Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Why have two research traditions built on J.J. Gibson, 4E cognitive science and ecological dynamics, barely spoken to each other, and what happens to skill, emotion, and meaning when they finally do?
In this Lectern conversation, Rafe Kelley leads a long-awaited dialogue between John Vervaeke and Rob Gray, who studies how people learn and adapt skills in baseball, other sports, and police training. Rafe frames the puzzle: both men are deeply rooted in Gibson, yet 4E cognitive science and ecological dynamics in motor learning have stayed largely siloed. Rob explains how the 4P model of knowing reached him through police-training colleague Pete Blair, and why it helps explain where cognition fits in an ecological approach, especially when officers must later explain their decisions. John argues that relevance realization comes before representation, that participatory and perspectival knowing are not representational, and proposes a fifth E, exaptation, in which sensorimotor processes are repurposed to move through abstract and affective space.
The conversation then turns from how skills are learned to why practice matters for a meaningful life. Rafe recalls John's challenge, “Where are the practices?”, and argues that physical practice like parkour grounds an embodied way of knowing whether we are getting better. John asks whether skill training can cultivate virtue, and Rob points to identity and to police work built around community-connected officers. Rafe proposes a sixth E, emotion, drawing on play research; Rob describes hot versus cold practice and helping athletes reframe pressure as challenge instead of suppressing it. In the final stretch, Rafe brings in Nikolai Bernstein and the degrees of freedom problem, and John explains why he does not think robots are embodied the way living organisms are.
Rafe Kelley is a movement teacher and parkour practitioner whose work focuses on embodied practice, play, and how physical practice contributes to meaning in life. He runs the Return to the Source intensive, and in this episode he leads the conversation as the bridge between the two traditions.
Rob Gray is a professor at Arizona State University who studies how people learn, acquire, and adapt skills. He applies an ecological dynamics, embodied approach to skill development in baseball, other sports, and police training.
John Vervaeke is a cognitive scientist and philosopher whose work explores cognition, meaning, wisdom, and the meaning crisis. In this conversation, he brings relevance realization, the 4P model of knowing, and his proposed fifth E, exaptation, to bear on skill, emotion, and embodiment.
John Vervaeke’s Web - johnvervaeke.com
Emerging Cognition - Rob Gray: amazon.com/s?k=Rob+Gray+Emerging+Cognition
Dynamics in Action - Alicia Juarrero: amazon.com/s?k=Alicia+Juarrero+Dynamics+in+Action
Descartes’ Error - Antonio Damasio: amazon.com/s?k=Antonio+Damasio+Descartes+Error
The Rediscovery of the Mind - John Searle: amazon.com/s?k=John+Searle+The+Rediscovery+of+the+Mind
00:00 Cold open: “Where are the practices?”
00:55 Welcome: Rafe takes the lead
01:30 Two traditions rooted in J.J. Gibson
03:40 Rob Gray on skill and police training
07:05 Why are 4E and ecological dynamics siloed?
11:40 The perspectival P and identity
13:05 Is 4E representational?
15:50 Relevance realization before representation
22:30 A fifth E: exaptation
25:40 Insight in finger and eye movements
27:20 What is natural language?
31:55 Meaning and Return to the Source
34:40 “Where are the practices?”
35:23 “Don't tell me, don't tell me what you believe. Tell me what you practice.”
38:20 Martial arts and the pendulum swing
42:50 A sixth E: emotion and play
45:00 Hot practice vs. cold practice
46:20 Reason and emotion are not enemies
51:00 Reframing pressure, not suppressing it
54:20 Bernstein and a seventh E
59:50 Dexterity and participatory knowing
01:01:40 Why robots aren’t embodied
01:03:40 Bernstein’s degrees of freedom
01:06:35 Closing reflections
Explore courses and teachings from The Lectern
lectern.johnvervaeke.com
Support the Lectern and join a growing community of wisdom seekers
patreon.com/johnvervaeke
Ideas, People, and Works Mentioned in this Episode
J.J. Gibson
Nikolai Bernstein
Alicia Juarrero
Evan Thompson
Julian Kiverstein
Anthony Chemero
John Searle
Hubert Dreyfus
Barbara Tversky
Antonio Damasio
Barbara Fredrickson
Jaak Panksepp
Pete Blair
Follow John Vervaeke:
Website - johnvervaeke.com
Twitter - https://x.com/DrJohnVervaeke
YouTube - youtube.com/@johnvervaeke/videos
Patreon - patreon.com/johnvervaeke
Thank you for watching!
Why have two research traditions built on J.J. Gibson, 4E cognitive science and ecological dynamics, barely spoken to each other, and what happens to skill, emotion, and meaning when they finally do?
In this Lectern conversation, Rafe Kelley leads a long-awaited dialogue between John Vervaeke and Rob Gray, who studies how people learn and adapt skills in baseball, other sports, and police training. Rafe frames the puzzle: both men are deeply rooted in Gibson, yet 4E cognitive science and ecological dynamics in motor learning have stayed largely siloed. Rob explains how the 4P model of knowing reached him through police-training colleague Pete Blair, and why it helps explain where cognition fits in an ecological approach, especially when officers must later explain their decisions. John argues that relevance realization comes before representation, that participatory and perspectival knowing are not representational, and proposes a fifth E, exaptation, in which sensorimotor processes are repurposed to move through abstract and affective space.
The conversation then turns from how skills are learned to why practice matters for a meaningful life. Rafe recalls John's challenge, “Where are the practices?”, and argues that physical practice like parkour grounds an embodied way of knowing whether we are getting better. John asks whether skill training can cultivate virtue, and Rob points to identity and to police work built around community-connected officers. Rafe proposes a sixth E, emotion, drawing on play research; Rob describes hot versus cold practice and helping athletes reframe pressure as challenge instead of suppressing it. In the final stretch, Rafe brings in Nikolai Bernstein and the degrees of freedom problem, and John explains why he does not think robots are embodied the way living organisms are.
Rafe Kelley is a movement teacher and parkour practitioner whose work focuses on embodied practice, play, and how physical practice contributes to meaning in life. He runs the Return to the Source intensive, and in this episode he leads the conversation as the bridge between the two traditions.
Rob Gray is a professor at Arizona State University who studies how people learn, acquire, and adapt skills. He applies an ecological dynamics, embodied approach to skill development in baseball, other sports, and police training.
John Vervaeke is a cognitive scientist and philosopher whose work explores cognition, meaning, wisdom, and the meaning crisis. In this conversation, he brings relevance realization, the 4P model of knowing, and his proposed fifth E, exaptation, to bear on skill, emotion, and embodiment.
John Vervaeke’s Web - johnvervaeke.com
Emerging Cognition - Rob Gray: amazon.com/s?k=Rob+Gray+Emerging+Cognition
Dynamics in Action - Alicia Juarrero: amazon.com/s?k=Alicia+Juarrero+Dynamics+in+Action
Descartes’ Error - Antonio Damasio: amazon.com/s?k=Antonio+Damasio+Descartes+Error
The Rediscovery of the Mind - John Searle: amazon.com/s?k=John+Searle+The+Rediscovery+of+the+Mind
00:00 Cold open: “Where are the practices?”
00:55 Welcome: Rafe takes the lead
01:30 Two traditions rooted in J.J. Gibson
03:40 Rob Gray on skill and police training
07:05 Why are 4E and ecological dynamics siloed?
11:40 The perspectival P and identity
13:05 Is 4E representational?
15:50 Relevance realization before representation
22:30 A fifth E: exaptation
25:40 Insight in finger and eye movements
27:20 What is natural language?
31:55 Meaning and Return to the Source
34:40 “Where are the practices?”
35:23 “Don't tell me, don't tell me what you believe. Tell me what you practice.”
38:20 Martial arts and the pendulum swing
42:50 A sixth E: emotion and play
45:00 Hot practice vs. cold practice
46:20 Reason and emotion are not enemies
51:00 Reframing pressure, not suppressing it
54:20 Bernstein and a seventh E
59:50 Dexterity and participatory knowing
01:01:40 Why robots aren’t embodied
01:03:40 Bernstein’s degrees of freedom
01:06:35 Closing reflections
Explore courses and teachings from The Lectern
lectern.johnvervaeke.com
Support the Lectern and join a growing community of wisdom seekers
patreon.com/johnvervaeke
Ideas, People, and Works Mentioned in this Episode
J.J. Gibson
Nikolai Bernstein
Alicia Juarrero
Evan Thompson
Julian Kiverstein
Anthony Chemero
John Searle
Hubert Dreyfus
Barbara Tversky
Antonio Damasio
Barbara Fredrickson
Jaak Panksepp
Pete Blair
Follow John Vervaeke:
Website - johnvervaeke.com
Twitter - https://x.com/DrJohnVervaeke
YouTube - youtube.com/@johnvervaeke/videos
Patreon - patreon.com/johnvervaeke
Thank you for watching!
![Exploring Emotions and Transrational Wisdom with Vivian Dittmar
John Vervaeke and Vivian Dittmar discuss the integral yet overlooked role of emotions and affect in spirituality and the cultivation of wisdom. Vivian, with her diverse background that includes experiences in traditional cultures, Far Eastern philosophy, and shamanic traditions, outlines a framework differentiating physical sensations, biological instincts, social feelings, unprocessed emotions, and transcendent abilities. She emphasizes practices that help process difficult emotions to develop wisdom rather than escape into spiritual bypassing. John explores resonances with Greek philosophys link between virtue, emotion, and reason. Their rich conversation hints at deep connections between rationality, wisdom, and spirituality, signaling more still to unpack.
Glossary of Terms
Transrational Wisdom: Beyond traditional rational thinking, incorporating intuitive and holistic understanding.
Conscious Release: A practice for processing and releasing emotional baggage.
Ecology of Practices: A framework for integrating various spiritual and mindfulness practices.
Vivian Dittmar
Website: https://viviandittmar.net/en/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/AuthorVivianDittmar/
John Vervaeke
Website: https://johnvervaeke.com/
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/johnvervaeke
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/VervaekeJohn/
X: https://twitter.com/vervaeke_john
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@johnvervaeke
Resources and References
The Vervaeke Foundation: https://vervaekefoundation.org/
Be the Change Stiftung: https://be-the-change.de/
Books, Articles, and Publications
The Emotional Backpack - Vivian Dittmar: https://viviandittmar.net/en/the-emotional-backpack-book/
Your inner GPS - Vivian Dittmar: https://viviandittmar.net/en/your-inner-gps/
How the West Really Lost God: A New Theory of Secularization - Mary Eberstadt: https://www.amazon.com/How-West-Really-Lost-Secularization/dp/1599474662
Emotion Focused Therapy: http://www.emotionfocusedtherapy.org/
Quotes
Discussing spirituality and rationality can bridge gaps in our understanding of emotions. - John Vervaeke
Emotional baggage shapes our perception and rationality in profound ways. - Vivian Dittmar
Chapters with Timestamps
[00:00:00] Introduction
[00:01:41] Vivian’s Background and Early Insights
[00:11:01] Exploring Emotions and Rationality
[00:20:01] The Practice of Conscious Release
[00:30:01] Transrational Wisdom and Spiritual Practices
[00:40:01] Concluding Thoughts
Timestamped Highlights
[00:00:00] Introduction of the episode and guest, Vivian Dittmar, by John Vervaeke.
[00:17:00] Discussion on the confusion surrounding emotions and feelings in Western thought.
[00:21:11] Vivian introduces her concept of five different kinds of sensations.
[00:23:39] Discussion on the importance of addressing emotional baggage and integrating transpersonal wisdom for appropriate emotional responses and personal growth.
[00:28:52] Vivian talks about how becoming a mother influenced her spiritual practices.
[00:33:08] Addressing the concept of spiritual bypassing and the need for genuine transformative practices.
[00:37:01] Description of the conscious release practice and its significance in emotional processing.
[00:41:00] Discussing the importance of catharsis in self-realization and wisdom acquisition.
[00:43:59] John and Vivian explore the deeper aspects of suffering and inner peace.
[00:47:14] Delving into the relationship between rationality and spirituality.
[00:52:42] Vivians final thoughts on embracing the darker aspects of our psyche for growth and wisdom.
[00:53:43] John reflects on the inward journey illuminated through the conversation.
[00:53:53] Conclusion of the episode with an invitation for further exploration in future discussions. Exploring Emotions and Transrational Wisdom with Vivian Dittmar](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/IQWLfOFe0lo/mqdefault.jpg)



![The Journey to Philosophical Wisdom | Philosophy of Meditation #1 with Rick Repetti
In this first episode of the Philosophy of Meditation series, Rick Repetti and John Vervaeke take listeners on an engaging exploration of the intricate world of meditation and its deep roots in philosophical thought. John shares his transformative journey from a strict fundamentalist Christian background to finding solace and depth in Eastern philosophy and the practice of mindfulness. Rick and John’s conversation navigates through the nuances of meditation and contemplation, shedding light on how these practices enrich the pursuit of wisdom and self-awareness. The discussion also bridges the gap between academic and practical philosophy, illustrating their vital role in understanding and cultivating wisdom. For listeners, this episode offers a deep, reflective insight into the philosophy of meditation, providing a comprehensive view of how these ancient practices are relevant and transformative in the modern world. The outcome is a rich tapestry of ideas, encouraging listeners to explore their own paths toward wisdom and self-realization.
John Vervaeke:
Website: https://johnvervaeke.com/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@johnvervaeke
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/johnvervaeke
X: https://twitter.com/vervaeke_john
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/VervaekeJohn/
Rick Repetti:
Website: https://www.rickrepetti.com/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/rickrepetti/
X: https://twitter.com/rickrepetti
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/philosophicalpractitioner/
Join our new Patreon
https://www.patreon.com/johnvervaeke
The Vervaeke Foundation - https://vervaekefoundation.org/
Awaken to Meaning - https://awakentomeaning.com/
John Vervaeke YouTube
Awakening from the Meaning Crisis https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLND1JCRq8Vuh3f0P5qjrSdb5eC1ZfZwWJ
After Socrates
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZOwjmZx12gk&list=PLND1JCRq8Vuj6q5NP_fXjBzUT1p_qYSCC
AI: The Coming Thresholds and The Path We Must Take | Internationally Acclaimed Cognitive Scientist
https://youtu.be/A RdKiDbz4
Books, Articles, and Publications
Routledge Handbook on the Philosophy of Meditation - Rick Repetti
https://www.amazon.com/Routledge-Handbook-Philosophy-Meditation-Repetti/dp/036764746X
Experimental Phenomenology: An Introduction - Don Ihde https://www.amazon.com/Experimental-Phenomenology-Introduction-Don-Ihde/dp/0887061990
Mentoring the Machines: Orientation - Part One: Surviving the Deep Impact of the Artificially Intelligent Tomorrow - John Vervaeke, Shawn Coyne https://www.amazon.com/Mentoring-Machines-Orientation-Artificially-Intelligent/dp/1645010821/
Mentoring the Machines: Origins - Part 2: Surviving the Deep Impact of the Artificially Intelligent Tomorrow - John Vervaeke, Shawn Coyne
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0CH8W8XLF
The Republic by Plato - The Internet Classics Archive
https://classics.mit.edu/Plato/republic.html
Relevance, Meaning and the Cognitive Science of Wisdom Vervaeke, J., & Ferraro, L. (2013)
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/286508333_Relevance_Meaning_and_the_Cognitive_Science_of_Wisdom
Quotes
Mindfulness and philosophy converge in cognitive science, enriching our understanding of wisdom. - John Vervaeke
Meditation and contemplation are integral for a holistic philosophical understanding. - Rick Repetti
The journey to wisdom involves integrating academic philosophy with life practices. - John Vervaeke
Chapters with Timestamps
[00:00:00] Introduction to the Series
[00:03:00] Johns Personal Journey to Philosophy and Meditation
[00:06:00] The Convergence of Mindfulness and Academic Philosophy
[00:11:40] Defining Meditation and Contemplation
[00:19:24] Discussion on Academic Philosophy and Its Practice
[00:22:20] Exploring the Philosophy of Meditation
[00:41:00] The Impact of Meditation in Personal Life
[00:52:00] Neoplatonic Levels of Meditation
[00:55:50] Integration of Eastern and Western Philosophical Practices
[01:17:16] Exploring the Verveke Foundation and Its Role
[01:24:00] The Importance of Community and Shared Practices
[01:28:00] Final Thoughts and Reflections The Journey to Philosophical Wisdom | Philosophy of Meditation #1 with Rick Repetti](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/JC3NpMEhGKQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![Dynamics of Modern Paradigm Shifts with Jordan Hall
John Vervaeke and Jordan Hall engage in a profound discussion on the nature and impact of paradigm shifts in contemporary times, exploring how these shifts are not just led by theoretical changes but also by randomness and technical advancements. They delve into the role of anomalies, experimentation, and the concept of the imaginal in facilitating these shifts. Highlighting historical examples, such as Einstein and Heisenberg, they discuss how philosophical and cross-cultural explorations contribute to new ways of thinking. The conversation further explores the necessity of breaking existing structures and disciplines for new explorations, with the metaphor of individuals gathering diverse tools without initially understanding their collective purpose. This comprehensive dialogue underscores the complexity of paradigm shifts, intertwining technical, individual, collective, and socio-cultural dynamics.
Resources and References:
Jordan Hall
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCMzT-mdCqoyEv YZVtE7MQ
Medium: https://medium.com/deep-code
X: https://twitter.com/jgreenhall?lang=en
John Vervaeke
Website: https://johnvervaeke.com/
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/johnvervaeke
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/VervaekeJohn/
X: https://twitter.com/vervaeke_john
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@johnvervaeke
The Vervaeke Foundation: https://vervaekefoundation.org/
John Vervaeke YouTube
Awakening from the Meaning Crisis: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLND1JCRq8Vuh3f0P5qjrSdb5eC1ZfZwWJ
The Elusive I - Part 1 - The Cognitive Science Show: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v Fnmp6UVafM
Books, Articles, and Publications
Hyperobjects: Philosophy and Ecology after the End of the World - Timothy Morton: https://www.amazon.com/Hyperobjects-Philosophy-Ecology-after-Posthumanities/dp/0816689237/ref=sr_1_1?crid=3LWYD2SINOHUY&keywords=hyperobject&qid=1701107924&s=books&sprefix=hyperobject%2Cstripbooks%2C157&sr=1-1
Gilles Deleuze - Postscript on the Societies of Control: http://home.lu.lv/~ruben/Deleuze%20-%20Postscript%20On%20The%20Societies%20Of%20Control.pdf
Postscript on Societies of Control. Deleuze, G. (1995). In M. Joughin (Trans.), Negotiations (pp. 177-182). Columbia University Press. (Original work published 1990).: https://deleuze.cla.purdue.edu/resource/gilles-deleuze-postscript-on-societies-of-control/
Timestamped Highlights
[00:00:00] - Introduction to the concept of paradigm shifts and their influence by technical changes and new theories.
[00:03:04] - Perspective on paradigm shifts, emphasizing philosophical aspects influencing scientists like Einstein and Heisenberg.
[00:06:01] - Discussion on the process of paradigm shifts, comparing it to discovering and utilizing new tools like a screwdriver.
[00:09:12] - Exploration of the role of imagination in paradigm shifts, with references to historical figures like Galileo.
[00:12:01] - Analysis of the interplay between the possible, the adjacent possible, and the imaginal in the context of paradigm shifts.
[00:15:06] - Elaboration on the concept of recollecting oneself during paradigm shifts.
[00:18:42] - Questioning how people recognize and adopt new paradigms, focusing on the role of anomalies.
[00:21:21] - Discussion of the impact of societal changes and cultural anomalies on individuals experiences and perceptions.
[00:24:53] - Connection of Timothy Mortons concept of hyperobjects with Piagets work on developmental change, relating it to paradigm shifts.
[00:30:12] - Discussion of the adjacent possible and its relation to paradigm shifts, using personal experiences as examples.
[00:33:12] - Delving into the idea of distributed cognition in relation to grasping complex concepts like hyperobjects.
[00:37:53] - Emphasis that in every paradigm shift, new problems are resolved, opportunities emerge, and new problems arise.
[00:42:44] - Analysis of the emergence of democracy from the Protestant Reformation, linking it to changes brought by the printing press.
[00:46:35] - Description of how digital identities and services could be modulated based on social credit scores in a future paradigm.
[00:51:50] - Prediction of the future potential of fully implemented social credit systems and their impact on everyday life.
[00:56:57] - Discussion on the potential of new technologies to cause paradigmatic shifts, similar to alphabetic literacy and the printing press, and how these shifts might engender new ways of thinking and being beyond their immediate, apparent effects.
[01:00:08] - Analysis of the potential outcomes and limitations of Chinas AI-controlled social credit system, exploring its evolutionary impact within the constraints of paradigm space.
[01:06:29] - Conclusion: Deliberation on the potential of rapid paradigm shifts to either disrupt human connection to timeless values or enhance understanding, emphasizing the need for discernment. Dynamics of Modern Paradigm Shifts with Jordan Hall](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/JDKM6UXzBqM/mqdefault.jpg)
![Integrating Science and Contemplative Practice | Philosophy of Meditation #7 with Mark Miller
In this episode of Voices with Vervaeke, philosopher and cognitive scientist Mark Miller joins John Vervaeke and Rick Repetti for a fascinating discussion on the connections between philosophy, science, and contemplative practice. Mark provides insight into his work as a synthetic philosopher, integrating diverse fields like neuroscience and Buddhism to create theoretical frameworks for understanding the mind and contemplation. The conversation explores whether there can or should be a philosophy of meditation, and how science and philosophy might contribute to human flourishing and contemplative development. Mark shares rich examples of how computational models and cognitive science can elucidate contemplative skills and states, providing nuance to traditional teachings. He emphasizes the importance of balance between insight practices and compassion cultivation on the contemplative path.
Mark Miller, a philosopher and cognitive scientist, holds a senior research fellowship at Monash Universitys Center for Consciousness and Contemplative Studies in Australia, with affiliations at the University of Toronto and Hokkaido University in Japan. His work, which delves into the interplay between human thought, technologys impact on well-being, and human-computer interaction, is at the forefront of integrating cognitive neuroscience with philosophical inquiry.
Glossary of Terms
Predictive Processing: A cognitive science theory that suggests the brain continuously makes predictions about the environment based on past experiences.
Synthetic Philosophy: An interdisciplinary approach that integrates insights from various fields to develop comprehensive frameworks for understanding complex phenomena.
Contemplative Science: A field of study that investigates the effects of meditation and contemplative practices on the mind and well-being.
John Vervaeke:
Website: https://johnvervaeke.com/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@johnvervaeke
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/johnvervaeke
X: https://twitter.com/vervaeke_john
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/VervaekeJohn/
Rick Repetti:
Website: https://www.rickrepetti.com/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/rickrepetti/
X: https://twitter.com/rickrepetti
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/philosophicalpractitioner/
Mark Miller:
The Contemplative Science Podcast: https://www.thecontemplativescientists.com/
Website: https://www.markdmiller.live/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCaYjSup-Hp3V9P6MGt2zPuA
X: https://twitter.com/predictivelife
Join our new Patreon
https://www.patreon.com/johnvervaeke
The Vervaeke Foundation - https://vervaekefoundation.org/
Awaken to Meaning - https://awakentomeaning.com/
Books, Articles, and Publications
Routledge Handbook on the Philosophy of Meditation - Rick Repetti
https://www.amazon.com/Routledge-Handbook-Philosophy-Meditation-Repetti/dp/036764746X
Why I Am Not a Buddhist - Evan Thompson https://www.amazon.com/Why-I-Am-Not-Buddhist/dp/0300264674
Quotes
“Meditation is philosophy. Its not about relaxing, and its certainly not about just creating weird psychedelic states so that we can blow our minds and talk about it. Meditation is a way of knowing ourselves, knowing our situation, and then flourishing through that special knowing.” - Mark Miller [00:16:42]
Dont under appreciate the value of love for your training. If youre listening to this, and youre contemplative, and youre tuning in now to help your practice, dont overlook it. Its valuable at the beginning, in the middle, in the end - like even a small amount of loving kindness and kindness practice now is going to make all the difference. - Mark Miller [00:56:00]
Chapters
[00:00:00] Introduction
[00:06:00] - Mark Millers Journey in Contemplative Science
[00:14:00] - Meditations Role in Philosophy and Contemplation
[00:17:00] - Synthetic Philosophy and Contemplative Science
[00:23:00] - Bridging Science, Philosophy and Contemplative Practice
[00:30:00] - Blending Philosophy and Cognitive Science in Contemplative Practice
[00:47:00] - Exploring Deep Belief Structures and Skillful Engagement
[00:55:00] - Concluding Thoughts Integrating Science and Contemplative Practice | Philosophy of Meditation #7 with Mark Miller](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/JF1DERVUc1M/mqdefault.jpg)


![Exploring the Transrational: A Journey into the Realms of Consciousness with Vivian Dittmar
In their second dialogue on Voices with Vervaeke, John Vervaeke and Vivian Dittmar explore transrational thought, emotions, and transformative practices, embarking on a profound journey into human experience. Vivian introduces a map of five distinct sensations, illuminating the practice of conscious release for personal growth, emotional maturity, and integrating higher consciousness with shadow aspects. Their discussion delves into pre-rational, rational, and transrational modes of thought, emphasizing the importance of integrating various forms of thinking to navigate modern cognitive landscapes effectively. This intellectual and experiential exploration offers valuable perspectives on human consciousness, emotional work, and the potential of transrational thought to enrich our self-understanding and worldview.
Vivian Dittmar, a globally influenced author, speaker, and wisdom teacher, has dedicated two decades to enhancing holistic development. Her diverse upbringing inspired her to explore beyond conventional education, delving into various cultures wisdom. Through her books and the Be the Change Foundation, Dittmar seeks to redefine prosperity, focusing on emotional intelligence, ecological sustainability, social justice, and spiritual fulfillment, aiming to address the crises facing modern society.
Glossary of Terms
Transrational: Going beyond or surpassing human reason or the rational; nonverbal; nonlinear; abstract.
Pre-rational: Preceding the development of intelligence.
Rational: A state of consciousness characterized by logical, linear, and verbal thinking.
Conscious Release: A practice developed by Vivian Dittmar that fosters the integration of higher states of consciousness with shadow aspects.
John Vervaeke
Website: https://johnvervaeke.com/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@johnvervaeke
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/johnvervaeke
X: https://twitter.com/vervaeke_john
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/VervaekeJohn/
Vivian Dittmar
Website: https://viviandittmar.com
YouTube: https://youtube.com/@viviandittmareng
Resources:
Join our new Patreon
https://www.patreon.com/johnvervaeke
The Vervaeke Foundation - https://vervaekefoundation.org/
Awaken to Meaning - https://awakentomeaning.com/
Voices with Veraeke: Exploring Emotions and Transrational Wisdom with Vivian Dittmar https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IQWLfOFe0lo
The Emotional Backpack: How to release unhealthy feelings - Vivian Dittmar https://viviandittmar.net/en/the-emotional-backpack-book/
Your Inner GPS: Find Clarity with the Five Ways of Thinking - Vivian Dittmar https://viviandittmar.net/en/your-inner-gps-book/
Workshop: “How Big Is Your Emotional Backpack?” https://signup.lebensweise.net/free-backpack-workshop
Online Course: “The Emotional Backpack” ► https://campus.lebensweise.net/o/the-emotional-backpack-online-course/
Rational Intuition: Philosophical Roots, Scientific Investigations - Lisa Osbeck, Barbara Held https://www.amazon.com/Rational-Intuition-Philosophical-Scientific-Investigations/dp/1316621219
Quotes
One of the things that became really clear to me is that the transrational by nature has a very difficult stance in todays world because it speaks to us in a way that is nonverbal, nonlinear, abstract. - Vivian Dittmar [00:16:00]
“The ancient world had a whole faculty and term for nous and noesis, and that was all lost with the loss of our Neoplatonic heritage. - John Vervaeke [00:16:18]
We have a transrational faculty that is also proactive, that is not receptive, and thats intention. It’s really challenging for people to understand in our cultural framework because we very quickly confuse intention with a goal. - Vivian Dittmar [00:57:43]
Chapters
[00:00:00] - Introduction and Overview of the Poly Crisis and Emotional Intelligence
[00:04:00] - Differentiating Sensations, Emotions, and Consciousness
[00:11:13] - Pre-rational, Rational, and Transrational Distinctions
[00:25:00] - Intuition, Inspiration, and Transrational Wisdom
[00:38:45] - Heart Intelligence
[00:47:50] - Reevaluating Rationality and Embracing Intuitive Integration for Decision-Making
[00:56:17] - Intention and Shaping Agency in Transrational Knowing
[01:03:40] - Bridging Phenomenology, Transrational, and Transpersonal Dialogues Exploring the Transrational: A Journey into the Realms of Consciousness with Vivian Dittmar](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/KSObTcQ6_Bg/mqdefault.jpg)
