Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 14 hours ago
As the saying goes: History is written by the victors. In the West, World War II was the good war; the defeat of fascism; a story about survival, liberation and sacrifice. But across Africa and Asia, the millions who fought returned to new forms of rule—not all of them favorable. As the generation that lived through the war fades away, the battle over its meaning continues on.
In this episode, we ask: How and why does the story of World War II differ across nations and generations? Have our memories and takeaways changed over time? Who’s missing from the global narrative? And did we learn the right lessons, or are we doomed to repeat history?
💬 Join the conversation in the comments.
Featuring:
Tariq Ali: Author and historian
Carol Gluck: Professor of history, Columbia University
Patrick Porter: Professor of international security, University of Birmingham
Daqing Yang: Associate professor of history, George Washington University
Moderated by award-winning journalist and writer Mohamed Hassan
⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰
00:00 Introduction: Who really won World War II?
1:45 What is the narrative about WWII today?
03:58 Was WWII more than a single war?
9:55 How does Asia remember WWII?
12:35 Recalling the Nanjing Massacre
15:52 How certain national narratives shape history
19:38 Japan, China and the politics of war memory
24:50 Who deserves credit for winning the war?
30:43 Unlikely allies: the U.S. and the Soviet Union
38:32 Were civilians responsible for wartime atrocities?
43:54 How do memories of WWII change over time?
58:50 Winston Churchill: Hero or imperialist?
1:06:01 Was the bombing of civilians justified?
1:14:39 Hiroshima, Nagasaki and the atomic bomb
1:24:57 Did World War II create a more peaceful world?
1:34:31 Is the postwar world order breaking down?
1:44:10 Nuclear weapons, Iran and the question of intervention
1:54:30 Why countries pursue nuclear weapons
1:57:52 Are we witnessing a new global order?
2:04:15 What memories of WWWII are being lost today?
2:10:00 Final thoughts
Doha Debates hosts Majlis-style conversations that bring together diverse global voices for truth-seeking dialogue on the questions shaping our world.
►► Subscribe and watch a new debate every Tuesday: youtube.com/@DohaDebates?si=T9-6fGZgssvCHOAU
Follow Doha Debates!
Instagram instagram.com/dohadebates
LinkedIn linkedin.com/company/doha-debates-2020
TikTok tiktok.com/@dohadebates
X https://x.com/DohaDebates
Learn more: dohadebates.com
As the saying goes: History is written by the victors. In the West, World War II was the good war; the defeat of fascism; a story about survival, liberation and sacrifice. But across Africa and Asia, the millions who fought returned to new forms of rule—not all of them favorable. As the generation that lived through the war fades away, the battle over its meaning continues on.
In this episode, we ask: How and why does the story of World War II differ across nations and generations? Have our memories and takeaways changed over time? Who’s missing from the global narrative? And did we learn the right lessons, or are we doomed to repeat history?
💬 Join the conversation in the comments.
Featuring:
Tariq Ali: Author and historian
Carol Gluck: Professor of history, Columbia University
Patrick Porter: Professor of international security, University of Birmingham
Daqing Yang: Associate professor of history, George Washington University
Moderated by award-winning journalist and writer Mohamed Hassan
⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰
00:00 Introduction: Who really won World War II?
1:45 What is the narrative about WWII today?
03:58 Was WWII more than a single war?
9:55 How does Asia remember WWII?
12:35 Recalling the Nanjing Massacre
15:52 How certain national narratives shape history
19:38 Japan, China and the politics of war memory
24:50 Who deserves credit for winning the war?
30:43 Unlikely allies: the U.S. and the Soviet Union
38:32 Were civilians responsible for wartime atrocities?
43:54 How do memories of WWII change over time?
58:50 Winston Churchill: Hero or imperialist?
1:06:01 Was the bombing of civilians justified?
1:14:39 Hiroshima, Nagasaki and the atomic bomb
1:24:57 Did World War II create a more peaceful world?
1:34:31 Is the postwar world order breaking down?
1:44:10 Nuclear weapons, Iran and the question of intervention
1:54:30 Why countries pursue nuclear weapons
1:57:52 Are we witnessing a new global order?
2:04:15 What memories of WWWII are being lost today?
2:10:00 Final thoughts
Doha Debates hosts Majlis-style conversations that bring together diverse global voices for truth-seeking dialogue on the questions shaping our world.
►► Subscribe and watch a new debate every Tuesday: youtube.com/@DohaDebates?si=T9-6fGZgssvCHOAU
Follow Doha Debates!
Instagram instagram.com/dohadebates
LinkedIn linkedin.com/company/doha-debates-2020
TikTok tiktok.com/@dohadebates
X https://x.com/DohaDebates
Learn more: dohadebates.com







![Football fandom: Community or commodity?
Twenty years ago, the football club you followed usually offered insight into where you came from. Today, Manchester United trades on the New York Stock Exchange and counts its followers in the hundreds of millions, most of them Asian and African nationals. Still, they cry when United loses. They fight in the comment sections. The sense of belonging is real—but what exactly do these fans belong to?
Some argue that the new money behind football clubs—private equity firms, sovereign wealth funds, and multi-club investment groups—means a better and more global game. But how does it affect fan identity and loyalty? This town hall, in partnership with the Qatar, Canada and Mexico 2026 Year of Culture, asks: What happens to football fandom when big money gets involved?
💬 Join the conversation in the comments.
Featuring:
- Shireen Ahmed: Senior contributor, CBC Sports [or: Co-owner, Lewes FC, East Sussex, England]
- David Goldblatt: Writer, historian and sociologist of football
- Kely Nascimento: Chief impact officer, Hadaf Global [or: President, Nascimento Foundation]
Moderated by international journalist Imran Garda
⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰
00:00 Intro
2:54 Which clubs do the young debaters and expert guests support?
7:55 Kely Nascimento on Brazil and her father Pelé
9:31 Who do clubs belong to: Fans or owners?
25:14 Football and geopolitics
40:06 Supporting football players like Messi and Ronaldo vs. clubs
43:03 Club impact on players and communities
57:26 Are there good club owners?
1:03:03 Fans or just customers?
1:12:38 Who is a real football fan?
1:18:19 What would it take to stop being a fan of a club like Arsenal?
1:23:44 What shouldnt money buy in football?
1:25:08 Is football a mirror of society?
Doha Debates hosts Majlis-style conversations that bring together diverse global voices for truth-seeking dialogue on the questions shaping our world.
►► Subscribe and watch a new debate every Tuesday: https://youtube.com/@DohaDebates?si=T9-6fGZgssvCHOAU
Follow Doha Debates!
Instagram https://www.instagram.com/dohadebates/
LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/company/doha-debates-2020
TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@dohadebates
X https://x.com/DohaDebates
Learn more: dohadebates.com Football fandom: Community or commodity?](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/iy4oN5ua6MQ/mqdefault.jpg)


