Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
In this estimates session with the Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA), I asked whether they can attribute any measurable improvements in education outcomes (such as academic performance or attendance) to its 17-year history.
Mr Gniel defended ACARA's role, clarifying that its KPIs are tied to its legislative functions, namely, developing the national curriculum, administering national assessments (like NAPLAN) and reporting data. He noted that education outcomes are a shared responsibility involving teachers, parents and state education systems.
I raised concerns about state autonomy, referencing New South Wales' "back-to-basics" syllabus reforms from early 2025 and suggesting the national curriculum is overly complex. Mr Gniel responded that all state and territory ministers approved the Australian Curriculum, and that state-level documents are simply a localised framework to enact it.
I asked whether ACARA was pushing "propaganda" and "indoctrination," pointing to Freedom of Information (FOI) documents regarding the UN’s UNESCO Greening Education Partnership. Did ACARA perform due diligence on climate change science integrated into the curriculum? Mr Gniel rejected the premise of indoctrination, stating the curriculum is evidence-based and approved by all education ministers.
Transcript: https://www.malcolmrobertsqld.com.au/who-controls-the-classroom/
In this estimates session with the Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA), I asked whether they can attribute any measurable improvements in education outcomes (such as academic performance or attendance) to its 17-year history.
Mr Gniel defended ACARA's role, clarifying that its KPIs are tied to its legislative functions, namely, developing the national curriculum, administering national assessments (like NAPLAN) and reporting data. He noted that education outcomes are a shared responsibility involving teachers, parents and state education systems.
I raised concerns about state autonomy, referencing New South Wales' "back-to-basics" syllabus reforms from early 2025 and suggesting the national curriculum is overly complex. Mr Gniel responded that all state and territory ministers approved the Australian Curriculum, and that state-level documents are simply a localised framework to enact it.
I asked whether ACARA was pushing "propaganda" and "indoctrination," pointing to Freedom of Information (FOI) documents regarding the UN’s UNESCO Greening Education Partnership. Did ACARA perform due diligence on climate change science integrated into the curriculum? Mr Gniel rejected the premise of indoctrination, stating the curriculum is evidence-based and approved by all education ministers.
Transcript: https://www.malcolmrobertsqld.com.au/who-controls-the-classroom/










