4E Cognition Meets Ecological Dynamics (with Rafe Kelley & Rob Gray) @johnvervaeke
4E Cognition Meets Ecological Dynamics (with Rafe Kelley & Rob Gray)  @johnvervaeke
Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Why have two research traditions built on J.J. Gibson, 4E cognitive science and ecological dynamics, barely spoken to each other, and what happens to skill, emotion, and meaning when they finally do?

In this Lectern conversation, Rafe Kelley leads a long-awaited dialogue between John Vervaeke and Rob Gray, who studies how people learn and adapt skills in baseball, other sports, and police training. Rafe frames the puzzle: both men are deeply rooted in Gibson, yet 4E cognitive science and ecological dynamics in motor learning have stayed largely siloed. Rob explains how the 4P model of knowing reached him through police-training colleague Pete Blair, and why it helps explain where cognition fits in an ecological approach, especially when officers must later explain their decisions. John argues that relevance realization comes before representation, that participatory and perspectival knowing are not representational, and proposes a fifth E, exaptation, in which sensorimotor processes are repurposed to move through abstract and affective space.

The conversation then turns from how skills are learned to why practice matters for a meaningful life. Rafe recalls John's challenge, “Where are the practices?”, and argues that physical practice like parkour grounds an embodied way of knowing whether we are getting better. John asks whether skill training can cultivate virtue, and Rob points to identity and to police work built around community-connected officers. Rafe proposes a sixth E, emotion, drawing on play research; Rob describes hot versus cold practice and helping athletes reframe pressure as challenge instead of suppressing it. In the final stretch, Rafe brings in Nikolai Bernstein and the degrees of freedom problem, and John explains why he does not think robots are embodied the way living organisms are.

Rafe Kelley is a movement teacher and parkour practitioner whose work focuses on embodied practice, play, and how physical practice contributes to meaning in life. He runs the Return to the Source intensive, and in this episode he leads the conversation as the bridge between the two traditions.

Rob Gray is a professor at Arizona State University who studies how people learn, acquire, and adapt skills. He applies an ecological dynamics, embodied approach to skill development in baseball, other sports, and police training.

John Vervaeke is a cognitive scientist and philosopher whose work explores cognition, meaning, wisdom, and the meaning crisis. In this conversation, he brings relevance realization, the 4P model of knowing, and his proposed fifth E, exaptation, to bear on skill, emotion, and embodiment.

John Vervaeke’s Web - johnvervaeke.com
Emerging Cognition - Rob Gray: amazon.com/s?k=Rob+Gray+Emerging+Cognition
Dynamics in Action - Alicia Juarrero: amazon.com/s?k=Alicia+Juarrero+Dynamics+in+Action
Descartes’ Error - Antonio Damasio: amazon.com/s?k=Antonio+Damasio+Descartes+Error
The Rediscovery of the Mind - John Searle: amazon.com/s?k=John+Searle+The+Rediscovery+of+the+Mind

00:00 Cold open: “Where are the practices?”
00:55 Welcome: Rafe takes the lead
01:30 Two traditions rooted in J.J. Gibson
03:40 Rob Gray on skill and police training
07:05 Why are 4E and ecological dynamics siloed?
11:40 The perspectival P and identity
13:05 Is 4E representational?
15:50 Relevance realization before representation
22:30 A fifth E: exaptation
25:40 Insight in finger and eye movements
27:20 What is natural language?
31:55 Meaning and Return to the Source
34:40 “Where are the practices?”
35:23 “Don't tell me, don't tell me what you believe. Tell me what you practice.”
38:20 Martial arts and the pendulum swing
42:50 A sixth E: emotion and play
45:00 Hot practice vs. cold practice
46:20 Reason and emotion are not enemies
51:00 Reframing pressure, not suppressing it
54:20 Bernstein and a seventh E
59:50 Dexterity and participatory knowing
01:01:40 Why robots aren’t embodied
01:03:40 Bernstein’s degrees of freedom
01:06:35 Closing reflections

Explore courses and teachings from The Lectern
lectern.johnvervaeke.com

Support the Lectern and join a growing community of wisdom seekers
patreon.com/johnvervaeke

Ideas, People, and Works Mentioned in this Episode
J.J. Gibson
Nikolai Bernstein
Alicia Juarrero
Evan Thompson
Julian Kiverstein
Anthony Chemero
John Searle
Hubert Dreyfus
Barbara Tversky
Antonio Damasio
Barbara Fredrickson
Jaak Panksepp
Pete Blair

Follow John Vervaeke:
Website - johnvervaeke.com
Twitter - https://x.com/DrJohnVervaeke
YouTube - youtube.com/@johnvervaeke/videos
Patreon - patreon.com/johnvervaeke

Thank you for watching!
4E Cognition Meets Ecological Dynamics (with Rafe Kelley & Rob Gray)Exploring Emotions and Transrational Wisdom with Vivian DittmarNew Course on The Lectern | Realizing the Imaginal: The Cognitive Science of the ImaginationIs Your Brain Built to Mislead You? The Science of Happiness with Mark MillerThe Difference Between a Tourist, an Explorer, and a PilgrimThe Journey to Philosophical Wisdom | Philosophy of Meditation #1 with Rick RepettiDynamics of Modern Paradigm Shifts with Jordan HallIntegrating Science and Contemplative Practice | Philosophy of Meditation #7 with Mark MillerHow Nonbeing Haunts Being: Corey Anton on Death, Spirituality, and the Meaning of a Finite LifeRealizing the Imaginal Public Q&A LIVEExploring the Transrational: A Journey into the Realms of Consciousness with Vivian DittmarJohn Vervaeke: William Desmond on God | ENROLMENT OPEN
John Vervaeke’s Lectern |

4E Cognition Meets Ecological Dynamics (with Rafe Kelley & Rob Gray)

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER