Why Catholicism is Wrong on Church History & Erick Ybarra Refuted Ubi Petrus 2020-05-23 | In this video we attempt to deconstruct the Catholic claims about Papal primacy in the first millennium Church while simultaneously aiming to prove the Orthodox position on ecclesiology in response to Erick Ybarra's video found here: (youtube.com/watch?v=_7o89kWxbGQ).Apologies for the "sped up" clips being quieter towards the end - this is the first video we have tried our hand at editing. Any critique is welcome.“Pope St. Leo’s Tome, Proof of Infallibility?” youtu.be/yh3-z8aLTV8“Papal Forgeries, A Road to Schism” youtu.be/n8jVL_0h3yo "All Bishops are Peter"ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020/01/24/all-bishops-are-successors-of-peter-florilegium"Does the Lateran Council of 649 Prove Papal Infallibility?" ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020/07/25/does-the-lateran-council-of-649-prove-papal-infallibility"Pope St. Boniface I and Papal Authority" ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020/06/13/pope-st-boniface-i-and-papal-authorityBibliography & Works Cited:Benedict, Pope, and Vittorio Messori. "The Ratzinger Report: An Exclusive Interview on the State of the Church." San Francisco, Ignatius Press, 1985.Booth, P., Cubitt, C., & Price, R. (2017). The Acts of the Lateran Synod of 649 TTH, LUP.Common Christological Declaration of Pope John Paul II and His Holiness Mar Dinkha IV, Catholicos-Patriarch of the Assyrian Church of the East. (1994, November 11). Https://Www.Vatican.va/Content/John-P.... Joint International Commission for the Theological Dialogue between the Orthodox Church and the Roman Catholique Church (2007, October 13). Https://Www.Ecupatria.Org/Documents/J.... Neil, B., & Allen, P. (2014). Pope Gelasius I, The Letters of Gelasius I (492–496): Micro-manager and Pastor of the Church of Rome (Adnotationes: Commentaries on Early Christian and Patristic Texts) (Bilingual ed.). Brepols Publishers.O’Connor, J. T. (2008). The Gift of Infallibility: The Official Relatio on Infallibility of Bishop Vincent Ferrer Gasser at Vatican Council I (First ed.). Ignatius Press.Price, R. (2012a&b). The Acts of the Council of Constantinople of 553: With Related Texts on the Three Chapters Controversy TTH, LUP. Price, R. (2020). The Acts of the Second Council of Nicaea (787) TTH, LUP.Price, R., & Gaddis, M. (2007). The Acts of the Council of Chalcedon TTH, LUP.Price, R., & Graumann, T. (2020). The Council of Ephesus of 431: Documents and Proceedings TTH, LUP.Price, R., & Whitby, M. (2011). Chalcedon in Context: Church Councils 400 to 700 TTH, LUP.Schaff, Philiip (Editor); Et Al. (1886). CHURCH FATHERS: Home. New Advent. newadvent.org/fathersSynodality and Primacy During the First Millennium: Towards a Common Understanding in Service to the Unity of the Church (2016, September 21). Https://Www.Ecupatria.Org/Synodality-.... Unless otherwise noted, all patristic and canonical quotations are from the Church Fathers series edited by Philip Schaff found at www.newadvent.com0:00 Introduction7:21 1848 Encyclical & Orthodox Scholars12:10 Orthodox Primacy & Canons21:15 "Archbishop of the World"24:59 Role of Primate & Canons32:48 Ecumenical Meetings36:10 Ybarra Doesn't Understand Orthodoxy40:14 Heretical Popes?42:29 The Role of Ecumenical Councils48:16 Appeals & Canon 2801:08:12 Benedict XVI & DOD01:11:46 Cyprian, Boniface, Forgeries & Vatican 101:31:39 Gelasius, Felix & Papal Excommunications01:50:48 Ex-Cathedra & Tome of Leo02:00:40 Books & Scholars02:03:37 Part II, The Filioque & Modern Problems02:09:01 Conclusion & Embarrassing Statements02:10:36 The Final Challenge---Links Referred To---Gregory the Great and the Sixth Century Dispute Over the Ecumenical Title: ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020/05/16/gregory-the-great-and-the-sixth-century-dispute-over-the-ecumenical-titleRorate Caeli on Haec Sancta: rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2016/07/haec-sancta-1415-conciliar-document.htmlJay Dyer forgeries stream: youtube.com/watch?v=DcZ7scez5XsSt. Maximos Article with doctored Dom Chapman quote: ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020/01/11/did-st-maximus-the-confessor-believe-in-papal-infalibilitypart-icatholic-apologists-rebuted-erick-ybarraDivorce & Remarriage Florilegium: ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020/01/05/church-fathers-and-patristic-era-writers-on-the-topic-of-divorce-and-remarriage-a-florilegiumOn Auctoritas: ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2019/11/25/on-auctoritasAKACatholic on Taylor Marshall: akacatholic.com/revelation-dr-taylor-marshall-abm-is-short---Personal Links---Blog: ubipetrusibiecclesia.comFacebook: facebook.com/ubi.petrus.7---Creditting---Final video clip from "Gladiator" directed by Ridley Scott - Retrieved from SceneScreen (youtube.com/watch?v=YbBiXPVKuTA)Narration by Orthodox Pilgrim: youtube.com/channel/UCHKbYzPJBG_I4XRLYUJ31agIntro music by Aaron Velen: aaronvelen.com
Is the Orthodox Church the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church? Ubi Petrus vs. Voice of Reason Ubi Petrus 2025-05-17 | In the Nicaean-Constantinopolitan Creed, the Church is described as "one, holy, catholic, and apostolic" giving rise to the term "the four marks of the Church." This debate focuses on whether the Orthodox Church fulfills the definitions of that, specifically "one" and "catholic." You can see our new videos and support us by following this link: patreon.com/c/ubipetrus where we post two videos per month and respond to questions.The thumbnail for this video was created by Dan Iova who beat out two other finalists by winning 3/4 of the vote when put to the YouTube audience. Thanks, Dan!The live stream was handled by Randolph Media Company randolphmediacompany.com
Can a Pope Be Deposed? Ubi Petrus 2025-04-06 | This clip is taken from the 2 1/2 long video "Ubi Petrus vs. Erick Ybarra Debate Review Part 1." The full video can be found at the links below: patreon.com/c/ubipetrus
Why the Minimalist Argument for the Papacy Fails - from Ubi Petrus vs. Ybarra Debate Review Part 1 Ubi Petrus 2025-03-29 | This clip is taken from the 2 1/2 long video "Ubi Petrus vs. Erick Ybarra Debate Review Part 1" which can be found at the links below: patreon.com/c/ubipetrus
MHFM/VaticanCatholic Refuted on Orthodoxy & Ecumenical Councils | When LARPing goes Wrong Ubi Petrus 2025-03-01 | In this video, we deconstruct the claims by the Dimond Brothers, also known as "Most Holy Family Monastery" or @vaticancatholic-dimond on YouTube. We refute three main claims made in their video attempting to debunk Orthodox ecclesiology. As you will see in the video, the "Trailer-ites"/"Trailer-Trads" made numerous incorrect statements, which we can only assume to be lies or based in ignorance. We are not sure which is worse given their pontification on the topic - which is ironic since they do not have a pontiff. Nota bene: the views we have expressed on the persons of the Dimond Brothers are our own opinions based on our research and are, to the best of our knowledge at the time of posting this video, accurate. This video discusses the criteria by which the Orthodox Church determines what is and is not an ecumenical council as well as the Council of Florence and why Robert and Frederick Dimond are deceivers and pseudo-monks, whom the canons of numerous local and ecumenical councils warn against.Furthermore, we extend a debate challenge to the Dimond Brothers and any of their followers to come onto our channel and debate the topic. We thank @JayDyer for his continued support as well as all our patrons and viewers.We thanks @Orthodox Pilgrim for the voice-over.Affiliate link for FreeFiltering: freefiltering.org/#UbiPetrusMusic by Aaron Velen: / aaronvelen Our Patreon: patreon.com/c/ubipetrusOur blog: ubipetrusibiecclesia.com-- Links --What makes a Council Ecumenical Patristic Quotations - Part 1: https://ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020...Part 2: https://ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2021...Jay Dyer's Video on Sedevacantism: • Sedevacantism Proves Orthodox Theolog... Ex-MHFM follower's video: • Why I Quit MHFM! The Dimond Brothers... Info on Joseph Natale and the founding of MHFM: https://www.bishop-accountability.org...http://www.23rdstreet.com/mhfm/joseph...https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Most_Ho... (look at bibliography)-- Works cited --Allen, P., & Neil, B. (2003). Maximus the Confessor and his Companions: Documents from Exile (Oxford Early Christian Texts) (1st ed.). Oxford University Press.Gill, Joseph, J. (2011). The Council of Florence (Illustrated ed.). Cambridge University Press.Hoffman, Georg. (1940). Concilium Florentinum. Documenta et Scriptores. Pontificio Istituto Per Gli Studi Orientali.Kappes, Christiaan. 1) “‘Mark of Ephesus, the Council of Florence, and the Roman Papacy.’” J. Chryssavgis (Editor), Primacy in the Church: The Office of Primacy and the Authority of Councils, St. Vladimir’s Seminary Press, www.academia.edu/15180881/_Mark_of_Ephesus_the_Council_of_Florence_and_the_Roman_Papacy_. Accessed 31 Dec. 2020.2) “‘A Latin Defense of Mark of Ephesus at the Council of Ferrara-Florence (1438-1439).’” Greek Orthodox Theological Review 59 (2014), www.academia.edu/4912818/_A_Latin_Defense_of_Mark_of_Ephesus_at_the_Council_of_Ferrara_Florence_1438_1439_. Accessed 31 Dec. 2020.Robinson, P. (2009, December 2). Against Khomiakov. Energetic Procession. https://energeticprocession.wordpress...Schaff, Philiip (Editor); Et Al. (1886). CHURCH FATHERS: Home. New Advent. newadvent.org/fathersUnless otherwise noted, all patristic quotations are from the Church Fathers series edited by Philip Schaff
Pope St. Agatho & the 6th Ecumenical Council - Ubi Petrus vs. Dr. James Likoudis Debate Ubi Petrus 2025-02-26 | This is the full version of the debate which took place in June 2021 with the late Dr. James Likoudis who passed away in September of 2024. Previously, the entire debate had been behind a paywall with only the first half public but we have lately been releasing the full version of videos that have been behind paywalls for multiple years. As when we debated Collorafi, Dr. Likoudis did not use Skype or Zoom, nor was he interested in live streaming so we had to do the entire debate over the phone and do it that way. Though we discuss the 5th Ecumenical Council, the main topic of the debate is the letter of Pope St. Agatho to the Emperor and the letter of the Roman Synod, headed by Pope St. Agatho, to the 6th Ecumenical Council in 680-81. Ubi Petrus begins his arguments on Pope St. Agatho and the 6th Ecumenical Council at @39:48
Contraception, NFP, and Humanae Vitae in Christian Historical Thought and the Orthodox Church Ubi Petrus 2024-11-02 | Unless otherwise stated, all citations are taken from ANF and NPNF series edited by Schaff.Bradshaw, David. “What Does it Mean to be Contrary to Nature?”Mahoney, John. "The Making of Moral Theology: A Study of the Roman Catholic Tradition." Clarendon Press, 1989McLaren, Angus. "History of Contraception From Antiquity to the Present Day." Blackwell Publishers, 1st Ed. 1992Noonan, John T. "Contraception. A History of Its Treatment by the Catholic Theologians and Canonists." Harvard University Press, 1986Origen of Alexandria "Homilies on Genesis and Exodus (Fathers of the Church Patristic Series)." Trans. Ronald E. Heine, CUA, 1982St. Ambrose of Milan "Commentary of Saint Ambrose on the Gospel according to Saint Luke" trans. Ide M. Ni Riain, Dublin 2001.St. Caesarius of Arles. "Sermons: 1-80 (Fathers of the Church Patristic Series)." Trans. Sr. Mary Magdaleine Mueller O.S.F. CUA, 1956.St. John Chrysostom "On Virginity" Shore, Sally Rieger. United States, CUA, 1982.Wilcox, M.M., Charles T., et al. Treatises on Marriage and Other Subjects (The Fathers of the Church, Volume 27). United States, Catholic University of America Press, 2010.
Papal Infallibility, Pope St. Leo the Great, & the Council of Chalcedon | Erick Ybarra Rebutted Ubi Petrus 2024-10-12 | In this video, we dive once more into the historicity behind the Tome of Pope St. Leo at the Ecumenical Council of Chalcedon, and discuss whether or not the Tome was an ex-cathedra statement and a proof of papal infallibility as Catholic apologists often claim.VISIT OUR PATREON HERE: patreon.com/ubipetrus?fan_landing=trueBlog ArticlesWas the Tome of Pope St. Leo Ex Cathedra? | Rebuttal to Catholic Apologist Erick Ybarra: ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/pope-st-leoRejoinder to Erick Ybarra’s First Reply to Ubi Petrus | Part 1 | When Plagiarism Goes Wrong: ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2019/12/15/when-plagiarism-goes-wrong-part-iRejoinder to Erick Ybarra’s First Reply to Ubi Petrus | Part 2 | When Plagiarism Goes Wrong: ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2019/12/20/when-plagiarism-goes-wrong-part-ii"The Gift of Infallibility. The Official Relatio on Infallibility of Bishop Vincent Ferrer Gasser at Vatican Council I" by Bishop Vincent Gasser. Translated by Fr. James T. O'Conner. Found here for free: archive.org/details/giftofinfallibil0000gassMcGuckin, J. A. (2010). Saint Cyril of Alexandria and the Christological Controversy (Reprint ed.). St Vladimirs Seminary Pr.Price, R., & Gaddis, M. (2007). The Acts of the Council of Chalcedon (Translated Texts for Historians LUP) (Volume 45). Liverpool University Press.00:00 Introduction04:00 Defining Papal Infallibility11:26 Do I only have to submit to ex-cathedra decrees?14:44 The History of Ephesus 1&2, Chalcedon & the Tome of Leo33:40 "Peter has spoken through Leo!"35:42 Judging the Tome51:47 Did the Bishops *really* Judge the Tome?1:01:49 Did Pope Leo think the Tome was ex-cathedra?1:08:02 Did only a minority of Bishops Object?1:14:45 A Final Roman Catholic prooftext1:18:41 Conclusion
Do Eastern Orthodox Evangelize? | A History of Orthodox Christian Missions | Vol. 3. (1601-1917) Ubi Petrus 2024-09-21 | Welcome to the third video we are doing in a series on the history of Orthodox missions in the second millennium. Our first can be found here: youtube.com/watch?v=2KslrBGk2-IThis series of videos was created mainly to answer the accusation of Catholic apologists that we do not evangelize and, therefore, we could not be the true church. Catholic apologists cite the supposed successes of Catholic missionaries throughout North and South America, Africa, and Asia but have these missions actually achieved results more spectacular than other religions and sects?Our patreon: patreon.com/ubipetrus---Bibliography---The 90th anniversary of the Schism of Tylawa: Reunion of Eastern Catholics with the Orthodox Church. (2016). orthochristian.com/97479.htmlBELARUSIAN CHURCH CELEBRATES ANNIVERSARY OF COUNCIL THAT BROUGHT 1.5 MILLION UNIATES BACK TO ORTHODOXY. (2019). orthochristian.com/119602.htmlCarpatho-Russia And The Struggle For The Russian Orthodox Tradition Outside Russia. (2017). http://orthodoxengland.org.uk/carp-rus.htmGeraci, R., & Khodarkovsky, M. (2001). Of Religion and Empire: Missions, Conversion, and Tolerance in Tsarist Russia. Cornell University Press.Keleher, Serge (1995, November 4). Trapped Between Two Churches: Orthodox and Greek-Catholics in Eastern Poland. Https://Citeseerx.Ist.Psu.Edu/Viewdoc/Download?Doi=10.1.1.467.4885&rep=rep1&type=pdf.Panchenko, C. A., Noble, S., & Noble, P. B. (2016). Arab Orthodox Christians Under the Ottomans 1516–1831. Holy Trinity Seminary Press.Phillips, A. A. (2017). Archpriest Andrew Phillips. Carpatho-Russia and the Struggle for the Russian Orthodox Tradition Outside Russia. orthochristian.com/108811.htmlPsarev, D. A. 1) (2020, December 10). Abun Mar Elia (Abraham, d. November 1928) of Supurgansk and Urmia - ROCOR Studies. ROCOR Studies - Historical Studies of the Russian Church Abroad. rocorstudies.org/2015/05/17/abun-mar-elia-abraham-1858-1928-of-supurgansk-and-urmia-22) (2020b, December 14). Bishop John (Gevargizov, d. 1960) of Urmia - ROCOR Studies. ROCOR Studies - Historical Studies of the Russian Church Abroad. rocorstudies.org/2009/12/10/bishop-john-of-urmiaSkinner, B. (2009). The Western Front of the Eastern Church: Uniate and Orthodox Conflict in Eighteenth-century Poland, Ukraine, Belarus, and Russia (NIU Series in Slavic, East European, and Eurasian Studies) (1st ed.). Northern Illinois University Press.Stokoe, Mark; Kishkovsky, the Very Rev. Leonid (1995). Orthodox Christians in North America (1794 - 1994). Orthodox Christian Publications Center (OCPC).OCA Lives of the Saints available at www.oca.org00:00 Introduction01:47 Chapter 1: The Mission to Japan12:19 Chapter 2: The Mission to North America (contd.)32:12 Chapter 3: The Mission to the Uniates in Eastern Europe1:20:40 Chapter 4: The Mission to the Uniates in the Eastern Mediterranean1:43:09 Chapter 5: The Mission to the Old Believers
Papal Forgeries: A Road to Schism (FULL) Ubi Petrus 2024-09-07 | 00:00 Introduction & Contents04:26 The Pseudo-Symmachian Forgeries25:27 The Liber Pontificalis31:51 The Donation of Constantine38:31 The Pseudo-Isidorian Decretals1:11:09 The Gregorian Reforms and Beyond1:23:20 Aquinas, Florence and Beyond
Do Eastern Orthodox Evangelize? | A History of Orthodox Christian Missions | Vol. 2. (1601-1917) Ubi Petrus 2024-08-17 | Welcome to the second video we are doing in a series on the history of Orthodox missions in the second millennium. Our first can be found here: youtube.com/watch?v=2KslrBGk2-IThis series of videos was created mainly to answer the accusation of Catholic apologists that we do not evangelize and, therefore, we could not be the true church. Catholic apologists cite the supposed successes of Catholic missionaries throughout North and South America, Africa, and Asia but have these missions actually achieved results more spectacular than other religions and sects? Our patreon: patreon.com/ubipetrus---Bibliography---Geraci, R., & Khodarkovsky, M. (2001). Of Religion and Empire: Missions, Conversion, and Tolerance in Tsarist Russia. Cornell University Press.METROPOLITAN NESTOR, ENLIGHTENER OF THE PEOPLES OF KAMCHATKA. (2012). Www.Orthodoxchristian.Com. orthochristian.com/57186.htmlOCA Lives of the Saints available at www.oca.orgPsarev, D. A. 1) (2020, December 10). Abun Mar Elia (Abraham, d. November 1928) of Supurgansk and Urmia - ROCOR Studies. ROCOR Studies - Historical Studies of the Russian Church Abroad. rocorstudies.org/2015/05/17/abun-mar-elia-abraham-1858-1928-of-supurgansk-and-urmia-22) (2020b, December 14). Bishop John (Gevargizov, d. 1960) of Urmia - ROCOR Studies. ROCOR Studies - Historical Studies of the Russian Church Abroad. rocorstudies.org/2009/12/10/bishop-john-of-urmiaStokoe, Mark; Kishkovsky, the Very Rev. Leonid (1995). Orthodox Christians in North America (1794 - 1994). Orthodox Christian Publications Center (OCPC).00:00 Introduction06:08 Chapter 1: The Mission to Siberia16:47 Chapter 2: The Mission to North America31:45 Chapter 3: The Altai Mission38:44 Chapter 4: The Kazan Mission45:43 Chapter 5: The Mission to the Assyrians51:39 Chapter 6: The Mission to Kamchatka57:19 Chapter 7: The Mission to China
Catholic Answers Michael Lofton Fails on Orthodoxy & Misses the Mark on Church History [FULL] Ubi Petrus 2024-07-20 | Catholic Answers' Michael Lofton Fails on Orthodox Christianity & Misses the Mark on Church History.Affiliate link for FreeFiltering: freefiltering.org/#UbiPetrusConfession of Dositheus: ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2022/06/21/the-confession-of-patriarch-dositheos-of-jerusalem-1672
Whats Wrong with Papal Infallibility? | Answering a Uniate Ubi Petrus 2024-06-29 | In this video we respond to a Uniate apologist who has done a response to our video on the Tome of Leo and one of our pragmatic arguments against Papal Infallibility. Needless to say, this Uniate cedes all our points, contradicts himself and makes big historical blunders regarding the Tome and St. Cyril + Nestorius. We hope you all enjoy, and our original Tome video can be found below.Original Tome Video: youtube.com/watch?v=yh3-z8aLTV800:00 Introduction & Background Info06:49 Rejecting Multiple Debate Offers12:24 Our Stance on Response Videos15:21 A Big Thanks to Our Patrons18:38 Defining 'Consent' & the Levels of the Magisterium21:53 Our 4 Original Points & Argument24:37 He Cedes all of Our Points 41:29 He Seems to Contradict Himself (1)50:56 He Cedes all of Our Points Again58:55 He Seems to Contradict Himself Again1:02:30 He Misrepresents Our Argument1:14:41 Would a Pope Act without Episcopal Consent? Pius IX Answers1:29:18 What Ubi says is Accurate... But Ubi is also ignorant?1:32:28 He suggests Editting Pastor Aeternus to Appease Orthodox1:38:09 He gets the History of Pope St. Leo Wrong 1:56:53 He confuses Synodality with Papal Infallibility1:58:47 Displays Ignorance of Orthodox Synodality2:02:36 Rich Irony2:04:23 Random & Hilarious Clips--- Sources ---sites.google.com/view/taboriclight/documents/official-relatio-of-vatican-iLevels of the Magisterium: catholicism.org/the-three-levels-of-magisterial-teaching.htmlO’Connor, J. T. (2008). The Gift of Infallibility: The Official Relatio on Infallibility of Bishop Vincent Ferrer Gasser at Vatican Council I (First ed.). Ignatius Press.Ordinatio Sacerdotalis: 1) https://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/ladaria-ferrer/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20180529_caratteredefinitivo-ordinatiosacerdotalis_en.html2) https://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_19951028_commento-dubium-ordinatio-sac_en.html3) newadvent.org/library/docs_df95os.htm
FULL VIDEO Reason and Theologys Michael Lofton Doubles Down On His Ignorance of Orthodoxy Ubi Petrus 2024-05-18 | In our previous installment, we went over many of Mr. Lofton’s pet arguments against the Orthodox Church and provided clips of him speaking in which he presented his objections followed by our responses. In this second video, we will continue responding to even more clips of his on additional topics.Affiliate link for FreeFiltering: freefiltering.org/#UbiPetrusAll video and audio clips not produced by us but found within this video are covered under "fair use" laws as described in Title 17, chapter 1, section 107 of the United States Law Code.For resources on the Armenian Church's acceptance of Chalcedon:1) A brief outline is provided in Fr. John Meyendorff's book "Imperial Unity and Christian Division" p.102-109, 280-285, and 340-345. 2) Frend's "The Rise of the Monophysite Movement" p. 308-315 and random scattered mentions contained in the index provide less but overlapping details. 3) An ancient source that is nearly primary is Sebeo's "Armenian History" Chs. 19 & 41 and the commentary on ch. 41 on p. 228 of the LUP TTH edition. N.B. Sebeos refers to "Theodosiopoulos" by its Armenian name "Karin".
Do Eastern Orthodox Evangelize? | A History of Orthodox Christian Missions | Vol. 1. (1054-1600) Ubi Petrus 2024-04-06 | One of the more common claims made against the Orthodox Church by Catholic apologists is the claim that we do not evangelize like the Catholic Church does. Not only is this disturbingly ignorant but it evinces a very palpable and very empty triumphalism. Part of this is willful cluelessness but part of it is also a lack of access to resources that are primarily in languages such as Russian, Serbian, and Greek and therefore, most western Christians have never had the opportunity to study the history. In this video we begin to recount the history of Orthodox missions in the second millenium and demonstrate that the cheap polemic is not only patently false, but completely ridiculous. Our patreon: patreon.com/ubipetrusRobert Michell and Nevill Forbes, (Translators) The Chronicle of Novgorod, 1016-1417. Camden Third Series. Vol. 25. London: The Camden Society, 1914. Passim et seriatim. reprinted in Warren Walsh, Readings in Russian History, (Syracuse NY: Syracuse University Press, 1948) accessed from https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/source/novgorod1.aspGiovanni Deplano Carpini on the destruction of Kiev: http://wayback.archive-it.org/6473/20160819150506/tspace.library.utoronto.ca/citd/RussianHeritage/4.PEAS/4.L/12.III.5.htmlThe OCA’s daily saints database was consulted for each of the saints for whom there is information there. They can be found by their feast day, which is listed with each of them either as the day of their death or separately.
The Theology of Marriage in Orthodox Christianity Ubi Petrus 2024-03-16 | In this video, we will briefly discuss the purpose and use of annulments within both Orthodoxy and Catholicism, how marriage is a Eucharistic union and icon of the Church, and whether or not marriage in the Orthodox Church is considered indissoluble.Our Subscribe Star: subscribestar.com/ubi-petrusOur Patreon: patreon.com/ubipetrusBibliography: ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2022/02/26/the-theology-of-marriage-in-orthodox-christianity
Divorce & Remarriage in the Church Fathers | Erick Ybarra & Called to Communion Rebutted FULL VIDEO Ubi Petrus 2024-02-24 | Catholic apologists have repeatedly made the accusation that the Orthodox Church, despite its staunch conservatism in regard to liturgy, fasting, and social issues, has caved on the topic of remarriage after divorce. They argue that the Church Fathers have always, or at least almost always taught that remarriage after a divorce, even in a narrow range of cases, is forbidden so long as the first spouse is living. Those Catholic apologists come armed with quote mines meant to defend that view and such quote mines are ubiquitous on the internet. Yet, these collections typically contain the same core quotations with little meaningful analysis. In this video, we will respond to two of these quote mines. The first is by Erick Ybarra and can be found on his blog. The second, which is more comprehensive than Mr. Ybarra's, is from the blog "Called to Communion," a website founded by Brian Cross (both quote mines are linked below in the form we found them while making this video). We will not necessarily be following the order that either of these blog posts use in presenting the quotations, but, throughout our video, we will dispute their interpretations of specific passages they quote in their collections. Our Subscribe Star: subscribestar.com/ubi-petrusOur Patreon: patreon.com/ubipetrusThe two quote mines we are responding to appear, in their current form here(1) web.archive.org/web/20220116013233/erickybarra.org/2019/08/04/divorce-remarriage-in-the-church-fathers(2) web.archive.org/web/20220111083719/calledtocommunion.com/2011/09/what-therefore-god-has-joined-together-divorce-and-the-sacrament-of-marriage00:00 Introduction02:41 The Matthean Exceptive Clause10:36 Were the Church Fathers against Remarriage after Divorce?19:11 Lactantius23:35 St. Augustine27:10 Ambrosiaster30:45 St. Chromatius of Aquilea32:04 Synod of Arles 314 AD35:46 St. Patrick of Ireland37:24 Synod of Elvira 305 AD42:00 Synod of Vannes 465 AD43:06 Synod of Agde 506 AD45:07 Synod of Compiegne 757 AD47:00 Synod of Rome 826 AD & Pope Gregory II49:51 Synod of Verberie 735 AD 52:12 Synod of Worms 1006 AD & Synod of Bourges-Limoges 103153:37 St. Theodore of Canterbury57:43 Archbishop Ecbert of York1:00:04 Origen1:05:12 Synod of Laodicea 365 AD1:06:21 St. Basil the Great1:23:31 St. Gregory Nazianzen1:29:01 St. Epiphanius of Salamis1:31:05 St. Asterius of Amasea & St. Cyril of Alexandria1:33:36 Theodoret of Cyrus & Apostolic Constitutions1:38:50 St. Emperor Justinian the Great1:45:02 Quinisext Council 692 AD1:48:26 Patriarch Alexius Studite1:49:27 The Tome of Union 920 AD & the Tetragamy Controversy2:00:12 Council of Nicea 325 AD2:10:44 End & Trailer---BIBLIOGRAPHY---"Can a Man Commit πορνεία with His Wife?" David Wheeler-Reed, Jennifer W. Knust and Dale B. Martin Journal of Biblical Literature Vol. 137, No. 2 (Summer 2018), pp. 383-398 (16 pages)ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020/01/05/church-fathers-and-patristic-era-writers-on-the-topic-of-divorce-and-remarriage-a-florilegium
Papacy Debate FULL VIDEO: The Role of the Pope in the 1st Millenium | John Collorafi vs. Ubi Petrus Ubi Petrus 2024-02-03 | In this debate on whether or not the Pope had a role in line with Vatican 1 within the first millenium, the Catholic apologist who goes by the pen name "John Collorafi" joins us to debate the question.Mr. John Collorafi has translated books on Fatima and Padre Pio from French and Latin and is also familiar with Koine Greek. He is a Latin mass enthusiast and author of the book "Keys Over the Christian World" wherein he argues for the Papal claims of the Roman Catholic Church. This book is available in PDF form.Our Patreon: patreon.com/ubipetrusOur Blog: ubipetrusibiecclesia.com
Assessing Erick Ybarras Book The Papacy │ Part 1 - Chapters 1 - 7 HALF Ubi Petrus 2024-01-06 | First part in a series responding to Erick Ybarra's book on the Papacy. This video is the first half.Full video available at: subscribestar.com/ubi-petrusAffiliate link for FreeFiltering: freefiltering.org/#UbiPetrus
Why Reason & Theologys Michael Lofton is Wrong on Orthodoxy, Ecumenical Councils, & the Magisterium Ubi Petrus 2023-01-07 | Support us on SubscribeStar here: subscribestar.com/ubi-petrusAffiliate link for FreeFiltering: freefiltering.org/#UbiPetrusOur blog: ubipetrusibiecclesia.comAll video and audio clips not produced by us but found within this video are covered under "fair use" laws as described in title 17, chapter 1, section 107 of the United States Law Code.
Filioque Debate: Ubi Petrus vs. Militant Thomist Ubi Petrus 2022-11-19 | A debate between Militant Thomist (Christian B. Wagner) and Ubi Petrus on the Filioque clause, which was one of the major occasions for the schism between the RCC and the OC. Militant Thomist believes that the position of the Greek Fathers, as interpreted by Florence and the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity study is not a church-dividing issue. By contrast, Ubi Petrus believes that the Filioque is unhistorical and carries with it a theology that is contrary to the patristic teaching. Militant Thomist's YT:youtube.com/c/DisputedQuestions Militant Thomist's Twitter: twitter.com/MilitantThomistUbi Petrus' SubscribeStare: subscribestar.com/ubi-petrus
The Eastern Orthodox Mission to China (from A History of Orthodox Christian Missions Part II) Ubi Petrus 2022-05-14 | This clip is from our 2nd video in the Orthodox Missions series. It is found in the second half only available for patrons. The clip discusses the Orthodox Christian mission to China headed by the Russian Orthodox Church.The first half can be found here: youtube.com/watch?v=_nImg9C9Xsw&t=0sOur subscribestar for full video:subscribestar.com/ubi-petrusAffiliate link for FreeFiltering: freefiltering.org/#UbiPetrus
The Eastern Orthodox Mission to Assyrian Christians (from A History of Orthodox Missions Part II) Ubi Petrus 2022-05-01 | This clip is from our 2nd video in the Orthodox Missions series. It is found in the second half only available for patrons. Some viewers have requested us to clip out just this part of the video so we have done so and made it available to the public. The first half can be found here: youtube.com/watch?v=_nImg9C9XswOur subscribestar for full video: subscribestar.com/ubi-petrus
Sex, Contraception, NFP, Humanae Vitae, & Natural Law with Dr. David Bradshaw Ubi Petrus 2022-04-30 | As an addendum to our video on contraception in Christian historical thought, we invite on Orthodox philosopher Dr. David Bradshaw to discuss his thoughts expressed in an upcoming publication subheaded "What does it mean to be Contrary to Nature?" and another article he wrote on Christian Sexual Ethics at Ancient Faith.We hope to discuss Natural Law, its influence on Humanae Vitae, and its place in Orthodox sexual ethics.Affiliate link for FreeFiltering: freefiltering.org/#UbiPetrusOur SubscribeStar: subscribestar.com/ubi-petrusDr. Bradshaw's article series on Christian Sexual Ethics: blogs.ancientfaith.com/every-thought-captive/2021/09/16/christian-sexual-ethics-what-went-wrong-pt-1
Os Ortodoxos Evangelizam? | A História das Missões Ortodoxas | Vol. 1 (1054-1600) Ubi Petrus 2021-10-29 | Uma das afirmações mais comuns feitas contra a Igreja Ortodoxa pelos apologistas Católicos é a afirmação de que não evangelizamos como a Igreja Católica faz. Isto não só é algo assustadoramente ignorante, como também evoca um triunfalismo vazio muito evidente. Parte disto é uma ignorância intencional, mas parte disto é também uma falta de acesso a materiais que estão principalmente em línguas como o russo, sérvio e grego e, portanto, a maioria dos cristãos ocidentais nunca tiveram a oportunidade de estudar a história. Neste vídeo começamos a recontar a história das missões Ortodoxas no segundo milênio e demonstramos que a polêmica popular não só é evidentemente falsa, mas completamente ridícula.Nosso patreon: patreon.com/ubipetrusRobert Michell and Nevill Forbes, (Translators) The Chronicle of Novgorod, 1016-1417. Camden Third Series. Vol. 25. London: The Camden Society, 1914. Passim et seriatim. Reimpresso em Warren Walsh, Readings in Russian History, (Syracuse NY: Syracuse University Press, 1948) acessado via https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/source/novgorod1.aspGiovanni Deplano Carpini sobre a destruição de Kiev: http://wayback.archive-it.org/6473/20160819150506/tspace.library.utoronto.ca/citd/RussianHeritage/4.PEAS/4.L/12.III.5.htmlO banco de dados diário de santos da Igreja Ortodoxa na América (OCA) foi consultado para cada um dos santos para os quais há informações lá. Eles podem ser encontrados no dia de sua festa, que é listada com cada um deles como o dia de sua morte ou separadamente.Tradução por Tony Pedroza e áudio por Diogo AzevedoPara mais material sobre a fé Ortodoxa em português acesse: http://skemmata.blogspot.comyoutube.com/c/pravoslavielegendas
Orthodox Christianity vs. Catholicism | Rebuttal to Erick Ybarra on Matt Fradds Pints With Aquinas Ubi Petrus 2021-09-29 | In this video, we do a review of the debate Erick Ybarra had with Fr. Patrick Ramsey on @pintswithaquinasconcerning whether or not the Vatican I Papacy was present in the first millennium Church. Watch our full video on Patreon: patreon.com/ubipetrusThe original debate on Matt Fradd's channel: youtube.com/watch?v=_qvZDYxZBHkOur blog is here: ubipetrusibiecclesiahome.wordpress.comWe would like to thank @Orthodox Pilgrim for the voice work.--Bibliography and Works Cited --- “Why Catholicism is Wrong on Church History & Erick Ybarra Refuted”: youtu.be/ibZN9U3kbzw “Pope St. Leo’s Tome, Proof of Infallibility?” youtu.be/yh3-z8aLTV8“Papal Forgeries, A Road to Schism” youtu.be/n8jVL_0h3yo "All Bishops are Peter"ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020/01/24/all-bishops-are-successors-of-peter-florilegium"Does the Lateran Council of 649 Prove Papal Infallibility?" ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020/07/25/does-the-lateran-council-of-649-prove-papal-infallibility"Pope St. Boniface I and Papal Authority" ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020/06/13/pope-st-boniface-i-and-papal-authorityBibliography & Works Cited:Benedict, Pope, and Vittorio Messori. "The Ratzinger Report : An Exclusive Interview on the State of the Church." San Francisco, Ignatius Press, 1985.Booth, P., Cubitt, C., & Price, R. (2017). The Acts of the Lateran Synod of 649 (Translated Texts for Historians LUP) (1st ed.). Liverpool University Press.Common Christological Declaration of Pope John Paul II and His Holiness Mar Dinkha IV, Catholicos-Patriarch of the Assyrian Church of the East. (1994, November 11). Https://Www.Vatican.va/Content/John-Paul-Ii/En/Speeches/1994/November/Documents/Hf_jp-Ii_spe_19941111_dichiarazione-Cristologica.Html. Joint International Commission for the Theological Dialogue between the Orthodox Church and the Roman Catholique Church (2007, October 13). Https://Www.Ecupatria.Org/Documents/Joint-International-Commission-for-the-Theological-Dialogue-between-the-Orthodox-Church-and-the-Roman-Catholique-Church/. Neil, B., & Allen, P. (2014). Pope Gelasius I, The Letters of Gelasius I (492–496): Micro-manager and Pastor of the Church of Rome (Adnotationes: Commentaries on Early Christian and Patristic Texts) (Bilingual ed.). Brepols Publishers.O’Connor, J. T. (2008). The Gift of Infallibility: The Official Relatio on Infallibility of Bishop Vincent Ferrer Gasser at Vatican Council I (First ed.). Ignatius Press.Price, R. (2012a&b). The Acts of the Council of Constantinople of 553: With Related Texts on the Three Chapters Controversy (Translated Texts for Historians LUP) (Volume 51) (1st ed.). Liverpool University Press.Price, R. (2020). The Acts of the Second Council of Nicaea (787) (Translated Texts for Historians LUP). Liverpool University Press.Price, R., & Gaddis, M. (2007). The Acts of the Council of Chalcedon (Translated Texts for Historians LUP) (Volume 45). LUP.Price, R., & Graumann, T. (2020). The Council of Ephesus of 431: Documents and Proceedings TTH, LUP.Price, R., & Whitby, M. (2011). Chalcedon in Context: Church Councils 400 to 700 TTH, LUP.Schaff, Philiip (Editor); Et Al. (1886). CHURCH FATHERS: Home. New Advent. newadvent.org/fathersSynodality and Primacy During the First Millennium: Towards a Common Understanding in Service to the Unity of the Church (2016, September 21). Https://Www.Ecupatria.Org/Synodality-and-Primacy-during-the-First-Millennium-towards-a-Common-Understanding-in-Service-to-the-Unity-of-the-Church/. Unless otherwise noted, all patristic and canonical quotations are from the Church Fathers series edited by Philip Schaff found at www.newadvent.com0:00 Introduction10:27 The Importance of Gasser's Relatio14:21 Three Examples of Papal Infallibility in the Relatio21:51 St. Irenaeus of Lyon29:29 Excommunications as Local Occurrences35:01 St. Cyprian of Carthage and Pope St. Stephen38:26 Council of Sardica and Rome as "Last Court of Appeals"41:30 Philip the Roman Legate at Ephesus43:50 The Robber Synod of Ephesus 449 48:35 The Council of Chalcedon and Canon 2853:46 The LIbellus of Hormisdas 55:59 The Lateran Council of 649 & St. Maximus the Confessor1:07:00 Pope St. Agatho the 6th Ecumenical Council1:14:11 Pope Hadrian and the 7th Ecumenical Council1:16:12 Authority as Auctoritas vs. Potestas1:19:11 St. Theodore the Studite1:20:43 Auctoritas in Pastor Aeternus1:25:48 Primacy vs. Supremacy in the Canons and the Papacy as a Divine Institution1:35:41 Appeals to Rome1:46:22 Lateran 649, St. Cyprian of Carthage, and Episcopal Depositions2:01:08 Dogmatic vs. Ecumenical Councils; Pope Vigilus & the 5th Ecumenical Council2:04:58 Nestorius in the Catholic Church2:11:45 Pope Benedict XVI Admits the Orthodox Church is the Authentic Church 2:18:01 Council of Florence and Was Rome a "Bulkwork of Orthodoxy" in the First Millennium?
Is the Papacy Biblical? | Suan Sonna v Kabane Ubi Petrus 2021-08-07 | Suan Sonna joins Ubi with Orthodox guest Kabane to discuss the Biblical case for the Papacy.Unfortunately Ben could not join us so the discussion is mainly between Kabane and Suan.Suan's channel: youtube.com/channel/UCCNjkpXEwIdH-jD8mPJwu_gKabane's channel: youtube.com/user/KabaneTheChristianSuan's Patreon: patreon.com/intellectualconservatismKabane's patreon: patreon.com/kabaneUbi's patreon: patreon.com/ubipetrusMatt Slick v Kabane debate: youtube.com/watch?v=LxJ3oNAHJ9A
DEBATE: Isaiah 22, Matthew 16, and the Papacy - Is There a Connection? | Suan Sonna vs. Ubi Petrus Ubi Petrus 2021-04-10 | We host Catholic Apologist Suan Sonna for a discussion/debate on whether or not there is a link between Isaiah 22 and Matthew 16, as well as other Biblical evidence to determine whether or not these prove the Roman Catholic teachings on the Papacy.Suan has gladly accepted our invitation and we are very honoured not only to host him but be hosted by him. Therefore, we ask all viewers to respect his wishes and be polite and amicable in the comments section of the two live streams. Suan is a convert to Catholicism and is a published author as well as a passionate defender of the Papacy, we greatly look forward to this engagement. You can find Suan's channel here: youtube.com/channel/UCCNjkpXEwIdH-jD8mPJwu_gSuan's academia page with his publications can be found here: https://ksu.academia.edu/SuanSonna
Refuting Erick Ybarra & Matt Fradd | Yes, you should become Eastern Orthodox Ubi Petrus 2020-11-30 | We host a stream with Snek, David therealMedWhite and Seraphim Spillman to respond to the stream hosted by Matt Fradd and Ybarra entitled "Should we become Eastern Orthodox?"Matt Fradd is a Catholic radio show host and frequently has Catholic apologists on to exposit their position. Strangely, he seems never to want to have a competent Orthodox on to explain our position despite having already made perhaps a dozen videos criticising Orthodoxy.The original video is here: youtube.com/watch?v=0LFumbMBnncDavid's channel: youtube.com/channel/UCK7Bjrg4sFG6uw__5-S3ShgSnek's Twitter: twitter.com/SnekTheRedSunDivorce & Remarriage Florilegium: ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020/01/05/church-fathers-and-patristic-era-writers-on-the-topic-of-divorce-and-remarriage-a-florilegiumAll Bishops are Successors of Peter: ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020/01/24/all-bishops-are-successors-of-peter-florilegium
