Knife Steel NerdsExperiments and recommendations on how to process steel after forging. Hardness and toughness measurements along with images of the microstructure. Some controversial conclusions!
How to Thermal Cycle Knife SteelKnife Steel Nerds2021-08-28 | Experiments and recommendations on how to process steel after forging. Hardness and toughness measurements along with images of the microstructure. Some controversial conclusions!
00:00 Intro 00:35 History of Damascus choices 04:01 Why 1084 and 15N20? 06:03 Alloy effects on etching 14:22 Forging and Welding Alloys 18:38 Austenitizing Compabitility 29:56 How to Adjust Thermal Cycling 33:02 Tempering Damascus 34:23 Toughness and Edge Retention 36:19 SummaryCrucible is Bankrupt! What Happens to MagnaCut?Knife Steel Nerds2025-01-06 | Text version along with links: wp.me/p9J9w4-29K
00:00 Crucible and Niagara 01:41 Crucible Bankruptcy 02:49 Previous Bankruptcy 04:20 Niagara's Plan 05:45 What About MagnaCut? 06:16 Crucible Trademarks? 06:42 But Crucible is So Popular! 06:56 Will Supply Be Disrupted? 07:09 Will Performance Be Worse? 07:48 Won't We Be Fine With Competitors?Can AI Design a Better Knife Steel? Artificial Intelligence Makes Me Obsolete?Knife Steel Nerds2024-12-08 | Multiple people have sent me AI-generated new steel compositions and asked me what I think. Can AI beat humans in steel design?
00:00 Intro 00:26 Infinisteel 05:33 Ultravium 10:07 MagnaCut Plus 14:04 General Thoughts about AI 16:50 Problems and Solutions for AICold forging of Knife Steel - Performance Improvement?Knife Steel Nerds2024-11-25 | An introduction to what cold forging is, along with a new set of experiments on cold forging of 52100.
00:00 Intro 00:18 What is Cold Forging? 03:34 Potential Benefits and Drawbacks 04:27 Trips for Cold Forging 05:37 Previous studies 07:02 New Experiments on 52100 08:32 Annealed hardness 09:56 Heat Treated hardness 11:12 Toughness 12:38 Should There Be More Improvement? 15:08 ConclusionsDo You Even Need it? Foil vs Coatings for Heat Treating SteelKnife Steel Nerds2024-10-21 | I tested four different heat treat coatings and compared them to foil for protecting steel from scale and decarburization. And just what is decarb anyway?
Intro 00:00 Scale vs Decarb 00:18 Issues from Decarb 01:48 Protecting Steel 03:25 Coatings 06:36 New Experiments 08:02 Uncoated 10:22 Coatings Effect on Quenching 11:25 NoScale2000 13:08 ATP-641 14:58 Turco 15:42 Condursal Z1100 16:57 Foil 17:59 Common Issues with Coatings 19:00 Scale-X 21:02 Summary 21:39 Thank You 23:37Learn How to Heat Treat Knives with a MetallurgistKnife Steel Nerds2024-09-17 | Written article version of this video with some extra details about datasheets: knifesteelnerds.com/2024/09/17/introduction-to-knife-steel-heat-treating-from-a-metallurgist
Learn more about heat treating with the book Knife Engineering: knifeengineering.com
00:00 Intro 00:19 Datasheet 01:57 Preheating 02:22 Austenitizing 03:32 Equipment for Heat Treating 07:55 Preparing and Protecting Steel 13:17 Hold Time for Austenitizing 14:47 Quenching 16:35 Cold Treatments 17:54 Following Recipe vs Custom Heat Treating 18:55 Tempering 19:36 Targeting Hardness Value 20:39 Recommended Heat Treatment 21:39 Thermal Cycling, Normalizing, Annealing 22:04 Finding Datasheets 24:11 Hardness Testing 29:07 ConclusionsNew Buck Knife Available! 501 “The Larrin” in CocoboloKnife Steel Nerds2024-08-23 | Available through the Buck Knives websiteAustempering for Bainite - Super Toughness!Knife Steel Nerds2024-08-20 | Austempering is the process for forming bainite. What is this special microstructure in steel? How does it improve toughness over martensite?
00:00 Intro 00:11 Austempering and Bainite 01:29 Salt Furnaces and Salts 02:11 Why Bainite? 05:27 Hardness of Bainite 06:47 Understanding the TTT 14:56 New Experiments 18:08 52100 Results 20:14 O1 Results 23:31 1095 Results 24:55 Austemper High Alloy Steel? 27:03 When Should You Austemper? 28:27 Patreon and Knife EngineeringRapid Heat Treating with Salt Pots -The Secret to Ultra Performance?Knife Steel Nerds2024-08-05 | Salt pots mean you don't need to use foil or coatings to avoid scale. But the biggest benefit is they heat up the steel a lot faster than air. Will this lead to better properties?
00:00 Intro 02:44 Why Salt Pots? 03:42 Heating Rate 06:38 Soak Time 09:55 Toughness Experiments 15:34 CruForgeV Triple Quench Experiment 16:53 Verhoeven Triple Quench Experiment 18:46 Are Salt Pots Recommended? 20:03 SummaryHow to Forge Stainless for PerformanceKnife Steel Nerds2024-07-05 | We tested how to best forge and anneal stainless knife steels AEB-L and MagnaCut. It's time for bladesmiths to declare independence from carbon steel. You can still visit carbon steel, just don't pay it your taxes.
00:00 Introduction 00:29 Should stainless steel be forged? 03:26 What is a high alloy steel? 04:44 What temperature to forge stainless 07:19 Don't normalize stainless 08:05 Annealing - Goals and Difficulties 10:49 AEB-L 13:03 What happens during annealing 14:34 Hold time and cooling rate 15:00 Slow cool annealing 17:11 Isothermal hold annealing and grain refining 19:57 Temper annealing 24:20 Which annealing type was best? 24:59 Annealing MagnaCut 27:01 Selecting an annealing temperature 30:00 Final hardness vs anneal 30:36 Final toughness vs anneal and stock removal 31:51 Summary about annealing high alloy steelsThank You Blade Show 2024 - We Did It!Knife Steel Nerds2024-06-25 | Acceptance speech for the Blade Show "Publisher's Award" at 2024 Blade Show Atlanta. This award is presented to someone who has made recent contributions to the knife industry.
Thanks to Joe Herbert of Spyderco for sending me the footage.AR-RPM9 Knife Steel Is Not Powder MetallurgyKnife Steel Nerds2024-05-10 | We investigated AR-RPM9 to test whether the company's claims about it are true. They aren't.
00:00 Announcement of AR-RPM9 01:23 Composition 06:23 Powder Metallurgy? 10:52 Properties 13:41 Malice or Stupidity?Wootz - The True Damascus Steel?Knife Steel Nerds2024-04-22 | Wootz Damascus steel is literally legendary for its performance - it can cut a silk scarf out of the air. How does it compare to modern steels and pattern-welded Damascus steel?
00:00 Introduction to Wootz 02:56 Composition and Hardenability 08:14 Microstructure 10:04 Toughness 12:15 Edge Retention 14:53 Wootz Questions 22:18 ConclusionsMatrix Steels K888 and CPM 1V - Age of the Hyper Steel?Knife Steel Nerds2024-03-11 | Bohler released a new non-stainless powder metallurgy steel called K888 which is advertised as having extremely high toughness even at hardness levels of 64 Rc. I tested it as well as the very similar, older CPM-1V to see how they compare with other knife steels.
00:00 Intro and History 03:33 Advertised Properties 04:33 Microstructure 06:03 Hardness and Heat Treatment 09:02 Toughness 14:03 Edge Retention 16:01 Summary and Thank YousVanadis 60 Super High Speed Steel - 70 Rc and 7% VanadiumKnife Steel Nerds2024-02-29 | New study by myself and Malachi Chou-Green looking at Uddeholm's Vanadis 60, a powder metallurgy high speed steel that reaches 70+ Rc and has 6.5% vanadium. We tested its properties and found how it compares to other super high speed steels like Maxamet and Z-Max.
Written version of this information with citations: knifesteelnerds.com/2024/02/29/testing-super-high-speed-steel-vanadis-60Testing Chinese Knife Steel - Actually Good? (8Cr13MoV)Knife Steel Nerds2024-01-13 | New testing of Chinese knife steel 8Cr13MoV/8Cr14MoV! I previously had ratings of this steel but had not tested it, so we got to find out if I am good at predicting properties.
00:00 Intro 00:37 8Cr13MoV Name and History 06:45 Getting the steel was impossible 09:50 Heat treating and hardness 12:03 Microstructure and macro segregation 16:26 Toughness 17:13 Edge retention 20:29 Comparison with original ratingsEurope vs USA Knife Steel (Powder Metallurgy)Knife Steel Nerds2023-12-17 | A new set of tests using Z-Wear (same as CPM-CruWear) made by powder metallurgy companies in both USA and Europe. I tested a whole bunch of coupons from each to make sure the results are good. And I compared with previous tests I have done between European and American PM knife steels.
Article version of this video with links to the prior studies I referenced: wp.me/p9J9w4-1ZN
00:00 Ultra high toughness with ferrite/martensite steels? 05:09 Normalize 80CrV2 with stock removal? 09:18 How much forging to eliminate carbide stringers? 11:16 Will CruForgeV ever come back? 12:25 What is the most important property for knife steel? 15:04 Different CATRA test for cooking knives? 17:22 Does bainite have a place in knives? 20:22 Austenitizing soak time? 23:40 High temperature tempering is bad?What is Next After MagnaCut? Q&AKnife Steel Nerds2023-09-08 | You asked questions and I answered them!
00:00 Intro 00:38 Nitro-V vs 14C28N 02:49 Carbide Pullout 05:07 High Hardness MagnaCut 08:33 New Steels After MagnaCut 12:49 Does a fine grain mean good heat treatment? 17:43 Pocket sharpeners 19:56 OutroTesting Damasteel - Powder Metallurgy DamascusKnife Steel Nerds2023-08-31 | Damasteel claims they have the highest performance Damascus. Is it true?
00:00 Damasteel Development 00:44 Steels used in Damasteel 01:59 Microstructure 03:32 Heat Treatment 10:19 Edge Retention 15:23 Toughness 17:21 Summary and ConclusionsDamascus vs. Super Steels - Testing a Dozen Different Damascus Steels!Knife Steel Nerds2023-07-13 | Nearly every experiment we did on Damascus was a surprise. Damascus performance sometimes lives up to the legends, and other times it can fall down.
00:00 Intro 00:05 K390 Composition and History 00:51 Hot Hardness 02:51 K390 in knives 03:18 Bohler's Claims about K390 03:48 Microstructure 05:24 CATRA Edge Retention 06:34 Toughness 08:03 Choosing Knives in K390 vs Similar Steels 08:25 Toughness vs Other Steels 09:17 The Biggest Problem with K390 09:38 Heat Treating K390 11:49 New Steel Ratings 12:57 Patreon 13:04 Knife Engineering 13:07 SubscribeSecrets of Nickel Knife Steels - 15N20, 8670, L6, and More!Knife Steel Nerds2023-03-22 | What nickel does to steel, how to heat treat nickel knife steels, how they compare, and much more!
00:00 What nickel does to steel 00:53 15N20 steel and TME 05:41 8670 steel, Pops vs AKS 08:38 L6 steel 12:07 4340 steel 12:54 Comparing nickel steels 13:48 Nickel steels compared to others 14:48 High hardness with nickel steels 16:57 Microstructure and Wear resistance 18:33 Z-Tuff and CD#1 18:58 Why not more nickel steels? 22:54 Heat treating nickel steels with a forge 24:32 Heat treating nickel steels with a furnace 25:59 Thank you Patreon supporters 26:47 How to learn about heat treatingNew M390MK Knife Steel?Knife Steel Nerds2023-02-14 | Microtech announced a new knife steel - M390MK. Different than regular M390. What is it? What are the properties going to be? Should you be excited?
00:00 Intro 00:19 Description from Microtech 02:04 The Name 02:30 Composition 06:27 Effect of carbon 07:37 Evaluating Microtech Claims 09:31 Summary 10:24 Patreon and OutroA Rival Knife Steel Metallurgist?!?Knife Steel Nerds2023-01-17 | Some cool studies done by knife steel metallurgist Juha Perttula. See the citations and more discussion in the written version of this video: knifesteelnerds.com/2023/01/16/knife-steel-metallurgist-juha-perttula
00:00 Intro 01:09 Wootz studies 05:50 Low Alloy Steels 09:19 80CrV2 13:17 Outro and PatreonZ-Tuff and CD#1 - The Toughest Knife Steels?Knife Steel Nerds2022-12-16 | New experiments on heat treating of Z-Tuff and CD#1, and a discussion of the properties of these steels and how they compare.
00:00 Intro 00:33 Z-Tuff vs CD#1 01:09 History and Composition 03:07 Microstructure 03:36 Heat Treating 05:01 Toughness comparison 05:35 CATRA edge retention 06:10 Corrosion Resistance 08:31 Summary 08:50 Patreon Thank YouDo Knifemakers Know How to Heat Treat?Knife Steel Nerds2022-11-09 | I watched several "How To" heat treating videos to find out if people know what they are doing. I have links below for resources on how to thermal cycle and how to heat to heat treat in a forge if you want to learn more. Or read my book which covers everything.
00:00 Intro 00:19 Real Engineering 08:12 Outdoors55 14:53 Walter Sorrells 20:11 Red Beard Ops 29:16 Bell Blades 32:23 DIYeasycrafts 38:01 Outro and SummaryIs a New Bohler Knife Steel Coming?Knife Steel Nerds2022-10-17 | A new research paper was published with a niobium-alloyed powder metallurgy stainless steel. What are its properties? Will it see a release? Patreon to support Knife Steel Nerds: patreon.com/knifesteelnerds
00:00 Intro 02:17 Nitrogen vs Carbon 05:01 BD1N and BD1 17:39 Nitro-B and 1.4116 27:06 LC200N 34:44 Vanax and Elmax 37:13 Vancron and CPM-10V 40:14 Wrap-Up and Summary 42:54 Nitro Pepsi TastingThe Problem with Nitrogen Knife SteelsKnife Steel Nerds2022-07-25 | I don't get very many "major" surprised in steel testing but this was one of them. You can read an article covering the same material along with the references used in the video here: knifesteelnerds.com/2022/07/25/vancron-and-the-problem-with-nitrogen-knife-steels
Timestamps: 00:00 Intro 00:25 Heat Treatments 00:52 Vancron composition 01:13 Vancron microstructure 01:21 CATRA Edge Wear 01:41 Uddeholm's Ratings 01:58 Adhesive Wear 02:32 Abrasive Wear 03:04 LC200N and Vanax 03:49 Vanadium Nitrides 04:19 Vancron Toughness 05:39 Toughness-Edge Retention Balance 06:06 Vancron Corrosion Resistance 06:32 Video on Nitrogen stainless steels? 06:52 Patreon plug 07:07 Safety MessageHow to Heat Treat 80CrV2 Knife SteelKnife Steel Nerds2022-06-23 | I found no less than 4 different recommendations for how to heat treat 80CrV2, and nobody seems to know whose advice to follow. I compare the heat treatments, test the resulting properties, and give my recommendation on how to heat treat it for different situations including with a forge vs a furnace, and for stock removal makers vs forging bladesmiths. And I compare the properties of 80CrV2 to other steels and explain how it is different than the slightly simpler 1080 steel.
Chapters: 00:00 Intro 00:31 80CrV2 Composition 03:43 Book plug 04:01 Heat Treating Steps 05:36 Normalizing 06:51 Grain refinement 07:18 Annealing 09:24 Please subscribe 09:55 New Experiments - Annealed Microstructure 11:58 Austenitizing and As-Quenched Hardness 14:50 Toughness Testing 16:12 Heat Treated Microstructure 17:21 Quench Oil and Hardenability 20:23 Tempering - Hardness and Toughness 21:19 Summarized Heat Treatment Steps 24:21 Thank YouWhat is the Best Hardness for MagnaCut Knives?Knife Steel Nerds2022-02-21 | Are the knives coming out in MagnaCut heat treated correctly? Are they taking it to the right hardness? How should you (yes you, knifemakers) heat treat it for optimal performance? Learn more about steel and heat treating in the book Knife Engineering: amazon.com/Knife-Engineering-Steel-Treating-Geometry/dp/B08D4P9D95 Articles to read for free on https://www.KnifeSteelNerds.com References used in the video: knifesteelnerds.com/2022/02/21/what-is-the-best-hardness-for-magnacut-knivesDo You Need Cryo for a Good Heat Treat?Knife Steel Nerds2022-01-11 | Support us on Patreon! patreon.com/Knifesteelnerds Written article with citations: knifesteelnerds.com/2022/01/10/how-cold-for-cryo Knife Engineering Book: knifeengineering.comLarrin Defends MagnaCut while Eating Spicy Wings in Front of Two FernsKnife Steel Nerds2021-11-25 | Larrin showed up for a spicy wings interview but instead meets Jesse who seems more interested in roasting him than interviewing. Knife Steel Nerds Patreon to support steel research: patreon.com/knifesteelnerds Knife Engineering Book: knifesteelnerds.com/2020/07/22/new-book-knife-engineering-steel-heat-treating-and-geometry
------- Song: Timur Haisyn - Brutal Fervour (No Copyright Music) Music provided by Tunetank. Free Download: bit.ly/2WuTq9d Video Link: youtu.be/4k2S-30eGyQ -------
------- Song: Ivan Shpilevsky - The Time (No Copyright Music) Music provided by Tunetank. Free Download: bit.ly/3e3sxiw Video Link: youtu.be/zeXd4dFB5cw -------
Track: Summer Vibes Music composed and recorded by Oak Studios Creative Commons - Attribution ND 4.0 youtu.be/ixCCak6cX0Y
Previous video about how to set up steel properly after forging before the final steps of heat treating: youtube.com/watch?v=_1rYyIoseZMWhich Quenching Oil is Best for Knives?Knife Steel Nerds2021-07-19 | Which oil do you use for which steel? Can you quench too fast? These questions and more answered!