Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 57 minutes ago
Why did Jesus have to die? And what does his death reveal about the violence at the heart of human society?
In this sermon from Grace Cathedral in San Francisco, Dean Malcolm Clemens Young explores the thought of philosopher René Girard (1923–2015) and his understanding of scapegoating. Girard argues that human beings learn what to desire by imitating others. Our desires become rivalries, our rivalries lead to conflict, and we try to restore order by finding someone to blame.
From ancient sacrificial rituals to modern political conflicts, scapegoating promises peace through exclusion and violence. But the story of Jesus offers a radically different vision. The Christian Gospel tells the story from the perspective of the innocent victim. In the resurrection, God overturns the verdict of the crowd and reveals a way beyond accusation, rivalry, and violence.
Reflecting on Matthew 22:15–22, the commandments against idolatry and coveting, and the meaning of the resurrection, Malcolm asks how we might become citizens of God's kingdom: people who no longer need to compete for power or make enemies of those who are different.
The sermon concludes with a moving story about Toyé Moses, a beloved elder at Grace Cathedral, whose words—“God is on his throne!”—offer hope amid suffering and uncertainty. It also draws on the witness of Archbishop Desmond Tutu and his vision of a God who weeps at human violence and smiles when we care for one another.
Scripture readings
Exodus 33:12–23
Psalm 99
1 Thessalonians 1:1–10
Matthew 22:15–22
Preacher: Malcolm Clemens Young, Dean of Grace CathedralDate: October 18, 2026Location: Grace Cathedral, San Francisco, California
Subscribe for sermons, conversations, and reflections on faith, theology, and the life of the world.
#RenéGirard #Scapegoating #Christianity #GraceCathedral #Resurrection
Why did Jesus have to die? And what does his death reveal about the violence at the heart of human society?
In this sermon from Grace Cathedral in San Francisco, Dean Malcolm Clemens Young explores the thought of philosopher René Girard (1923–2015) and his understanding of scapegoating. Girard argues that human beings learn what to desire by imitating others. Our desires become rivalries, our rivalries lead to conflict, and we try to restore order by finding someone to blame.
From ancient sacrificial rituals to modern political conflicts, scapegoating promises peace through exclusion and violence. But the story of Jesus offers a radically different vision. The Christian Gospel tells the story from the perspective of the innocent victim. In the resurrection, God overturns the verdict of the crowd and reveals a way beyond accusation, rivalry, and violence.
Reflecting on Matthew 22:15–22, the commandments against idolatry and coveting, and the meaning of the resurrection, Malcolm asks how we might become citizens of God's kingdom: people who no longer need to compete for power or make enemies of those who are different.
The sermon concludes with a moving story about Toyé Moses, a beloved elder at Grace Cathedral, whose words—“God is on his throne!”—offer hope amid suffering and uncertainty. It also draws on the witness of Archbishop Desmond Tutu and his vision of a God who weeps at human violence and smiles when we care for one another.
Scripture readings
Exodus 33:12–23
Psalm 99
1 Thessalonians 1:1–10
Matthew 22:15–22
Preacher: Malcolm Clemens Young, Dean of Grace CathedralDate: October 18, 2026Location: Grace Cathedral, San Francisco, California
Subscribe for sermons, conversations, and reflections on faith, theology, and the life of the world.
#RenéGirard #Scapegoating #Christianity #GraceCathedral #Resurrection










