CHUCK BRONSON#baitcar #caughtoncamera #lawsuit CHUCK BRONSON FIGHTING FOR YOUR RIGHTS BRINGING YOU THE VIDEOS YOU REALLY WANT TO SEE
CHUCK BRONSON'S BAITCARS FOR SOME REASON DIRTY COPS ALWAYS TAKE THE BAIT WHEN CHUCK BRONSON GOES OUT OF HIS WAY TO FOLLOW ALL LAWS DIRTY COPS CAN'T RESIST FOLLOWING AND MAKING UP LIES TO TRY AND BRING THIS GUY DOWN WHEN HIS ONLY DEMAND IS THAT THE COPS FOLLOW THE LAW THEMSELVES AND TREAT PEOPLE FAIR. IT NEVER FAILS WHEN SOME COP OR COPS DECIDE TO MAKE THEMSELVES LOOK SILLY AND GET EXPOSED FOR THEIR WRONG DOINGS.
LAFAYETTE POLICE DEPARTMENT 765-807-1200
BEST DASHCAM TO PROTECT YOURSELF AND YOUR FAMILY amzn.to/3qonTYs
(DONATE HERE) TALK TO SPEECH TTS LINK streamlabs.com/yournewsnow EMAIL chuckbronson55@gmail.com FOR EDUCATIONAL AND NEWS PUPOSES ONLY FAIR USE NOTICE This video may contain copyrighted material; the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available for the purposes of criticism, comment, review and news reporting which constitute the fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. Not withstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work for purposes such as criticism, comment, review and news reporting is not an infringement of copyright.
BAITCAR CATCHES MORE DIRTY COPS THAN EVER BEFORE 4.4 MILLION DOLLAR LAWSUIT FILED AGAINST 7 COPSCHUCK BRONSON2023-07-21 | #baitcar #caughtoncamera #lawsuit CHUCK BRONSON FIGHTING FOR YOUR RIGHTS BRINGING YOU THE VIDEOS YOU REALLY WANT TO SEE
CHUCK BRONSON'S BAITCARS FOR SOME REASON DIRTY COPS ALWAYS TAKE THE BAIT WHEN CHUCK BRONSON GOES OUT OF HIS WAY TO FOLLOW ALL LAWS DIRTY COPS CAN'T RESIST FOLLOWING AND MAKING UP LIES TO TRY AND BRING THIS GUY DOWN WHEN HIS ONLY DEMAND IS THAT THE COPS FOLLOW THE LAW THEMSELVES AND TREAT PEOPLE FAIR. IT NEVER FAILS WHEN SOME COP OR COPS DECIDE TO MAKE THEMSELVES LOOK SILLY AND GET EXPOSED FOR THEIR WRONG DOINGS.
LAFAYETTE POLICE DEPARTMENT 765-807-1200
BEST DASHCAM TO PROTECT YOURSELF AND YOUR FAMILY amzn.to/3qonTYs
(DONATE HERE) TALK TO SPEECH TTS LINK streamlabs.com/yournewsnow EMAIL chuckbronson55@gmail.com FOR EDUCATIONAL AND NEWS PUPOSES ONLY FAIR USE NOTICE This video may contain copyrighted material; the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available for the purposes of criticism, comment, review and news reporting which constitute the fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. Not withstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work for purposes such as criticism, comment, review and news reporting is not an infringement of copyright.ANOTHER MAN GETS HIS RIGHTS VIOLATED BY THE COPS WITH NO BODYCAMS OR DASHCAMSCHUCK BRONSON2023-09-28 | #copslive
CHUCK BRONSON KICK.COM
kick.com/chuckbronsonCOP ENDANGERS GIRLS LIFE TO GET PROMOTED OFFICER SAFETY IS ABOVE PUBLIC SAFETYCHUCK BRONSON2023-09-25 | #bodycamera #2girls1cop #dui
CHUCK BRONSON FIGHTING FOR YOUR RIGHTS BRINGING YOU THE VIDEOS YOU REALLY WANT TO SEE
(DONATE HERE) TALK TO SPEECH TTS LINK streamlabs.com/yournewsnow EMAIL chuckbronson55@gmail.com FOR EDUCATIONAL AND NEWS PUPOSES ONLY FAIR USE NOTICE This video may contain copyrighted material; the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available for the purposes of criticism, comment, review and news reporting which constitute the fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. Not withstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work for purposes such as criticism, comment, review and news reporting is not an infringement of copyright.CHARLOTTE COUNTY SHERIFF VIOLATING EVERYONES RIGHTS IN SIGHT COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA v. BARRCHUCK BRONSON2023-08-20 | THESE DEPUTIES USED THE SMELL AS PROBABLE CAUSE TO PULL THIS CAR OVER AND SEARCH WITH OUT A WARRANT WHILE CONTINUING TO BLOCK THE CAMERA WHILE ATTEMPTING TO BROADCAST INFO TO THE PUBLIC.
CHUCK BRONSON KICK.COM
kick.com/chuckbronsonITS THE COPSCHUCK BRONSON2023-08-19 | This stream is created with #PRISMLiveStudioITS THE COPSCHUCK BRONSON2023-08-19 | This stream is created with #PRISMLiveStudioBAITCAR CATCHING DIRTY COPS COMMITING FELONIESCHUCK BRONSON2023-08-17 | #cops #baitcar #subscribe
This is a follow up video to the Full Video Part 1 with more videos to come this video shows 2 men targeted by dirty cops who retaliate for exposing their corruption by recording them the first 3 cops thought they could get away with it until they got scared and had to call for back up after unlawfully pulling a car over and making up lies they end up having to lie on the police report to cover up for their lies then issue a false warrant without a judges signature for CHUCK BRONSON'S arrest all out of RETALIATION for getting caught and exposed by CHUCK BRONSON and his Bait car. Then Chuck Gets Pulled Over Again For Having A Warrant That Doesn't Really Exist Lawfully. A Baitcar Is A Car That Is Driven Around During Normal Use To Work To The Store Running Erands Normal Use and The Driver Always Goes Out Of His Way To Follow All Laws But For Some Reason Dirty Cops Always Take The Bait and Make Up Lies and Pull It Over Then They Get Exposed. Often They Will Return To Retaliate Because Thats What Dirty Cops Do.
FOR EDUCATIONAL AND NEWS PUPOSES ONLY FAIR USE NOTICE This video may contain copyrighted material; the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available for the purposes of criticism, comment, review and news reporting which constitute the fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. Not withstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work for purposes such as criticism, comment, review and news reporting is not an infringement of copyright.SETTING UP DIRTY COPS BY FOLLOWING ALL LAWSCHUCK BRONSON2023-04-29 | #baitcar #caughtoncamera #youtube
CHUCK BRONSONS BAITCAR CATCHES ANOTHER COP SLIPPING
CHUCK BRONSON FIGHTING FOR YOUR RIGHTS BRINGING YOU THE VIDEOS YOU REALLY WANT TO SEE
(DONATE HERE) TALK TO SPEECH TTS LINK streamlabs.com/yournewsnow EMAIL chuckbronson55@gmail.com FOR EDUCATIONAL AND NEWS PUPOSES ONLY FAIR USE NOTICE This video may contain copyrighted material; the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available for the purposes of criticism, comment, review and news reporting which constitute the fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. Not withstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work for purposes such as criticism, comment, review and news reporting is not an infringement of copyright.BAITCAR STRIKES AGAIN EXPOSING DIRTY COPSCHUCK BRONSON2023-04-14 | #cops #baitcar #subscribe CHUCK BRONSON FIGHTING FOR YOUR RIGHTS BRINGING YOU THE VIDEOS YOU REALLY WANT TO SEE
(DONATE HERE) TALK TO SPEECH TTS LINK streamlabs.com/yournewsnow EMAIL chuckbronson55@gmail.com FOR EDUCATIONAL AND NEWS PUPOSES ONLY FAIR USE NOTICE This video may contain copyrighted material; the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available for the purposes of criticism, comment, review and news reporting which constitute the fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. Not withstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work for purposes such as criticism, comment, review and news reporting is not an infringement of copyright.DIRTY COP GETS CAUGHT THEN TRIES TO GET ANOTHER COP TO TURN CAMERA OFF (FULL VIDEO)CHUCK BRONSON2023-03-21 | #caughtoncamera #bodycam #dirty
OKLAHOMA CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT CAPTAIN DUI ARREST FULL VIDEO BOTH BODYCAM AND DASHCAM
JAMES MATTHEW FRENCH WAS CAUGHT RED HANDED BY AN OKLAHOMA CITY COP THAT REFUSED TO TURN OFF HIS BODY CAMERA AT FIRST BUT THEN HE DOES TO HELP HIS BROTHER IN BLUE.COPS REFUSE TO ARREST ONE OF THEIR OWN FORT MYERS FLORIDACHUCK BRONSON2023-03-04 | #piggy #pig #viralhogHOW MANY TIMES CAN U CRASH IN 9 SECONDSCHUCK BRONSON2023-02-23 | #crash #shorts #drunk Down Town Fort Myers FloridaNASTY OFFICER SALAZAR SNOT ROCKETS ON SIDEWALK DURING TRAFFIC STOP #snotrocket #shortsCHUCK BRONSON2023-02-20 | ...GANG OF TYRANT COPS GET OWNED EXPOSING DIRTY COPS OFFICER SAFETY V. PUBLIC SAFETYCHUCK BRONSON2023-02-17 | #bluelivesmurder #owned #badcopPROOF NOTHING GOOD COMES FROM CALLING THE COPSCHUCK BRONSON2023-02-13 | #4thamendment #right #tyrannyCOP PULLS OVER OFF DUTY COP FOR SPEEDING INSTANTLY TURNS OFF BODYCAMCHUCK BRONSON2023-02-04 | Cop Pulls Over Cop For Speeding Then Kills BodyCam As soon As He Sees who it is.IS HE ALLOWED TO KAREN #karen #legal #DarenCHUCK BRONSON2023-02-02 | ...2 WALKS OF SHAME IN LESS THAN 1 MINUTE #walkofshameCHUCK BRONSON2023-02-01 | Edited by YouCut:https://youcutapp.page.link/BestEditorWALK OF SHAME #copwatch #filmthepolice #copsCHUCK BRONSON2023-01-31 | ...IF YOU DONT GIVE ME YOUR I.D. YOU ARE GOING TO JAIL PASSENGERS FORCED TO I.D. PANAMA CITY BEACH, FLCHUCK BRONSON2023-01-20 | #id #youtube #subscribe CHUCK BRONSON FIGHTING FOR YOUR RIGHTS BRINGING YOU THE VIDEOS YOU REALLY WANT TO SEE
(DONATE HERE) TALK TO SPEECH TTS LINK streamlabs.com/yournewsnow EMAIL chuckbronson55@gmail.com FOR EDUCATIONAL AND NEWS PUPOSES ONLY FAIR USE NOTICE This video may contain copyrighted material; the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available for the purposes of criticism, comment, review and news reporting which constitute the fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. Not withstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work for purposes such as criticism, comment, review and news reporting is not an infringement of copyright.BAITCAR STOPPED AT UNLAWFUL I.D. CHECKPOINT CHUCK BRONSON PULLED FROM CAR ANDERSON SOUTH CAROLINACHUCK BRONSON2023-01-13 | #baitcar #checkpoint #illegalWOULD U RIDE THIS?CHUCK BRONSON2023-01-11 | #shortsTHESE COPS GET DISMISSED REAL QUICKCHUCK BRONSON2022-12-20 | #unlawful #detained #dismissed MOUNT PLEASANT NY COPS GET CAUGHT RUNNING PLATES FOR PERSONAL REASONSCOPS GET OWNEDCHUCK BRONSON2022-12-18 | #cops #1stamendment #shortsARE WE BEING DETAINEDCHUCK BRONSON2022-12-17 | ...I WILL SUE UCHUCK BRONSON2022-12-16 | ...HOW DO U WALK AWAY #wowCHUCK BRONSON2022-12-16 | #shorts #crash 2 men walk away from a scary momentLADY REFUSES TO TAKE MY MONEYCHUCK BRONSON2022-12-15 | #pennies #coin #coincounterCHIC WANTS MY PICCHUCK BRONSON2022-12-14 | #picoftheday #camback #picturePAYING PARKING TICKET IN PENNIESCHUCK BRONSON2022-12-14 | #ticket #parking #ticketsI WILL ILLEGALLY SIEZE YOUR PHONECHUCK BRONSON2022-12-12 | #4thamendment #oathtraitor #rightviolatorWATCH MY FINGER #cops #copwatch #filmthepoliceCHUCK BRONSON2022-12-09 | #cops #dui #sheriffKODAK BLACK FORCED TO LICK BOOTS DUE TO HIS FEDERAL RELEASE AGREEMENTCHUCK BRONSON2022-12-08 | #kodak #browardcounty #kodakblack
Full Video of Kodak Black's Trip to the Market to buy a toothbrush but runs into a major turn of events. Broward County sheriff Department Follows Kodak From Where Hes Staying Then Pulls Him Over Acting like He had No idea who he was.KODAK BLACK LICKIN BOOTSCHUCK BRONSON2022-12-07 | #kodakblack #kodak #viral
FULL VIDEO youtu.be/Dls8CUL6-G8COPS OWNED LIKE NEVER SEEN BEFORECHUCK BRONSON2022-12-06 | #owned #ftp #copwatchBAITCAR EXPOSING DIRTY COPSCHUCK BRONSON2022-12-01 | #baitcar #ftp #copwatchBAITCAR CATCHING COPS LIECHUCK BRONSON2022-11-29 | #baitcar #cops #shortEXPOSING DIRTY COPSCHUCK BRONSON2022-11-27 | #baitcar #shortCAN I SEARCH YOUR CAR? HELL NOCHUCK BRONSON2022-11-24 | #short #baitcarTYPICALLY OUR DEPUTIES DONT LIECHUCK BRONSON2022-11-24 | #copslie #liar #cops A COP CLAIMING HIS DEPUTIES DONT LIE LOLFRANK GALLAGHER BECAME A COP ITS SHAMELESSCHUCK BRONSON2022-11-23 | #shorts #shameless #short DIRTY COPS RETALIATE TRYING TO TRESPASS ME FROM A COUNTY OWNED PARKING LOT FOR NOT COMMITING A CRIME BECAUSE I WAS LIVE STREAMING SHOWING AN ON DUTY COP PLAYING ON SOCIAL MEDIA FOR 30 MIN SO INDEPTH SHE HAD NO IDEA I WAS STANDING RIGHT NEXT TO HER.CRIMINAL COPSCHUCK BRONSON2022-11-23 | #filmthepolice #copwatch #ftp when cops cant follow their own policies its a sign that they think they are above the law, and nothing good comes from a cop that thinks hes above the law. MIAMI PD POLICY 11.6.48.1 AND 11.6.48.2 TOBACCO USE IS NOT ALLOWEDTHE COPS ARE PEEPING THROUGH YOUR WINDOWS AND HIDING IN THE DARKCHUCK BRONSON2022-11-22 | #creepy #cops #creeperCOP FAILS OFFICER SAFETY TESTCHUCK BRONSON2022-11-06 | #fail #officersafety #fortmyers TESTING COPS ABILITY TO PROPERLY PERFORM THEIR DUTIES AS A PUBLIC SERVANT OFFICER SAFETY IS THEIR GO TO EXCUSE FOR EVERYTHING. FORT MYERS PD FAILS AGAIN BUT IM NOT REALLY SUPRISED.TYRANT COP GOES CRAZY TRIES MAKING UP LAWS BECAUSE HE CANT DO ANYTHING ELSE MIS USE OF AUTHORITYCHUCK BRONSON2022-10-28 | #tyrant #retaliation #misuseofauthority #trespassing
FORT MYERS POLICE DEPARTMENT OFFICERS LOOSE ALL CONTROL OVER A MAN LEGALLY RECORDING ON PUBLIC PROPERTY AND GO OUT OF THEIR WAY TO MIS USE THEIR AUTHORITY AND VIOLATE THE MANS RIGHTS OUT OF RETALIATION BECAUSE MAN CATCHES ONE COP HANGING OUT ON SOCIAL MEDIA WHILE ON THE CLOCK, ALL WHILE EXPOSING THEIR OWN CORRUPTION TO THE WORLD TRYING TO COVER UP FOR THE COP THAT GOT CAUGHT. THIS IS AFTER RECEIVING YEARS OF TRAINING ON THE FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS OF PEOPLE RECORDING IN PUBLIC. THIS DEPARTMENT AND ITS OFFICERS CONTINUE TO FAIL TO FOLLOW THE LAW THEMSELVES AND CONTINUES TO VIOLATE CITIZENS CONTITUTION RIGHTS EVERY DAY OF THE WEEK.BAIT CAR STRIKES AGAIN EXPOSING COPS THE RIGHTS AND WRONGSCHUCK BRONSON2022-10-21 | #baitcar #police #publicservices
@COPCRITIC @CHUCKBRONSONPAYING PARKING TICKET IN PENNIES KAREN FREAKS OUT AND HIDES CAMBACK KAREN EXERCISES HER RIGHTSCHUCK BRONSON2022-09-16 | #karen #publicfreakout #payinginpennies
KAREN REFUSES TO TAKE MY PAYMENT IN PENNIES FOR A PARKING TICKET FORT MYERS FLORIDA SHE TATTLE TELLS ON ME TO HER BOSS AND HE SAYS JUST PUT THEM IN THE CHANGE COUNTER. THIS WAS A VERY STRANGE ENCOUNTER WHEN THIS IS IN HER JOB DESCRIPTION.SETTING UP COPS COP LIES UNDER OATH GETS CAUGHT JUDGE COVERS IT UP SMALL TOWN CORRUPTION FORT MYERSCHUCK BRONSON2022-07-02 | #baitcar #badjudge #oathbroken
THE BAIT CAR IS BACK CHUCK BRONSON'S BAIT CAR IS OUT ON PATROL IN A TOWN NEAR YOU SETTING UP DIRTY COPS BY FOLLOWING ALL LAWS CODES AND ORDINANCES BUT THE COPS CANT HELP THEMSELVES TO NOT BE CORRUPT AND RETALIATE
Sgt. FRANKIE POOSER LEE COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT LEE COUNTY FLORIDABAIT CAR CATCHES DUMBEST COPS EVER COPS DONT LIE CAPE CORAL POLICE DEPARTMENT FOLLOW UP VIDEOCHUCK BRONSON2022-06-17 | #baitcar #copslie #dashcam
CAPE CORAL POLICE DEPARTMENT KELSEY MEADOWS 239-574-3223 HER BADGE #1715 HER I.D. #3333
ONE NIGHT I WAS TRAVELING DOWN THE ROAD WHEN A CAPE CORAL COP RACED FROM OVER A MILE AWAY TO CATCH UP WITH ME. AS I WAS APPROACHING AN INTERSECTION, THE LIGHT TURNED YELLOW. NO ONE WANTS TO RUN A RED LIGHT IN FRONT OF AN OFFICER, SO I STOPPED AT THE LIGHT. CONSEQUENTLY, THE COP CHANGED LANES FROM THE ADJACENT LANE TO GET BEHIND ME AT THAT MOMENT. BECAUSE OF HER NEGLIGENCE IN WATCHING THE ROAD AND WAS RATHER, LOOKING AT A DEVICE TO RUN MY PLATE WITH NO PROBABLE CAUSE, SHE HAD TO SLAM HER BRAKES TO PREVENT REARENDING ME. IN THE VIDEO, YOU CAN HEAR HER TIRES SQUEAL.
DUE TO HER INABILITY TO ADMIT HER MISTAKE, SHE DECIDED THAT I DESERVED A $163 TICKET AND THREE POINTS ON MY LICENSE FOR STOPPING AT A RED LIGHT. THE ACTUAL TICKET WAS FOR STOPPING PAST THE STOP LINE. AGAIN, IN THE VIDEO, YOU CAN SEE HOW I HAD TO ROLL FORWARD TO AVOID HER REARENDING ME. YOU CAN SEE WHERE HER CAR STOPPED AND THAT IT WOULD HAVE HIT ME, HAD I NOT MOVED FORWARD.
THIS KIND OF BLATANT DISREGARD FOR CITIZENS AND THE TRUTH MAKE THIS REACTIONARY COP A DANGER TO THE PEOPLE. AS WE ALL HAVE A RIGHT TO REDRESS OUR GREIVANCES, I AM IN THE PROCESS OF DOING THIS CURRENTLY. STAY TUNED FOR FOLLOW UPS, AS THEY HAVE ALREADY BEGUN. CLICK THE LINKS BELOW TO SEE THE ORIGINAL AND UNEDITED LIVE STREAM OF THE TRAFFIC STOP AS WELL AS THE FIRST FOLLOW UP WHERE I GO TO THE CAPE CORAL POLICE DEPARTMENT TO REQUEST DASH AND BODY CAM FOOTAGE, AS WELL AS FROM THE STREET CAMERAS GIVING THE OVERHEAD PERSPECTIVE OF THE INTERSECTION. OH, AND I PAY FOR IT IN CHANGE. YOU KNOW WHY? BECAUSE WE NEED CHANGE! THE POLICE NEED TO BE ACCOUNTABLE TO THE PEOPLE, NOT TAX COLLECTORS.
FIRST EDIT WITH MY DASH CAMS AND LIVE STREAM youtu.be/ZWi56EWjjiABAIT CAR SETTING UP DIRTY COPS ALL THE EVIDENCE YOU HAVE BEEN ASKING FOR THE FOLLOW UP VIDEOCHUCK BRONSON2022-05-20 | #baitcar #dirtycops #settingupcops
CHUCK BRONSON'S BAIT CAR THE BAITCAR IS ANY NORMAL CAR SET UP WITH MULTIPLE CAMERAS, POLICE SCANNERS, COMPUTERS, GPS TRACKING AND MORE THAT WE CANT RELEASE. YOU MIGHT ASK WELL HOW DOES THAT BAIT THE COPS WELL ITS VERY SIMPLE ALL WE HAVE TO DO IS DRIVE AROUND DURING NORMAL LIFE AND BUSINESS FOLLOWING ALL LAWS, CODES, STATUTES, AND ORDINANCES, WEMAKE SURE EVERYTHING IS WORKING AND ALL PAPERWORK IS IN ORDER AND FOR SOME ODD REASON COPS ARE LIKE RATS AND A PEICE OF CHEESE THEY JUST CANNOT RESIST BUT TO MAKE UP LIES AND PULL PEOPLE OVER WHO ARE COMPLETELY INNOCENT OF ANY WRONG DOING PLEASE DONT ASK WHY BECAUSE I HONESTLY DONT HAVE THE ANSWER MAYBE YOU CAN TELL ME IN THE COMMENT BELOW. THANKYOU ALL WHO ENJOY THERE WILL BE MORE TO COME WITH CHUCK BRONSON'S BAIT CARS.
Houston v. Hill - 482 U.S. 451, 107 S. Ct. 2502 (1987)
RULE:
The First Amendment, U.S. Const. amend. I, protects a significant amount of verbal criticism and challenge directed at police officers. Speech is often provocative and challenging, but it is nevertheless protected against censorship or punishment, unless shown likely to produce a clear and present danger of a serious substantive evil that rises far above public inconvenience, annoyance, or unrest.
FACTS:
Raymond Hill, a gay rights activist who had been arrested on previous occasions for violating a city ordinance which made it unlawful to "assault, strike, or in any manner oppose, molest, abuse or interrupt" police officers in the execution of their duty, but who had never been convicted, was again arrested under the ordinance when, after officers had approached a friend of his, he attempted to divert their attention by shouting at them to pick on someone their own size. After he was acquitted on those charges by a municipal court, the activist brought an action against the city in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Texas, in which action he sought (1) a declaratory judgment that the ordinance was unconstitutional on its face and as applied to him, (2) an injunction against its enforcement, (3) an order expunging the records of his arrests under the ordinance, and (4) damages and attorneys' fees. The District Court held that the ordinance was not an overly broad intrusion on speech protected under the First Amendment and entered judgment in favor of the city. However, the District Court's judgment was reversed and remanded by the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, which ruled that the ordinance was unconstitutionally overbroad. The panel's decision was adhered to by the Court of Appeals en banc, in a decision which (1) noted evidence that the ordinance had been regarded by local authorities as penalizing the mere interruption of an officer acting in the line of duty, and (2) concluded that there was a substantial danger that the ordinance would be applied against constitutionally protected speech (789 F2d 1103).
ISSUE:
Is an ordinance that criminalizes constitutionally protected speech and vests excessive enforcement discretion with law enforcement officers unconstitutionally overbroad?
ANSWER:
Yes.
CONCLUSION:
The court disagreed with the City's characterization of the statute as criminal. It noted that the enforceable portion of the ordinance dealt not with core criminal conduct, but with speech. Additionally, the court noted that the First Amendment protected a significant amount of verbal criticism and challenge directed at police officers. The Houston ordinance criminalized a substantial amount of constitutionally protected speech and accorded the police unconstitutional discretion in enforcement. The court concluded that the ordinance was substantially overbroad, and that the lower court did not err in holding it facially invalid. With respect to abstention, the court noted that the municipal courts had construed the ordinance. The court also noted that since the question was whether the ordinance on its face was unconstitutional, abstention from federal jurisdiction was not required.