Uploaded January 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
Can the past be infinite? In this philosophy of time explainer, we analyse the Grim Reaper Paradox and show a brand new argument for why it fails as a cosmological argument.
The Grim Reaper Argument is often presented as a decisive reason to think an infinite past is impossible. Here Alex Malpass and Dan Linford explain their new paper on why the argument quietly relies on incompatible assumptions about laws, causation, and metaphysics.
Don't confuse this with a prior video we did with Joe Schmid of Majesty of Reason, this is a brand new argument!
You can find the article here :
https://digitalcommons.odu.edu/philosophy_fac_pubs/107/
and do check out Alex Malpass's own show Thoughtology which has lots of great material and guests
youtube.com/@thoughtology7732
00:00 Introduction to the Grim Reaper Argument
5:08 bad criticisms the argument
6:29 better than Hilberts Hotel
8:44 assumption behind the Grim Reaper
12:00 solutions the paradox
19:56 Humean vs anti Humean
24:26 laws of physics
25:59 thick modal properties
30:30 an argument for no one
38:58 reformulating the argument
44:56 near reaper vs grim reaper
49:35 indeterminism
54:24 alternate view of causality
58:45 reaction
1:05 : 18 Vielnkin's tunnelling from Notting
Can the past be infinite? In this philosophy of time explainer, we analyse the Grim Reaper Paradox and show a brand new argument for why it fails as a cosmological argument.
The Grim Reaper Argument is often presented as a decisive reason to think an infinite past is impossible. Here Alex Malpass and Dan Linford explain their new paper on why the argument quietly relies on incompatible assumptions about laws, causation, and metaphysics.
Don't confuse this with a prior video we did with Joe Schmid of Majesty of Reason, this is a brand new argument!
You can find the article here :
https://digitalcommons.odu.edu/philosophy_fac_pubs/107/
and do check out Alex Malpass's own show Thoughtology which has lots of great material and guests
youtube.com/@thoughtology7732
00:00 Introduction to the Grim Reaper Argument
5:08 bad criticisms the argument
6:29 better than Hilberts Hotel
8:44 assumption behind the Grim Reaper
12:00 solutions the paradox
19:56 Humean vs anti Humean
24:26 laws of physics
25:59 thick modal properties
30:30 an argument for no one
38:58 reformulating the argument
44:56 near reaper vs grim reaper
49:35 indeterminism
54:24 alternate view of causality
58:45 reaction
1:05 : 18 Vielnkin's tunnelling from Notting










