Viable, Even if Not Valid  Greg Neimeyer on Diagnosis, Dimensions, and the Future of the DSM @PsychotherapyNet
Viable, Even if Not Valid  Greg Neimeyer on Diagnosis, Dimensions, and the Future of the DSM  @PsychotherapyNet
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Most of us were trained to live inside the DSM, but the DSM is literally extracted from the ICD, and the two systems are now being pushed to harmonize. In this episode, Travis Heath talks with Dr. Greg Neimeyer, CEO of the Performance CE Institute, longtime University of Florida psychology professor, and former APA associate executive director for continuing education, about what that convergence means for how we diagnose. Greg, a constructivist with a deep working knowledge of psychiatric diagnosis, traces the shift from categorical to dimensional models, the DSM's politics and constraints, the role culture and social context play in diagnosis, past and present, and the power of a label to bring relief or to harden into identity. They close by imagining what diagnosis might look like if we designed it from the ground up.

Topics and questions covered

~00:03:32 Why therapists should care about what's happening with the DSM and ICD

~00:03:49 From a psychoanalytic DSM to DSM-5-TR: how fast diagnosis has changed

~00:04:55 The DSM as the "Adam's rib" of the ICD, open access vs. proprietary, and the push to harmonize

~00:07:04 Where they still diverge: complex PTSD

~00:07:58 What dimensional diagnosis means in practice, and why it matters (the categorical problem, with depression as the example)

~00:09:51 Why personality disorders and eating disorders were expected to go dimensional first

~00:12:00 ICD-11 drops categorical personality disorders; why the DSM has been slower to follow

~00:12:50 The DSM's constraints: conservatism, revenue, and the problem of choosing dimensions (including proprietary systems like Millon's)

~00:16:40 What it means to call a diagnostic system "scientific": Spitzer's pillars, multiaxial, and the neurobiological assumption

~00:19:42 The APA's Future of the DSM Strategic Committee and its Cultural and Environmental Determinants subcommittee

~00:21:22 Social determinants of health, Z codes, and how context shapes presentation

~00:22:22 Hysteria and "idioms of distress": diagnoses as culturally contingent

~00:23:38 Do dimensions really shift the medical model? The DSM's biological retreat and its biomarkers subcommittee

~00:25:33 Diagnosis and power, and the practicum story of a client reading his file

~00:28:51 When a label brings relief; "viable" vs. "valid"

~00:30:58 When diagnoses become identities, and narrative therapy's externalization

~00:33:34 The gap between reimbursement language and clinical language, and the role of clinical utility and functioning

~00:38:30 AI and diagnostic reliability, including speech-based biomarkers

~00:41:52 Rethinking diagnosis from the ground up: problems in living, a place for biologically driven disorders, and whole-person models

~00:44:42 Closing: moving past "pro-DSM" and "anti-DSM" camps

Resources and mentions

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition, Text Revision (DSM-5-TR), American Psychiatric Association

International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10 and ICD-11), World Health Organization

The DSM-5 hybrid dimensional-categorical model for personality disorders, and ICD-11's dimensional personality disorder model

Complex PTSD (recognized in ICD-11, not in the DSM)

Robert Spitzer and the DSM-III's evidence-based, atheoretical approach

Theodore Millon's multiaxial personality system (a proprietary dimensional approach)

Hans Vaihinger and the philosophy of "functional fictions"

The APA's Future of the DSM Strategic Committee (dimensional diagnosis, cultural and environmental determinants, biomarkers, and clinical utility)

Social determinants of health and ICD Z codes

Michael White and narrative therapy (externalization of the problem)

Connect with Dr. Greg Neimeyer

Website: performancece.org

LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/greg-neimeyer-536493111

About Therapist Confidential

Therapist Confidential is a psychotherapy.net podcast hosted by Travis Heath. Listen and find more episodes at psychotherapy.net/perspectives/podcasts
Viable, Even if Not Valid  Greg Neimeyer on Diagnosis, Dimensions, and the Future of the DSMNiche Is Normal  Stefanie Goerlich on Kink, Consent, and SexualityTwo Kinds of Pain - ACT in ActionHolding the Mirror Up to Systems That Fail Us: Treating Eating Disorders with Kim Fry“Why Can’t You Talk to Me the Way You Text Me ” Couples Therapy in the Age of AIFlipping the Script - Therapist ConfidentialThe System Wasnt Built for You  Elijah Murphy on Hope, Racism, and PhDing While BlackFindamentals of Clinical Supervision vol 1From Chaos to Context: Treating Family Violence and IncestDigital Play Therapy - Therapist ConfidentialResponsibility - Irvin Yalom on Psychotherapy and WritingDownsides of Diagnosis - Irvin Yalom and the Art of Psychotherapy
PsychotherapyNet |

Viable, Even if Not Valid Greg Neimeyer on Diagnosis, Dimensions, and the Future of the DSM

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER