Uploaded December 2025 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
This is my 2019 interview with historian Dan Vogel. He breaks down the complex history of the Book of Abraham, beginning with the 1835 purchase of Egyptian mummies in Kirtland, Ohio. Rather than seeing the Kirtland Egyptian Papers as a failed attempt by scribes to understand Egyptian, Vogel argues they were Joseph Smith’s own working papers. He demonstrates how Smith used these documents to "brainstorm" a new theological framework, allowing him to introduce doctrines like the priesthood ban and the plurality of gods under the guise of an ancient text.
Check out this playlist for more info on this topic! youtube.com/watch?v=uPPqFGMrO7M&list=PLLhI8GMw9sJ4oHJTj4BYhTGw3m3r7E2fY
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Buy a PRINTED TRANSCRIPT of this interview: amazon.com/Gospel-Tangents-Interview
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
SUBSCRIBE to the Gospel Tangents YouTube Channel for non-confrontational interviews on topics like polygamy, the race and priesthood ban, Heartland or Mesoamerican Book of Mormon Geography, the Hofmann bombings and forgeries, women and priesthood, Joseph Smith, Brigham Young, and much, much more:
youtube.com/channel/UC4clkuJcpGygxprWuwa5SVA/join
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Gospel Tangents NEWSLETTER: gospeltangents.com/newsletter
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Love it? Please DONATE to support our work: gospeltangents.com/product/donate-1
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
CHAPTERS
0:00 – Arrival of Michael Chandler & Mummies
7:00 – Identifying the Scrolls: Horus and Ta-Sherit-Min
15:00 – The Kirtland Egyptian Papers: Alphabet and Grammar24:00 – Evidence of Oral Dictation
35:00 – Damaged Scrolls and Invented Characters
48:00 – Theology of Planets and Priesthood
55:00 – Critiquing the "Long Scroll" & "Reverse Engineering" Theories
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
WEBSITE: gospeltangents.com
FACEBOOK: facebook.com/gospeltangents
PATREON: patreon.com/gospeltangents
iTUNES: tinyurl.com/gospeltangents
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Gospel Tangents is the best source for Mormon history, science, and theology.
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Copyright © 2025, Gospel Tangents. All rights reserved.
Historian Dan Vogel breaks down the complex history of the Book of Abraham, beginning with the 1835 purchase of Egyptian mummies in Kirtland, Ohio. Rather than seeing the Kirtland Egyptian Papers as a failed attempt by scribes to understand Egyptian, Vogel argues they were Joseph Smith’s own working papers. He demonstrates how Smith used these documents to "brainstorm" a new theological framework, allowing him to introduce doctrines like the priesthood ban and the plurality of gods under the guise of an ancient text.
Vogel provides compelling evidence for oral dictation, noting that scribes often misspelled Egyptian names based on the phonetic sounds of Smith’s New England accent. He also tackles the physical state of the scrolls, explaining that Smith filled in missing gaps on damaged papyri with invented characters. This interview challenges the "Long Scroll Theory" by showing that the characters found in the translation manuscripts match the surviving fragments currently held by the Church. It is a fascinating look at how Joseph Smith transitioned from "money digger" to a prophet who could project his 19th-century priesthood concerns onto the stars.
This is my 2019 interview with historian Dan Vogel. He breaks down the complex history of the Book of Abraham, beginning with the 1835 purchase of Egyptian mummies in Kirtland, Ohio. Rather than seeing the Kirtland Egyptian Papers as a failed attempt by scribes to understand Egyptian, Vogel argues they were Joseph Smith’s own working papers. He demonstrates how Smith used these documents to "brainstorm" a new theological framework, allowing him to introduce doctrines like the priesthood ban and the plurality of gods under the guise of an ancient text.
Check out this playlist for more info on this topic! youtube.com/watch?v=uPPqFGMrO7M&list=PLLhI8GMw9sJ4oHJTj4BYhTGw3m3r7E2fY
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Buy a PRINTED TRANSCRIPT of this interview: amazon.com/Gospel-Tangents-Interview
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
SUBSCRIBE to the Gospel Tangents YouTube Channel for non-confrontational interviews on topics like polygamy, the race and priesthood ban, Heartland or Mesoamerican Book of Mormon Geography, the Hofmann bombings and forgeries, women and priesthood, Joseph Smith, Brigham Young, and much, much more:
youtube.com/channel/UC4clkuJcpGygxprWuwa5SVA/join
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Gospel Tangents NEWSLETTER: gospeltangents.com/newsletter
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Love it? Please DONATE to support our work: gospeltangents.com/product/donate-1
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
CHAPTERS
0:00 – Arrival of Michael Chandler & Mummies
7:00 – Identifying the Scrolls: Horus and Ta-Sherit-Min
15:00 – The Kirtland Egyptian Papers: Alphabet and Grammar24:00 – Evidence of Oral Dictation
35:00 – Damaged Scrolls and Invented Characters
48:00 – Theology of Planets and Priesthood
55:00 – Critiquing the "Long Scroll" & "Reverse Engineering" Theories
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
WEBSITE: gospeltangents.com
FACEBOOK: facebook.com/gospeltangents
PATREON: patreon.com/gospeltangents
iTUNES: tinyurl.com/gospeltangents
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Gospel Tangents is the best source for Mormon history, science, and theology.
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Copyright © 2025, Gospel Tangents. All rights reserved.
Historian Dan Vogel breaks down the complex history of the Book of Abraham, beginning with the 1835 purchase of Egyptian mummies in Kirtland, Ohio. Rather than seeing the Kirtland Egyptian Papers as a failed attempt by scribes to understand Egyptian, Vogel argues they were Joseph Smith’s own working papers. He demonstrates how Smith used these documents to "brainstorm" a new theological framework, allowing him to introduce doctrines like the priesthood ban and the plurality of gods under the guise of an ancient text.
Vogel provides compelling evidence for oral dictation, noting that scribes often misspelled Egyptian names based on the phonetic sounds of Smith’s New England accent. He also tackles the physical state of the scrolls, explaining that Smith filled in missing gaps on damaged papyri with invented characters. This interview challenges the "Long Scroll Theory" by showing that the characters found in the translation manuscripts match the surviving fragments currently held by the Church. It is a fascinating look at how Joseph Smith transitioned from "money digger" to a prophet who could project his 19th-century priesthood concerns onto the stars.










