Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
At Politifest San Diego City Council candidates Richard Bailey and Nicole Crosby couldn’t agree on a simple fact: whether the California Coastal Commission would have to sign off on any changes to the city’s laws on vacation rentals.
Crosby wants to severely overhaul the rules and said she would pursue it on Day 1, dramatically lowering the number of allowed vacation rentals. Right now, 1 percent of the city’s housing stock can be permitted for short-term vacation rentals. The exception is Mission Beach, where 30 percent of homes can be set aside for visitors.
Bailey was more cautious. He said he would consider changes but the already budget-conscious city can’t just disregard the tens of millions of tourism tax dollars short-term vacation rentals now pay the city.
But he said the Coastal Commission would have to sign off on any changes. Crosby, a chief deputy city attorney said Bailey was wrong — the city could change it without the Commission’s blessing.
She now admits she wasn’t correct. The city could change its vacation-rental laws but the part that is on the coast would need to wait for a change to the Local Coastal Program, which does need Coastal Commission Approval.
She said they could change it and work with Coastal Commission staff to make sure it stuck.
Read more Public Matters stories at kpbs.org/publicmatters
📝Scott Lewis / Voice of San Diego
📷Charlotte Radulovich, Emmy Burrus
At Politifest San Diego City Council candidates Richard Bailey and Nicole Crosby couldn’t agree on a simple fact: whether the California Coastal Commission would have to sign off on any changes to the city’s laws on vacation rentals.
Crosby wants to severely overhaul the rules and said she would pursue it on Day 1, dramatically lowering the number of allowed vacation rentals. Right now, 1 percent of the city’s housing stock can be permitted for short-term vacation rentals. The exception is Mission Beach, where 30 percent of homes can be set aside for visitors.
Bailey was more cautious. He said he would consider changes but the already budget-conscious city can’t just disregard the tens of millions of tourism tax dollars short-term vacation rentals now pay the city.
But he said the Coastal Commission would have to sign off on any changes. Crosby, a chief deputy city attorney said Bailey was wrong — the city could change it without the Commission’s blessing.
She now admits she wasn’t correct. The city could change its vacation-rental laws but the part that is on the coast would need to wait for a change to the Local Coastal Program, which does need Coastal Commission Approval.
She said they could change it and work with Coastal Commission staff to make sure it stuck.
Read more Public Matters stories at kpbs.org/publicmatters
📝Scott Lewis / Voice of San Diego
📷Charlotte Radulovich, Emmy Burrus










