Why I dont accept the papacy @Deflate2020
Why I dont accept the papacy  @Deflate2020
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 17 hours ago
There's a "glitch" in the video at 2:48-2:56. Sorry about that! Also, I hope you'll enjoy my Swiss-German pronunciation of "Eliakim"...

This video is about the key passage that the Catholic Church points to when it comes to the papacy: Matthew 16:13–20.

I’ll explain why I don’t believe that Jesus’ interaction with Peter establishes the office of the pope. In other words, I don’t believe that this passage establishes papal supremacy, apostolic succession, or papal infallibility.

The reason I’m putting out this video is not to “debunk” Catholicism, much less to “go against” my Catholic brothers and sisters. The main motivation for making this video has been Joe Schmid’s conversion. Having followed Joe for a long time and digging into his conversion story, I found myself exposed to more material related to Protestant-Catholic dialogue.

While I initially resisted the “urge” to join that “party,” I eventually decided to put this out there and see what happens.

I believe that our world—and the Church—need more examples of what it means to disagree in love. I also believe that, as Christians, lovingly disagreeing over things that are dear to us is one of the most relevant ways in which we can embody Christlikeness as the Church.

This video is my attempt to make a contribution in that direction. And you are more than welcome to express your disagreement with me.

0:00 Intro & Disclaimers
5:51 The Catholic Case
10:50 My Critique
23:42 A Protestant Interpretation
Why I dont accept the papacyWhats the Trinity? ✨The Unlikely Story Behind This YouTube ChannelBasics of Intelligent Design: Messing with DarwinTiktoker: “Free Will is NOT Biblical!” 🤯Yet Another Bible Contradiction Fail!How Women & Coca-Cola Prove the RESURRECTIONAtheism is NOT a LACK of Belief. SORRY, Atheists!Atheism is NOT a Belief!?Basics of Intelligent Design: Still NO Fossils!!?No, Consciousness is NOT Emergent from Matter!
Deflate |

Why I don't accept the papacy

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER