Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 19 hours ago
What if the man that we know as Paul McCartney is in fact somebody else altogether? Could it be that the former Beatle was replaced by an imposter in the 1960s who's been living a lie ever since?
In this episode of History’s Greatest Conspiracy Theories, Steven Cockroft – co-host of the Beatles podcast Nothing Is Real – joins Rob Attar to examine one of the most bizarre conspiracy theories to emerge from the world of pop music. In this clip, hear more about the event that sparked the earliest versions of the rumour.
Listen to the full conversation ad-free on the HistoryExtra app or search for 'History's Greatest Conspiracy Theories' wherever you listen to podcasts.
📸 by Getty Images
What if the man that we know as Paul McCartney is in fact somebody else altogether? Could it be that the former Beatle was replaced by an imposter in the 1960s who's been living a lie ever since?
In this episode of History’s Greatest Conspiracy Theories, Steven Cockroft – co-host of the Beatles podcast Nothing Is Real – joins Rob Attar to examine one of the most bizarre conspiracy theories to emerge from the world of pop music. In this clip, hear more about the event that sparked the earliest versions of the rumour.
Listen to the full conversation ad-free on the HistoryExtra app or search for 'History's Greatest Conspiracy Theories' wherever you listen to podcasts.
📸 by Getty Images










