1113: Pious Fraud or Inspired Prophet? (Dan Vogel) @GospelTangents
1113: Pious Fraud or Inspired Prophet? (Dan Vogel)  @GospelTangents
Uploaded December 2025 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Historian Dan Vogel offers a deep dive into the historical developments of early Mormonism, challenging both critics and believers to look closer at the documents. What if Joseph Smith was neither a simple con man nor a traditional prophet, but something more complex?

Check out this playlist for more info on this topic! youtube.com/watch?v=uPPqFGMrO7M&list=PLLhI8GMw9sJ4oHJTj4BYhTGw3m3r7E2fY
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Buy a PRINTED TRANSCRIPT of this interview: amazon.com/Gospel-Tangents-Interview
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
SUBSCRIBE to the Gospel Tangents YouTube Channel for non-confrontational interviews on topics like polygamy, the race and priesthood ban, Heartland or Mesoamerican Book of Mormon Geography, the Hofmann bombings and forgeries, women and priesthood, Joseph Smith, Brigham Young, and much, much more:
youtube.com/channel/UC4clkuJcpGygxprWuwa5SVA/join
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Gospel Tangents NEWSLETTER: gospeltangents.com/newsletter
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Love it? Please DONATE to support our work: gospeltangents.com/product/donate-1
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
CHAPTERS
0:00 - Intro to Dan Vogel & his Background
22:00 – "Pious Fraud" and Inspired Pseudepigrapha
36:00 – Comparing the First Vision Accounts (1832 vs. 1838)
51:00 – Restoration of Priesthood and Authority
1:10:00 – Theological Shifts: From Modalism to the Godhead
1:30:00 – Autobiographical Parallels in the Book of Mormon
1:50:00 – Anachronisms and the 1820 Revival
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
WEBSITE: gospeltangents.com
FACEBOOK: facebook.com/gospeltangents
PATREON: patreon.com/gospeltangents
iTUNES: tinyurl.com/gospeltangents
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Gospel Tangents is the best source for Mormon history, science, and theology.
-----------------------------------------------//-----------------------------------------------
Copyright © 2025, Gospel Tangents. All rights reserved.

Vogel describes himself as a "moderate" critic who seeks the most charitable view of Joseph Smith that a non-believer can hold. He proposes the theory of "pious fraud," viewing Smith as an "inspired pseudepigraphist". In this framework, Smith believed he was genuinely called by God to teach true doctrine but used intentional deception—such as the physical gold plates—to provide "evidence" that would make it harder for others to reject his message.
Vogel compares this to a faith healer who uses suggestion or minor "tricks" to raise an audience's faith level so that they are prepared to receive what they believe are real miracles. For Smith, the "greater good" was the salvation of his followers and the conversion of his own family.
Evolution of the First Vision
One of the most significant points of Vogel’s research is the evolution of the First Vision narrative. He highlights that the earliest recorded account from 1832 is markedly different from the canonized 1838 version.
• The 1832 Account: This version mentions only one personage (Jesus) and focuses on Smith’s personal remission of sins. There is no mention of a revival or a command to stay away from all churches; rather, Smith had already concluded the churches were wrong by the age of 12.
• The 1838 Account: This version, written during a time of intense persecution in Missouri, includes the 1820 revival and a mandate that all other creeds were an "abomination".
Vogel argues that the 1820 date for the revival is anachronistic, noting that historical records place the great Palmyra revival in 1824–25. He suggests Smith moved the event back in his history to transform a personal "born-again" experience into a foundational event for the entire Church.
Priesthood and the "Chain of Ordinations"
Angelic ordinations were likely a later development. Vogel asserts that early on, authority was understood as a direct command from God through a seer stone or revelation, rather than the laying on of hands by angels. It wasn't until around 1834–35 that detailed stories of John the Baptist and Peter, James, and John appeared in the records. Vogel posits these stories were introduced to solidify Joseph Smith’s authority against internal challengers and to create a formal "chain of ordinations" that was harder to break.
Theological Shifts: From One God to Three
Vogel tracks a clear evolution in Smith's theology regarding the nature of God:
1. Modalism: The Book of Mormon reflects a view where Jesus is both the Father and the Son.
1113: Pious Fraud or Inspired Prophet? (Dan Vogel)954: Are Clayton Journals Reliable? (Clair Barrus 4 of 4)1096: Apostle, Microfilm, & Fake Diary: Sandra Tanner’s Quest for Hidden History (4 of 5)1062: Were Gold Plates Real? (John Turner 3 of 6)1131: How a Tiny Church Battled for the Temple Lot (R Jean Addams)GT Live with Jim Bennett tonight!v204: Remembering David Nielsen of Nielsen-Naylor Group1178a: Non-LDS Temple Q&A (Rick B 4 of 4)1074: Tour of Beaver Island (2 of 3)1049: What Does Peggy Think? (Peggy Fletcher Flack 4 of 4)1192: Why Cleon Skousen’s Nephew Got in Trouble at BYU (Mark Skousen 1 of 4)1165: Vegas Surprises & Historical Deep Dives: Recap of Mormon History Association Conference 2026
Gospel Tangents |

1113: Pious Fraud or Inspired Prophet? (Dan Vogel)

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER