Uploaded May 2022 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
I've had this video ready for a while, I've just been procrastinating on actually publishing it, so sorry for making you guys wait.
Anyways, I really enjoyed the first book for Warrior Cats: A Starless Clan. River was a great start to the new arc and did a pretty good job of introducing all of the new characters. The overall story was great and felt very fresh compared to other warrior cats books, with all of the conflict being within the clans rather than focusing on cats outside of the clans (or the dark forest... so far at least). Below are my thoughts on each of the new protagonists; IT DOES CONTAIN SPOILERS FOR RIVER, you've been warned.
Flamepaw: Flamepaw is my favorite of the three protagonists. I love his personality; its been a while since we had a cat who was more rude and grumpy; reminds me a lot of Jayfeather. Anyways, I really enjoy his story, and how he's upset with everyone comparing him to his relatives rather than appreciate him for who he is. I love his relationship with his mother and his foster family, it's super interesting and not something we get a lot in Warrior Cats. I also really like his new name, Nightheart, it suits him very well, in my opinion. I can't wait to see where the Erins take him in the next book.
Frostpaw: I really enjoy Frostpaws chapters and all of the chaos that's happening in Riverclan. I love that they actually killed off Mistystar and Reedwhisker. And Curlfeather's death was so sad. However, with all of these things happening, it's a bit hard to tell who Frostpaw is as a person, she doesn't have much of a chance to show off any personality in this book. Hopefully that changes in future books.
Sunbeam: Sunbeam's probably my least favorite of the three, but I do still love her. I feel like she seems too much like a repeat of Bristlefrost, with her breakup with Blazefire and the possibility that they might be setting her up to become mates with Nightheart. Besides that, I am enjoying the drama in Shadowclan with Berryheart and her friend group and with Fringewhisker joining Shadowclan to be mates with Spireclaw; I'm very excited to see how that pans out.
If you actually read all of this, thank you so much for reading my rambling. I would very much love to hear your guys' opinions on the book or characters as well as any theories for the next one.
Anyways, see you guys later. I've been working on an animation meme for WoF that should hopefully be out soon (if I don't procrastinate on that as well). Have a good day/night.
Technical Stuff:
Drawings and Thumbnail: IbisPaintX
Edited with: YouCut
Music: youtu.be/0uOPrIMqKoY
Music from Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/hartzmann/paradise-island
License code: DEH2O82AN2V6GLVZ
I've had this video ready for a while, I've just been procrastinating on actually publishing it, so sorry for making you guys wait.
Anyways, I really enjoyed the first book for Warrior Cats: A Starless Clan. River was a great start to the new arc and did a pretty good job of introducing all of the new characters. The overall story was great and felt very fresh compared to other warrior cats books, with all of the conflict being within the clans rather than focusing on cats outside of the clans (or the dark forest... so far at least). Below are my thoughts on each of the new protagonists; IT DOES CONTAIN SPOILERS FOR RIVER, you've been warned.
Flamepaw: Flamepaw is my favorite of the three protagonists. I love his personality; its been a while since we had a cat who was more rude and grumpy; reminds me a lot of Jayfeather. Anyways, I really enjoy his story, and how he's upset with everyone comparing him to his relatives rather than appreciate him for who he is. I love his relationship with his mother and his foster family, it's super interesting and not something we get a lot in Warrior Cats. I also really like his new name, Nightheart, it suits him very well, in my opinion. I can't wait to see where the Erins take him in the next book.
Frostpaw: I really enjoy Frostpaws chapters and all of the chaos that's happening in Riverclan. I love that they actually killed off Mistystar and Reedwhisker. And Curlfeather's death was so sad. However, with all of these things happening, it's a bit hard to tell who Frostpaw is as a person, she doesn't have much of a chance to show off any personality in this book. Hopefully that changes in future books.
Sunbeam: Sunbeam's probably my least favorite of the three, but I do still love her. I feel like she seems too much like a repeat of Bristlefrost, with her breakup with Blazefire and the possibility that they might be setting her up to become mates with Nightheart. Besides that, I am enjoying the drama in Shadowclan with Berryheart and her friend group and with Fringewhisker joining Shadowclan to be mates with Spireclaw; I'm very excited to see how that pans out.
If you actually read all of this, thank you so much for reading my rambling. I would very much love to hear your guys' opinions on the book or characters as well as any theories for the next one.
Anyways, see you guys later. I've been working on an animation meme for WoF that should hopefully be out soon (if I don't procrastinate on that as well). Have a good day/night.
Technical Stuff:
Drawings and Thumbnail: IbisPaintX
Edited with: YouCut
Music: youtu.be/0uOPrIMqKoY
Music from Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/hartzmann/paradise-island
License code: DEH2O82AN2V6GLVZ





