Uploaded September 2025 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
In this video, Professor Thorsby discusses "Value in Nature and the Value of Nature" by Holmes Rolston III.
Okay, by this point we have learned some ideas about non-anthropocentrism. But even if nature has intrinsic value - what does that mean? What is a value / values, and where do they come from? I this lesson we will explore precisely this. Thoreau and Muir helped shift American thought away from strict anthropocentrism by affirming the worth of wilderness. Our next philosopher, Holmes Rolston deepens that turn: he argues not merely that nature matters to us, but that nature itself produces value—values that precede and outrun human preferences—so ethical consideration must extend to organisms, species, ecosystems, and the Earth as a whole. Where Thoreau’s and Muir’s voices are often poetic and activist, Rolston’s intervention is systematic and philosophical, bridging environmental ethics with ecology and evolutionary biology. His central claim is that value shows up along life’s own trajectories, not only in human appraisals.
Holmes Rolston III (b. 1932) is a pioneering figure in environmental ethics and longtime professor at Colorado State University. Trained across theology, philosophy, and the sciences, Rolston’s work helped found environmental ethics as an academic field. He received the Templeton Prize (1992) for contributions integrating science, ethics, and religion.
Some of his influential books include Philosophy Gone Wild (1986) and Environmental Ethics: Duties to and Values in the Natural World (1988). Across these and later writings, Rolston argues that evolution, ecology, and life itself generate intrinsic value, which humans are bound to recognize and respect.
Some of the Key Ideas From this Essay
Intrinsic value in living things. Organisms actively maintain and defend their own lives. Animals and even plants display a kind of “self-valuing” through goal-directed persistence. From organisms to systems. Value is not only in individuals; ecological systems generate and sustain values. Rolston emphasizes a triad—intrinsic, instrumental, and systemic—with systemic value as foundational. Planetary lens. Seen from space, Earth is a creative, self-organizing system that births life and all Earth-bound values—hence plausibly “the most valuable entity,” not merely a stock of resources.
Against “value only when humans arrive.” Rolston resists the view that value exists only when “lit” by human minds; nature’s creativity yields value prior to and independent of our appraisals. Hierarchies without reduction. Values interlock across levels (organism → species-line → ecosystem → biosphere). Higher-level goods do not erase the standing of lower-level goods.
Rolston’s Argument's
We can summarize his argument in the following steps: (1) Begin with what few deny: humans value things. Many philosophers infer that all value is therefore relative to human valuers. (2) Rolston challenges that inference by probing what “intrinsic” could mean and by warning against the assumption that nothing is valuable apart from human conferral. (3) He widens the lens to animals, who pursue and defend their lives; the best interpretation is that life values itself, not merely that it serves human ends. (4) He pushes further to plants, highlighting their teleonomic self-maintenance—growth, repair, defense, signaling—as objective organization that it is apt to call valuable. (5) From organisms he moves to species-lines and ecosystems, arguing that values interlock across levels and that systemic creativity underwrites both intrinsic and instrumental value. (6) Finally, he scales up to Earth as a system-of-systems: a biosphere uniquely capable of producing life and hence the entire field of Earth-bound value. Therefore, Earth plausibly commands the highest moral regard in environmental ethics. In this regard we see that not only is our environment valuable - it is the source of value itself. It goes therefore without saying that the environment commands our moral attention.
In this video, Professor Thorsby discusses "Value in Nature and the Value of Nature" by Holmes Rolston III.
Okay, by this point we have learned some ideas about non-anthropocentrism. But even if nature has intrinsic value - what does that mean? What is a value / values, and where do they come from? I this lesson we will explore precisely this. Thoreau and Muir helped shift American thought away from strict anthropocentrism by affirming the worth of wilderness. Our next philosopher, Holmes Rolston deepens that turn: he argues not merely that nature matters to us, but that nature itself produces value—values that precede and outrun human preferences—so ethical consideration must extend to organisms, species, ecosystems, and the Earth as a whole. Where Thoreau’s and Muir’s voices are often poetic and activist, Rolston’s intervention is systematic and philosophical, bridging environmental ethics with ecology and evolutionary biology. His central claim is that value shows up along life’s own trajectories, not only in human appraisals.
Holmes Rolston III (b. 1932) is a pioneering figure in environmental ethics and longtime professor at Colorado State University. Trained across theology, philosophy, and the sciences, Rolston’s work helped found environmental ethics as an academic field. He received the Templeton Prize (1992) for contributions integrating science, ethics, and religion.
Some of his influential books include Philosophy Gone Wild (1986) and Environmental Ethics: Duties to and Values in the Natural World (1988). Across these and later writings, Rolston argues that evolution, ecology, and life itself generate intrinsic value, which humans are bound to recognize and respect.
Some of the Key Ideas From this Essay
Intrinsic value in living things. Organisms actively maintain and defend their own lives. Animals and even plants display a kind of “self-valuing” through goal-directed persistence. From organisms to systems. Value is not only in individuals; ecological systems generate and sustain values. Rolston emphasizes a triad—intrinsic, instrumental, and systemic—with systemic value as foundational. Planetary lens. Seen from space, Earth is a creative, self-organizing system that births life and all Earth-bound values—hence plausibly “the most valuable entity,” not merely a stock of resources.
Against “value only when humans arrive.” Rolston resists the view that value exists only when “lit” by human minds; nature’s creativity yields value prior to and independent of our appraisals. Hierarchies without reduction. Values interlock across levels (organism → species-line → ecosystem → biosphere). Higher-level goods do not erase the standing of lower-level goods.
Rolston’s Argument's
We can summarize his argument in the following steps: (1) Begin with what few deny: humans value things. Many philosophers infer that all value is therefore relative to human valuers. (2) Rolston challenges that inference by probing what “intrinsic” could mean and by warning against the assumption that nothing is valuable apart from human conferral. (3) He widens the lens to animals, who pursue and defend their lives; the best interpretation is that life values itself, not merely that it serves human ends. (4) He pushes further to plants, highlighting their teleonomic self-maintenance—growth, repair, defense, signaling—as objective organization that it is apt to call valuable. (5) From organisms he moves to species-lines and ecosystems, arguing that values interlock across levels and that systemic creativity underwrites both intrinsic and instrumental value. (6) Finally, he scales up to Earth as a system-of-systems: a biosphere uniquely capable of producing life and hence the entire field of Earth-bound value. Therefore, Earth plausibly commands the highest moral regard in environmental ethics. In this regard we see that not only is our environment valuable - it is the source of value itself. It goes therefore without saying that the environment commands our moral attention.










