Uploaded January 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
A lot of people have a kind of dualist idea about information—that information is somehow completely different from the physical world.
There is a hint of truth in that. Information can be substrate independent. But it can never be substrate free.
What does that mean?
Genetic information is substrate independent. By that, we mean genetic information can be held in DNA, transferred into RNA, or translated into protein. It does not depend on one single material. But it also does not have unlimited freedom. Those are just three different types of physical substrate that can carry it.
Genetic information is also independent in another sense: it can be copied from parent to child. So it persists across time and across bodies. But it is never substrate free.
Information always has to be held. No matter what kind of information it is, it must exist in a physical form. Otherwise, it is nothing. There is no magic here. Information is not spiritual or immaterial. Information always has a physical substrate.
Because of that, information transfer is a physical process, and physical processes have physical limitations.
You could imagine a system that transfers information extremely well, but it would still require energy. It would still require real structures to be built in the bodies of the sender and the receiver. Those structures would likely need to interface deeply with the nervous system of both.
None of this happens for free. Information transfer is a physical process.
A lot of people have a kind of dualist idea about information—that information is somehow completely different from the physical world.
There is a hint of truth in that. Information can be substrate independent. But it can never be substrate free.
What does that mean?
Genetic information is substrate independent. By that, we mean genetic information can be held in DNA, transferred into RNA, or translated into protein. It does not depend on one single material. But it also does not have unlimited freedom. Those are just three different types of physical substrate that can carry it.
Genetic information is also independent in another sense: it can be copied from parent to child. So it persists across time and across bodies. But it is never substrate free.
Information always has to be held. No matter what kind of information it is, it must exist in a physical form. Otherwise, it is nothing. There is no magic here. Information is not spiritual or immaterial. Information always has a physical substrate.
Because of that, information transfer is a physical process, and physical processes have physical limitations.
You could imagine a system that transfers information extremely well, but it would still require energy. It would still require real structures to be built in the bodies of the sender and the receiver. Those structures would likely need to interface deeply with the nervous system of both.
None of this happens for free. Information transfer is a physical process.










