossibilities: 20 to 70 Chromosomes in One "Kind"
18:00 - The Genetic Bottleneck Paradox
22:30 - Kurt Wise's "Saltational Diversification" Non-Mechanism
26:30 - The Fundamental Contradiction: Rejecting and Requiring Macroevolution
30:00 - Following the Evidence: What Lemurs Tell Us About Deep Time
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Joel Duff (aka Dr. Duff or The Natural Historian) resources:
About: joelduff.org
Blog: thenaturalhistorian.com
Twitter: twitter.com/NaturalHistoria
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/thenaturalhi...
Photography "Portraits of Creation:" beechnutphotography.com
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Lemur Problem: When Creationists Concede Too MuchIce Core Science vs The Lost Squadron: Debunking a Popular Creation ArgumentThis Week in Creationism: New Books, New Hires, and Old ContradictionsOOPS! Creationist Artificial Selection Experiment Disproves Rapid Post-Flood SpeciationWhy I Know I Am Right So Let Me Humbly Tell You Why You Are WrongAdam and Eve Naked and Not Ashamed ≠ Global Tropics: Hermeneutics 101Preparing to Speak at the Scopes Trial Centennial:  100 Years of Protestant Reactions to EvolutionBiblical Kinds: A 1946 Perspective on Young Earth CreationismMy Lecture From the Scopes Courtroom: A Century of Christian Responses to EvolutionDoes Creationist No New Information Argument Allow Too Much Evolution?Dead Sea Chronicles Part II:  The Lowest Place on Earth Keeps Getting LowerYEC Scientists Published a Paper—And It Destroys Flood Geology
Dr. Joel Duff |

The Lemur Problem: When Creationists Concede Too Much

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER