When Skeptics Accidentally Prove Christianity is True @BrianHoldsworth
When Skeptics Accidentally Prove Christianity is True  @BrianHoldsworth
Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
When Christianity is repeatedly condemned for opposite and mutually exclusive faults, that tells us something about the criticism itself.

Support the channel by visiting: brianholdsworth.ca/help

Christianity is too violent but also too pacifist. Too obsessed with sin and judgment but also far too eager to forgive. It hates pleasure and the body, but somehow also surrounds itself with cathedrals, beauty, art, and opulence.

For centuries, critics of Christianity have attacked the faith from opposite direction, sometimes even the same critic making contradictory accusations.

In this video, I look at examples from Nietzsche, Christopher Hitchens, Marx, Engels, and others, and ask what these contradictions actually reveal about Christianity. Perhaps the problem isn't that Christianity occupies every conceivable extreme. Perhaps it's that truth refuses to conform itself to the ideological extremes from which we judge it.

Timestamps
0:00 Nietzsche's attack on Christianity
1:08 Christianity: too violent AND too weak?
2:56 Christopher Hitchens' contradictory criticisms
3:47 Did Christianity oppress or liberate women?
6:40 Too much judgment, too much forgiveness
7:37 Asceticism vs. the "opulence" of the Church
8:49 Marx, Engels, and another contradiction
10:12 Christianity is apparently guilty of everything
10:46 What contradictory criticism actually tells us
11:26 Christian heresies and opposite extremes
12:23 Why truth gets distorted
13:23 Aristotle, virtue, and the mean

Music written and generously provided by Paul Jernberg. Find out more about his work as a composer here: pauljernberg.com

Podcast Version: brianholdsworth.libsyn.com
When Skeptics Accidentally Prove Christianity is TrueCS Lewis Tried to Warn UsProtestants Cant Ignore THIS Scripture Verse AnymoreYoga vs Christianity: A Hidden IncompatibilityProtestantism Needs Catholicism to ExistThe Prophesy of Pope Leo XIVThe Good, Bad, and Ugly of Catholic MediaIs Worship Supposed to Look Like This?Protestants Dont Really Practice Sola ScripturaTrad LARPing is Good, ActuallyI Cant Believe What Were Seeing with Pope Leo XIVJD Vance and the Order of Love
Brian Holdsworth |

When Skeptics Accidentally Prove Christianity is True

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER