Uploaded August 2025 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Alex O'Connor has the called the Ontological Argument for God his favourite argument for God. But in this video we show how it can be flipped around and used as an argument for atheism. This symmetry has been known about for a long time. But in a new paper, Joe Schmidt and colleagues have shown the atheistic version of the argument actually stronger than the theistic version. Joe Schmidt joins me to unpack these exciting new results.
Joe's new paper can be found here:
philarchive.org/rec/FRISLA-2
here is article in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy here:
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ontological-arguments/
and his survey of symmetry breakers here:
philarchive.org/rec/SCHSBF-2
00:00 Introduction
00:39 What is the ontological argument ?
4:30 modal argument
8:15 possible worlds
16:17 modal argument for atheism
19:43 symmetry breakers
27:26 the central problem
28:06 the new paper explained
42 :00 debates on modal logics
47:26 why atheisms in favoured
51:29 Why if Kt isnt right?
56:00 magic trick
59:35 theism push back?
Alex O'Connor has the called the Ontological Argument for God his favourite argument for God. But in this video we show how it can be flipped around and used as an argument for atheism. This symmetry has been known about for a long time. But in a new paper, Joe Schmidt and colleagues have shown the atheistic version of the argument actually stronger than the theistic version. Joe Schmidt joins me to unpack these exciting new results.
Joe's new paper can be found here:
philarchive.org/rec/FRISLA-2
here is article in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy here:
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ontological-arguments/
and his survey of symmetry breakers here:
philarchive.org/rec/SCHSBF-2
00:00 Introduction
00:39 What is the ontological argument ?
4:30 modal argument
8:15 possible worlds
16:17 modal argument for atheism
19:43 symmetry breakers
27:26 the central problem
28:06 the new paper explained
42 :00 debates on modal logics
47:26 why atheisms in favoured
51:29 Why if Kt isnt right?
56:00 magic trick
59:35 theism push back?










