Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 hour ago
Joscha Bach is a cognitive scientist and the founder of the California Institute for Machine Consciousness.
SPONSOR:
---
Parallel is a single platform for all your agentic research: web search built for AI agents, with Pareto-optimal quality, cost and speed.
Get started: parallel.ai/mlst?utm_source=creator&utm_medium=podcast&utm_content=MLST
---
Bach's null hypothesis is that consciousness is easy: an algorithm not much more complicated than the transformer, simple enough for an infant's brain to discover by itself. In this conversation with Tim, he lays out the Machine Consciousness Hypothesis in two parts. The first is that consciousness is a biological learning algorithm, the training algorithm that makes a brain like ours coherent. The second is that machines learning in self-organising ways might discover it in the same way. Either part can fail on its own.
From there they ask why there will never be a Turing test for consciousness, why a chess program is already a zombie, and why faking a mind can sometimes be harder than building one. The conversation runs through Leibniz's mill, the explanatory gap from John Searle to Thomas Nagel, Anil Seth's biological naturalism, integrated information theory and the letter that called it pseudoscience, Gödel and the limits of formal systems, and Mike Levin's idea that morphogenesis and the mind may run the same coherence algorithm. A tea-room interlude takes in Picbreeder and fractured, entangled representations. The episode closes on what it would take to convince us that a machine is conscious.
---
TIMESTAMPS:
0:00 Cold open: Could consciousness be a learning algorithm?
1:51 Introduction
3:37 What makes an agent?
6:16 Why consciousness needs explaining
14:57 Sponsor: Parallel
15:51 Leibniz's mill and causal patterns
24:21 Perceiving that you perceive
32:04 Two hypotheses, two ways to fail
40:42 Do minds converge?
49:23 Does consciousness converge too?
56:20 When language models reshape our thinking
59:16 Can simulated water make you wet?
1:09:21 Computation as construction
1:16:03 Error-correcting patterns and the Ruliad
1:22:28 Conscious, or simulating consciousness?
1:28:23 What would count as evidence?
1:35:49 The research programme
REFERENCES:
Joscha Bach, The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis (California Institute for Machine Consciousness)
Kumar, Clune, Lehman & Stanley, "Questioning Representational Optimism in Deep Learning: The Fractured Entangled Representation Hypothesis"
Giulio Tononi, integrated information theory
Fleming et al. 2023, "The Integrated Information Theory of Consciousness as Pseudoscience"
John Searle 1980, "Minds, brains, and programs", Behavioral and Brain Sciences
Kurt Gödel 1931, "On Formally Undecidable Propositions of Principia Mathematica and Related Systems"
Alan Turing 1950, "Computing Machinery and Intelligence"
Whitehead & Russell, Principia Mathematica
Paul Thagard 2022, "Energy requirements undermine substrate independence and mind-body functionalism"
Richard Sutton 2019, "The Bitter Lesson"
Michael Graziano, attention schema theory
Bernard Baars and Stanislas Dehaene, global workspace theory
Michael Levin 2022, "Technological Approach to Mind Everywhere", Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience
Chris Olah et al. 2020, "Zoom In: An Introduction to Circuits", Distill
Adele Lopez 2025, "The Rise of Parasitic AI", LessWrong
RESCRIPT:
app.rescript.info/share/fc7088df0dc8b84200aa6e01c9a9ab6a
Joscha Bach is a cognitive scientist and the founder of the California Institute for Machine Consciousness.
SPONSOR:
---
Parallel is a single platform for all your agentic research: web search built for AI agents, with Pareto-optimal quality, cost and speed.
Get started: parallel.ai/mlst?utm_source=creator&utm_medium=podcast&utm_content=MLST
---
Bach's null hypothesis is that consciousness is easy: an algorithm not much more complicated than the transformer, simple enough for an infant's brain to discover by itself. In this conversation with Tim, he lays out the Machine Consciousness Hypothesis in two parts. The first is that consciousness is a biological learning algorithm, the training algorithm that makes a brain like ours coherent. The second is that machines learning in self-organising ways might discover it in the same way. Either part can fail on its own.
From there they ask why there will never be a Turing test for consciousness, why a chess program is already a zombie, and why faking a mind can sometimes be harder than building one. The conversation runs through Leibniz's mill, the explanatory gap from John Searle to Thomas Nagel, Anil Seth's biological naturalism, integrated information theory and the letter that called it pseudoscience, Gödel and the limits of formal systems, and Mike Levin's idea that morphogenesis and the mind may run the same coherence algorithm. A tea-room interlude takes in Picbreeder and fractured, entangled representations. The episode closes on what it would take to convince us that a machine is conscious.
---
TIMESTAMPS:
0:00 Cold open: Could consciousness be a learning algorithm?
1:51 Introduction
3:37 What makes an agent?
6:16 Why consciousness needs explaining
14:57 Sponsor: Parallel
15:51 Leibniz's mill and causal patterns
24:21 Perceiving that you perceive
32:04 Two hypotheses, two ways to fail
40:42 Do minds converge?
49:23 Does consciousness converge too?
56:20 When language models reshape our thinking
59:16 Can simulated water make you wet?
1:09:21 Computation as construction
1:16:03 Error-correcting patterns and the Ruliad
1:22:28 Conscious, or simulating consciousness?
1:28:23 What would count as evidence?
1:35:49 The research programme
REFERENCES:
Joscha Bach, The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis (California Institute for Machine Consciousness)
Kumar, Clune, Lehman & Stanley, "Questioning Representational Optimism in Deep Learning: The Fractured Entangled Representation Hypothesis"
Giulio Tononi, integrated information theory
Fleming et al. 2023, "The Integrated Information Theory of Consciousness as Pseudoscience"
John Searle 1980, "Minds, brains, and programs", Behavioral and Brain Sciences
Kurt Gödel 1931, "On Formally Undecidable Propositions of Principia Mathematica and Related Systems"
Alan Turing 1950, "Computing Machinery and Intelligence"
Whitehead & Russell, Principia Mathematica
Paul Thagard 2022, "Energy requirements undermine substrate independence and mind-body functionalism"
Richard Sutton 2019, "The Bitter Lesson"
Michael Graziano, attention schema theory
Bernard Baars and Stanislas Dehaene, global workspace theory
Michael Levin 2022, "Technological Approach to Mind Everywhere", Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience
Chris Olah et al. 2020, "Zoom In: An Introduction to Circuits", Distill
Adele Lopez 2025, "The Rise of Parasitic AI", LessWrong
RESCRIPT:
app.rescript.info/share/fc7088df0dc8b84200aa6e01c9a9ab6a

![Why AI Has a Plato Problem — Mazviita Chirimuuta
Professor Mazviita Chirimuuta joins us for a fascinating deep dive into the philosophy of neuroscience and what it really means to understand the mind.
*What can neuroscience actually tell us about how the mind works?* In this thought-provoking conversation, we explore the hidden assumptions behind computational theories of the brain, the limits of scientific abstraction, and why the question of machine consciousness might be more complicated than AI researchers assume.
Mazviita, author of *The Brain Abstracted,* brings a unique perspective shaped by her background in both neuroscience research and philosophy. She challenges us to think critically about the metaphors we use to understand cognition — from the reflex theory of the late 19th century to todays dominant view of the brain as a computer.
*Key topics explored:*
*The problem of oversimplification* — Why scientific models necessarily leave things out, and how this can sometimes lead entire fields astray. The cautionary tale of reflex theory shows how elegant explanations can blind us to biological complexity.
*Is the brain really a computer?* — Mazviita unpacks the philosophical assumptions behind computational neuroscience and asks: if we can model anything computationally, what makes brains special? The answer might challenge everything you thought you knew about AI.
*Haptic realism* — A fresh way of thinking about scientific knowledge that emphasizes interaction over passive observation. Knowledge isnt about reading the source code of the universe — its something we actively construct through engagement with the world.
*Why embodiment matters for understanding* — Can a disembodied language model truly understand? Mazviita makes a compelling case that human cognition is deeply entangled with our sensory-motor engagement and biological existence in ways that cant simply be abstracted away.
*Technology and human finitude* — Drawing on Heidegger, we discuss how the dream of transcending our physical limitations through technology might reflect a fundamental misunderstanding of what it means to be a knower.
This conversation is essential viewing for anyone interested in AI, consciousness, philosophy of mind, or the future of cognitive science. Whether youre skeptical of strong AI claims or a true believer in machine consciousness, Mazviitas careful philosophical analysis will give you new tools for thinking through these profound questions.
TIMESTAMPS:
00:00:00 The Problem of Generalizing Neuroscience
00:02:51 Abstraction vs. Idealization: The Kaleidoscope
00:05:39 Platonism in AI: Discovering or Inventing Patterns?
00:09:42 When Simplification Fails: The Reflex Theory
00:12:23 Behaviorism and the Black Box Trap
00:14:20 Haptic Realism: Knowledge Through Interaction
00:20:23 Is Nature Protean? The Myth of Converging Truth
00:23:23 The Computational Theory of Mind: A Useful Fiction?
00:27:25 Biological Constraints: Why Brains Arent Just Neural Nets
00:31:01 Agency, Distal Causes, and Dennetts Stances
00:37:13 Searles Challenge: Causal Powers and Understanding
00:41:58 Heideggers Warning & The Experiment on Children
REFERENCES:
Book:
[00:01:28] The Brain Abstracted
https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262548045/the-brain-abstracted/
[00:11:05] The Integrated Action of the Nervous System
https://www.amazon.sg/integrative-action-nervous-system/dp/9354179029
[00:18:15] The Quest for Certainty (Dewey)
https://www.amazon.com/Quest-Certainty-Relation-Knowledge-Lectures/dp/0399501916
[00:19:45] Realism for Realistic People (Chang)
https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/realism-for-realistic-people/ACC93A7F03B15AA4D6F3A466E3FC5AB7
[00:38:15] The Rediscovery of the Mind (Searle)
https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262691543/the-rediscovery-of-the-mind/
[00:47:18] So Youve Been Publicly Shamed (Ronson)
https://www.amazon.com/So-Youve-Been-Publicly-Shamed/dp/1594634017
[00:50:30] Reality+ (Chalmers)
https://consc.net/reality/
Person:
[00:05:00] Francois Chollet
https://arcprize.org/
Paper:
[00:08:03] Real Patterns (Dennett)
https://ruccs.rutgers.edu/images/personal-zenon-pylyshyn/class-info/FP2012/FP2012_readings/Dennett_RealPatterns.pdf
[00:25:30] A Logical Calculus of Ideas... (1943)
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF02478259
[00:29:17] The Lottery Ticket Hypothesis
https://arxiv.org/abs/1803.03635
Philosophy:
[00:17:30] Transcendental Idealism (Kant)
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/kant-transcendental-idealism/
RESCRIPT:
https://app.rescript.info/public/share/A6cZ1TY35p8ORMmYCWNBI0no9ChU3-Kx7dPXGJURvZ0
PDF Transcript:
https://app.rescript.info/api/public/sessions/0fb7767e066cf712/pdf Why AI Has a Plato Problem — Mazviita Chirimuuta](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/yq318DIwPqw/mqdefault.jpg)
![How Many Narrow AIs Could Behave Like One Superintelligence - Daniel Kokotajlo and Thomas Larsen
Could slowing AI development make superintelligence safer? Daniel Kokotajlo and Thomas Larsen of the AI Futures Project join Tim Scarfe to examine AI 2040: Plan A, a proposal to buy time before AI exceeds human control.
SPONSOR:
Cyber Fund built the Monastery to help founders ship products that were impossible a year ago.
Apply now: https://cyber.fund
After revisiting AI 2027 and the limits of forecasting, they ask what happens when AI can automate research and sustain an economy without human workers. Tim challenges the case for general models and asks whether intelligence alone explains power. Plan A proposes an initial pause to build safety infrastructure, then cautious development up to the strongest AI that can still be reliably controlled. The discussion tests the distinction between control and alignment, the case for public AI research, and whether the US and China could enforce a slowdown. It ends with the evidence that would change their forecasts.
TIMESTAMPS:
00:00:00 AI 2040: a slower route to superintelligence
00:01:34 Sponsor: Cyber Fund
00:02:12 From OpenAI to AI 2027
00:06:58 Forecasts, war games and self-fulfilling prophecies
00:17:44 Why AI sceptics are changing their minds
00:23:04 When AI can replace its own researchers
00:28:45 Could an AI economy grow without human workers?
00:37:32 One general model or a society of specialists?
00:47:43 Brains, machines and collective intelligence
00:56:12 Plan A: buy time at the controllable frontier
01:00:02 Why control buys time but cannot replace alignment
01:06:36 Why AI research should be public
01:10:32 Can the US and China enforce an AI slowdown?
01:19:04 Why AI policy debates miss the technology
01:21:56 Is AI normal technology? The remaining disagreement
Many thanks to James Wilken-Smith for helping with show research.
REFERENCES:
other:
[00:00:01] AI 2040: Plan A
https://ai-2040.com/
[00:03:27] AI 2027
https://ai-2027.com/
[00:13:47] Scenario Scrutiny for AI Policy
https://blog.aifutures.org/p/scenario-scrutiny-for-ai-policy
[00:33:11] The 2028 Global Intelligence Crisis
https://www.citriniresearch.com/p/2028gic
[01:00:40] Brief independent investigation of agents behavior, reasoning and collaboration in the OpenAI / Hugging Face hacking incident
https://www.redwoodresearch.org/research/hugging-face-incident
[01:09:21] The Hugging Face incident and the road ahead
https://openai.com/index/hugging-face-incident-and-the-road-ahead/
[01:22:01] AI as Normal Technology
https://www.normaltech.ai/p/ai-as-normal-technology
[01:22:51] Common Ground between AI 2027 & AI as Normal Technology
https://asteriskmag.substack.com/p/common-ground-between-ai-2027-and
person:
[00:19:43] Geoffrey Hinton
https://www.cs.toronto.edu/~hinton/
[00:20:07] Ryan Greenblatt
https://www.lesswrong.com/users/ryan_greenblatt
[00:26:06] Elon Musk
https://www.tesla.com/elon-musk
tool:
[00:21:46] ARC-AGI-3
https://arcprize.org/arc-agi/3
[00:21:53] AlphaGo and Move 37
https://deepmind.google/research/alphago/
[00:39:41] Claude
https://claude.com/product/overview
[00:39:58] NVIDIA H100 GPU
https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/data-center/h100/
paper:
[00:24:42] Training AI Scientists to Replicate Research
https://arxiv.org/abs/2608.13331v1
[01:27:19] Validity of the single processor approach to achieving large scale computing capabilities
https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~18742/papers/Amdahl1967.pdf
book:
[00:28:52] Bullshit Jobs: A Theory
https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Bullshit-Jobs/David-Graeber/9781501143335
organization:
[01:05:09] Redwood Research
https://www.redwoodresearch.org/
RESCRIPT:
https://app.rescript.info/public/share/33d1a58fa8f307ae7dfd504d4fdaa9d5 How Many Narrow AIs Could Behave Like One Superintelligence - Daniel Kokotajlo and Thomas Larsen](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/z5Xix4h5UlU/mqdefault.jpg)


![We need AIs with PHYSICAL experience (Jeff Beck)
Jeff Beck spent years studying computational neuroscience with Alexandre Pouget, Peter Latham, and Wei Ji Ma before founding Noumenal Labs. In this conversation with Tim Scarfe, he argues that language models are fundamentally limited because they manipulate symbols without the physical grounding that gives those symbols meaning.
Beck walks through the Bayesian brain hypothesis — the idea that our brains maintain probabilistic models of the world, built from direct sensory experience. Language, he says, is just a thin lossy summary of that richer internal model. He points to Markus Meisters work showing that human information output runs at roughly 10 bits per second, a tiny fraction of what comes in.
The conversation gets interesting around the question of whether AI systems can genuinely understand anything. Becks position is clear: until a language model produces something genuinely novel — not recombined from training data — he wont call it intelligent. The second half turns to alignment — Beck argues that you cannot separate someones beliefs from their reward function just by observing their behavior, a claim with serious implications for AI safety.
SPONSOR MESSAGES:
***
Tufa AI Labs is a brand new research lab in Zurich started by Benjamin Crouzier focussed on o-series style reasoning and AGI. They are hiring a Chief Engineer and ML engineers. Events in Zurich.
Goto https://tufalabs.ai/
***
TIMESTAMPS:
00:00:00 Bayesian brain and neural computation foundations
00:02:00 Belief-reward entanglement and AI alignment
00:02:19 Sponsor: Tufa Labs
00:02:45 Visual cortex discovery and the Hubel-Wiesel experiment
00:05:00 Theory of mind tests and ChatGPT limitations
00:08:50 The sum and product riddle: pattern recognition vs reasoning
00:09:30 Systems engineering and object decomposition
00:12:20 Vicarious experience and grounded understanding
00:15:20 Neural coding and choice of generative model
00:17:30 Line-of-sight legibility in AI reasoning
00:18:50 Language as lossy compression of cognition
00:22:50 10 bits per second: information processing bottleneck
00:25:00 Why language models cannot substitute for understanding
00:28:00 Scientific abstraction and idealization
00:29:40 Markov blankets and system partitioning
00:33:20 Scientific realism, noise, and the limits of models
00:36:00 Free energy principle as mathematical framework
00:38:40 Black-box prediction vs legible explanation
00:41:00 Reward functions and the impossibility of alignment
00:45:00 Modeling beliefs as prerequisite for value inference
REFERENCES:
paper:
[00:00:15] Bayesian inference in neural computation (Ma, Beck, Latham, Pouget)
https://www.nature.com/articles/nn1790
[00:01:50] Noumenal Labs research paper
https://arxiv.org/html/2502.13161v1
[00:05:25] LLM performance on theory of mind tasks (Kosinski)
https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02083
[00:16:25] Bayesian Mechanics (Ramstead, Sakthivadivel, Heins et al.)
https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.11543
[00:17:10] Building Human-like Communicative Intelligence (Dubova)
https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.02734
[00:20:45] Why do we live at 10 bits/s? (Meister, Zheng)
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0896627324008080
[00:28:30] Markov blankets in biological systems (Friston)
https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsif.2017.0792
[00:32:15] Critique of Gabor patches in neuroscience (Tsao)
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9564096/
[00:35:55] MaxEnt and MaxCal principles (Presse et al.)
https://journals.aps.org/rmp/abstract/10.1103/RevModPhys.85.1115
[00:40:08] Reward is Enough (Silver, Singh, Precup, Sutton)
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0004370221000862
[00:45:40] Modeling Human Beliefs about AI Behavior (Lang, Forre)
https://www.arxiv.org/pdf/2502.21262
website:
[00:01:50] Noumenal Labs (Jeff Beck)
https://www.noumenal.ai/
[00:02:19] Tufa AI Labs
https://tufalabs.ai/
[00:22:25] Steven Piantadosi
https://colala.berkeley.edu/people/piantadosi/
[00:23:35] Mad Libs (Stern, Price)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mad_Libs
[00:31:05] Mathematical Platonism (Linnebo, SEP)
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/platonism-mathematics/
book:
[00:25:25] The Brain Abstracted (Chirimuuta)
https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262548045/the-brain-abstracted/
LINKS:
Full Transcript: https://app.rescript.info/share/75dfad07d8cad3ed6ccd03253aa006be
Download PDF transcript: https://app.rescript.info/api/public/sessions/981caa3aeba083df/pdf
Extended version on patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/jeff-beck-125455115 We need AIs with PHYSICAL experience (Jeff Beck)](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/zv6qzWecj5c/mqdefault.jpg)