Uploaded August 2024 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Robert Kagan, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and a member of the Council on Foreign Relations, discusses the delicate balance required in practicing democracy to mitigate tribal instincts, while also addressing concerns about excessive democracy. He reflects on historical reforms in the Democratic and Republican primaries, highlighting the implications of fully democratized candidate selection. Kagan argues for more democracy in the overall system but prefers less democracy within party primaries, suggesting a return to more controlled candidate vetting to avoid extreme outcomes.
00:00 Introduction to Democracy and Tribal Instincts
00:27 Balancing Democracy: Too Much or Too Little?
00:44 Party Primaries: A Case of Too Much Democracy
00:57 Historical Reforms in Democratic Party Primaries
01:32 Superdelegates and Republican Primary System
01:49 The Argument for Smoke-Filled Rooms
02:25 The Impact of Democratic Systems on Candidate Selection
02:39 The Small Fraction of Primary Voters
02:47 Republican Party's Control Issues
02:57 More Democracy in the Larger System
03:02 Obstacles to Democracy: The Filibuster
03:29 Conclusion: Less Democracy in Primaries
Full lecture here: youtube.com/live/Ff2ECItNLDM
Robert Kagan, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and a member of the Council on Foreign Relations, discusses the delicate balance required in practicing democracy to mitigate tribal instincts, while also addressing concerns about excessive democracy. He reflects on historical reforms in the Democratic and Republican primaries, highlighting the implications of fully democratized candidate selection. Kagan argues for more democracy in the overall system but prefers less democracy within party primaries, suggesting a return to more controlled candidate vetting to avoid extreme outcomes.
00:00 Introduction to Democracy and Tribal Instincts
00:27 Balancing Democracy: Too Much or Too Little?
00:44 Party Primaries: A Case of Too Much Democracy
00:57 Historical Reforms in Democratic Party Primaries
01:32 Superdelegates and Republican Primary System
01:49 The Argument for Smoke-Filled Rooms
02:25 The Impact of Democratic Systems on Candidate Selection
02:39 The Small Fraction of Primary Voters
02:47 Republican Party's Control Issues
02:57 More Democracy in the Larger System
03:02 Obstacles to Democracy: The Filibuster
03:29 Conclusion: Less Democracy in Primaries
Full lecture here: youtube.com/live/Ff2ECItNLDM










