Uploaded January 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Haters of Intelligent Design use a variety of false and misleading arguments against ID claims. Some are more crafty than others, and one is the claim that ID improbability arguments are rooted in after-the-fact or Texas Sharpshooter improbability arguments.
But before I explain what "after-the-fact" and "Texas Sharpshooter" arguments are, let me revisit a challenge I posed to evolutionary biologist Nick Matzke (of Kitzmiller vs. Dover 2005 fame).
A simple example of an ID improbability argument I posed to evolutionary biologists Nick Matzke which he could NOT refute was "if you came across a table with 500 fair coins, and all of them were showing heads, was that the result of a random [stochastic] process?"
He should have said, "NO", but he couldn't bring himself to say so! Why was that so uncomfortable. See my description of this landmark historical exchange between and ID proponent and an evolutionary biologist:
youtube.com/watch?v=2UeLhWjVw8Q
The corresponding reddit post was here:
reddit.com/r/Creation/comments/1qrmab5/comment/o2q1czf
A video of the episode with Nick Matzke pointing to original documents is here:
youtube.com/watch?v=2UeLhWjVw8Q
The original exchange with Nick Matzke
uncommondescent.com/intelligent-design/a-statistics-question-for-nick-matzke
The videos of Dr. Dan making basic biochemistry errors is here:
youtube.com/watch?v=njkZuzbS6oM
youtube.com/watch?v=OyuqfkuVTMM
Haters of Intelligent Design use a variety of false and misleading arguments against ID claims. Some are more crafty than others, and one is the claim that ID improbability arguments are rooted in after-the-fact or Texas Sharpshooter improbability arguments.
But before I explain what "after-the-fact" and "Texas Sharpshooter" arguments are, let me revisit a challenge I posed to evolutionary biologist Nick Matzke (of Kitzmiller vs. Dover 2005 fame).
A simple example of an ID improbability argument I posed to evolutionary biologists Nick Matzke which he could NOT refute was "if you came across a table with 500 fair coins, and all of them were showing heads, was that the result of a random [stochastic] process?"
He should have said, "NO", but he couldn't bring himself to say so! Why was that so uncomfortable. See my description of this landmark historical exchange between and ID proponent and an evolutionary biologist:
youtube.com/watch?v=2UeLhWjVw8Q
The corresponding reddit post was here:
reddit.com/r/Creation/comments/1qrmab5/comment/o2q1czf
A video of the episode with Nick Matzke pointing to original documents is here:
youtube.com/watch?v=2UeLhWjVw8Q
The original exchange with Nick Matzke
uncommondescent.com/intelligent-design/a-statistics-question-for-nick-matzke
The videos of Dr. Dan making basic biochemistry errors is here:
youtube.com/watch?v=njkZuzbS6oM
youtube.com/watch?v=OyuqfkuVTMM










