Uploaded September 2025 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
In this video, Professor Thorsby offers an overview of what an argument is.
To reason is to move. But to move with purpose—toward truth, toward clarity—we must understand what gives reasoning its structure. That structure is the argument. It is not a quarrel. It is not a fight. It is a form. An argument is a pattern of reasoning in which one or more statements (called premises) are offered as support for another statement (called the conclusion).
To give an argument is to say: “This is what I claim—and here is why.”
An argument consists of two parts:
(1) Premise(s): The reasons or evidence.
(2) Conclusion: The claim being supported.
In logic, we typically list the premises first, followed by a line, then the conclusion, or with the symbol ∴ (therefore), which signals the point of inference. This vertical format allows us to isolate the structure clearly. In general, our premises are always written above the conclusion. In some books you will see a line between the premises and the conclusion.
When analyzing arguments, it helps to recognize certain words or phrases that act as signals—they indicate whether a statement is a premise or a conclusion. These are known as indicator terms, and while they do not guarantee an argument is valid or sound, they help us locate the structure of reasoning in natural language. It is important to recognize indicator terms because it is how we identify what the reasons are from the conclusion of an argument. In ordinary language, we rarely order our ideas in the most logical manner, or follow the convention of stating the conclusion last. Indicator terms do not change the truth or form of an argument, but they are tools of orientation. Like signposts on a trail, they help us follow the path of reasoning more clearly.
Why Use Symbols?
Symbols are the shorthand of reasoning. As logic becomes more formal, we use symbols to represent the form of arguments—stripping away the content to examine the structure alone.
All A are B.
All B are C.
∴ All A are C.
We do not do this to make things obscure—but to make them clear. The form is what matters.
Inference and Necessity
The movement from premises to conclusion is called an inference. This is where logic lives: in the connection between ideas. An inference may be strong or weak, probable or necessary. In formal logic, we are concerned with deductive inference, where the conclusion follows with necessity. Necessity means that the link between a premise and conclusion is absolute and does not depend upon our knowledge of the world or the likelihood of things. Consider the following:
All humans are mortal.
Socrates is a human.
∴ Socrates is mortal.
If the premises are true, then the conclusion must be true. This is the gold standard of inference in logic. In fact, the necessity between the premises and the conclusion in the argument argument does not depend on whether the statements are true, but is rooted in the form and structure of the argument itself. This is the focus of formal logic.
Truth-Functionality
Logic, especially formal logic, is truth-functional. This means that the validity of an argument depends on the truth values of its parts and how those parts are arranged.
Let’s look at a simple case in ordinary language:
If it is raining, then the streets are wet.
It is raining.
∴ The streets are wet.
This inference depends only on the truth of the pieces and the form of the pattern. The actual subject (rain, streets) is irrelevant to the logical relation. We will see that we can make arguments, but the strength and validity of an argument depends on the idea that the truth functionality of an argument is airtight becomes it is truth-functional. We can truth as something that flows from the premises to the conclusion. We, as human beings, have a tremendous ability to recognize this story of truth functionality and infer conclusions. Inference depends upon the truth-functionality of an argument.
We can express the same argument symbolically:
If P, then Q.
P.
∴ Q.
This is one of the basic argument forms we will study, known as modus ponens (Mediaeval logicians gave this argument form a latin name).
Types of Arguments
While logic focuses on deductive reasoning, it’s worth noting that arguments come in many forms. We will learn about these argument types in an upcoming lesson, but its important to recognize that there are different types of arguments. These include:
Deductive Arguments: The conclusion necessarily follows from the premises.
Inductive Arguments: The premises support the conclusion with some degree of probability.
Abductive Arguments: The conclusion is the best explanation of the premises.
In this course, we will focus mostly on deductive logic, because it provides the clearest foundation for studying the structure of reasoning.
In this video, Professor Thorsby offers an overview of what an argument is.
To reason is to move. But to move with purpose—toward truth, toward clarity—we must understand what gives reasoning its structure. That structure is the argument. It is not a quarrel. It is not a fight. It is a form. An argument is a pattern of reasoning in which one or more statements (called premises) are offered as support for another statement (called the conclusion).
To give an argument is to say: “This is what I claim—and here is why.”
An argument consists of two parts:
(1) Premise(s): The reasons or evidence.
(2) Conclusion: The claim being supported.
In logic, we typically list the premises first, followed by a line, then the conclusion, or with the symbol ∴ (therefore), which signals the point of inference. This vertical format allows us to isolate the structure clearly. In general, our premises are always written above the conclusion. In some books you will see a line between the premises and the conclusion.
When analyzing arguments, it helps to recognize certain words or phrases that act as signals—they indicate whether a statement is a premise or a conclusion. These are known as indicator terms, and while they do not guarantee an argument is valid or sound, they help us locate the structure of reasoning in natural language. It is important to recognize indicator terms because it is how we identify what the reasons are from the conclusion of an argument. In ordinary language, we rarely order our ideas in the most logical manner, or follow the convention of stating the conclusion last. Indicator terms do not change the truth or form of an argument, but they are tools of orientation. Like signposts on a trail, they help us follow the path of reasoning more clearly.
Why Use Symbols?
Symbols are the shorthand of reasoning. As logic becomes more formal, we use symbols to represent the form of arguments—stripping away the content to examine the structure alone.
All A are B.
All B are C.
∴ All A are C.
We do not do this to make things obscure—but to make them clear. The form is what matters.
Inference and Necessity
The movement from premises to conclusion is called an inference. This is where logic lives: in the connection between ideas. An inference may be strong or weak, probable or necessary. In formal logic, we are concerned with deductive inference, where the conclusion follows with necessity. Necessity means that the link between a premise and conclusion is absolute and does not depend upon our knowledge of the world or the likelihood of things. Consider the following:
All humans are mortal.
Socrates is a human.
∴ Socrates is mortal.
If the premises are true, then the conclusion must be true. This is the gold standard of inference in logic. In fact, the necessity between the premises and the conclusion in the argument argument does not depend on whether the statements are true, but is rooted in the form and structure of the argument itself. This is the focus of formal logic.
Truth-Functionality
Logic, especially formal logic, is truth-functional. This means that the validity of an argument depends on the truth values of its parts and how those parts are arranged.
Let’s look at a simple case in ordinary language:
If it is raining, then the streets are wet.
It is raining.
∴ The streets are wet.
This inference depends only on the truth of the pieces and the form of the pattern. The actual subject (rain, streets) is irrelevant to the logical relation. We will see that we can make arguments, but the strength and validity of an argument depends on the idea that the truth functionality of an argument is airtight becomes it is truth-functional. We can truth as something that flows from the premises to the conclusion. We, as human beings, have a tremendous ability to recognize this story of truth functionality and infer conclusions. Inference depends upon the truth-functionality of an argument.
We can express the same argument symbolically:
If P, then Q.
P.
∴ Q.
This is one of the basic argument forms we will study, known as modus ponens (Mediaeval logicians gave this argument form a latin name).
Types of Arguments
While logic focuses on deductive reasoning, it’s worth noting that arguments come in many forms. We will learn about these argument types in an upcoming lesson, but its important to recognize that there are different types of arguments. These include:
Deductive Arguments: The conclusion necessarily follows from the premises.
Inductive Arguments: The premises support the conclusion with some degree of probability.
Abductive Arguments: The conclusion is the best explanation of the premises.
In this course, we will focus mostly on deductive logic, because it provides the clearest foundation for studying the structure of reasoning.










