What do Grant Proposal Reviews for Math look like? Behind the Scenes @JoelRosenfeld
What do Grant Proposal Reviews for Math look like? Behind the Scenes  @JoelRosenfeld
Uploaded July 2021 | Updated September 2026, 1 day ago
As I prepare my NSF CAREER proposal, I take a look back at some of my failures and successes with NSF awards. I am doing my best to learn from the critical responses that I have received from previous reviews to help improve what I am doing now.

The CAREER award is a bit more higher profile of an award than what I have previously achieved at the NSF, so I want to put my best foot forward.

I have an award at the program I am submitting to, and so that gives me a good idea of how it will be received (provided I can sufficiently demonstrate that this is different than what is currently funded). But man... some reviewers are brutal in their reviews, which I cover in the video.

Music:
Come 2gether by Ooyy
Our Skies by Cacti
Our Last Stand by FormantiX
Wrong by Dan Henig
Guardians + Tex by Craig Hardgrove
What do Grant Proposal Reviews for Math look like? Behind the ScenesScience, Toys, and the PCAA Strangely Deep Problem about Sequenceslearning math in old ageFixed Point Iteration - Loki SLAPPED 16 times for SCIENCE!The ONE integral everyone should knowDMD Explained! (Dynamic Mode Decomposition)All that work for nothing! The Polylogarithmic Hardy Spacehe wrote this in secretGetting caught with facial recognition - How SVDs are used in Facial Recognition SoftwareTomography - Hilbert Spaces and OrthogonalityNailing the Job Talk
ThatMathThing |

What do Grant Proposal Reviews for Math look like? Behind the Scenes

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER