Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
On this week's episode of New York's Best Bagel, host Henry Rosoff held "The Ultimate Bagel" (Battle... Battle... Battle...)
Rosoff has given out two top scores of "10 Bagels" after nearly 50 reviews to Apollo Bagels and Caputo Bagels.
First was a standard tasting of an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. Caputo came out on top here largely because it held up after being transported across the city for the tasting. Flavors were similar, Apollo's cream cheese had a bit more scallion, but Caputo won on texture.
Apollo's tomato bagel sandwich was the winner of the second part of the comparison which looked at a signature offering for each shop. Caputo's Lard Bagel with salami and cheese was excellent, although it did not present as a classic bagel sandwich. It was more of an amazing baked good-- a tribute to the legendary but now shuttered bakery that bore the Caputo name. Apollo's tomato with salt and pepper on a bagel with cream cheese was fresh and tasty and channeled more traditional bagel sandwich vibes.
Ultimately Rosoff put more weight on the first part of the comparison-- though it was extremely close-- Caputo was named the winner of the "ultimate bagel battle."
On this week's episode of New York's Best Bagel, host Henry Rosoff held "The Ultimate Bagel" (Battle... Battle... Battle...)
Rosoff has given out two top scores of "10 Bagels" after nearly 50 reviews to Apollo Bagels and Caputo Bagels.
First was a standard tasting of an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. Caputo came out on top here largely because it held up after being transported across the city for the tasting. Flavors were similar, Apollo's cream cheese had a bit more scallion, but Caputo won on texture.
Apollo's tomato bagel sandwich was the winner of the second part of the comparison which looked at a signature offering for each shop. Caputo's Lard Bagel with salami and cheese was excellent, although it did not present as a classic bagel sandwich. It was more of an amazing baked good-- a tribute to the legendary but now shuttered bakery that bore the Caputo name. Apollo's tomato with salt and pepper on a bagel with cream cheese was fresh and tasty and channeled more traditional bagel sandwich vibes.
Ultimately Rosoff put more weight on the first part of the comparison-- though it was extremely close-- Caputo was named the winner of the "ultimate bagel battle."










