This ATR 42 Should Not Have Been Here — What Happened? @FlywithMagnar
This ATR 42 Should Not Have Been Here — What Happened?  @FlywithMagnar
Uploaded January 2026 | Updated November 2026, 5 days ago
On January 17, 2026, aviation was shaken by the tragic loss of an ATR 42-500 aircraft operated by Air Indonesia Transport near Makassar, Indonesia. In this video, ATR instructor and former captain Magnar Nordal breaks down everything we currently know about the accident — and what remains unanswered.

My deepest condolences go out to the families, friends, and colleagues of those affected.

Social Links 🔗
instagram.com/flywithmagnar
facebook.com/groups/flywithmagnar
linkedin.com/in/magnar-nordal
youtube.com/@FlywithMagnar

"New Moon" 🎵
🎼 Created and produced by Miho Terachi.
🎷 Performed by Miho Terachi (sax) and Marie Takeda (piano).
🎙️ Recorded at Sparkling Studio, Japan.
youtube.com/@TerachiMiho

The aircraft, registered PK-THT, was originally delivered to Air Dolomiti in 2000 before being transferred to Air Indonesia Transport in 2010. After operating for many years in passenger service, it was converted into an airborne surveillance platform in 2025 and was flying under contract for Indonesia’s Marine and Fisheries Resources Surveillance Agency at the time of the accident.

The flight departed Yogyakarta at 01:09 UTC with 11 people on board and conducted a low-level surveillance mission over the Java Sea before climbing and continuing toward Sultan Hasanuddin Airport in Makassar. Radar data shows the aircraft was cleared for an ILS approach to Runway 21, yet it ultimately disappeared from radar and was later found at the foot of Mount Bulusaraung — terrain with a minimum safe altitude of 7,000 feet.

Why did a modern turboprop aircraft equipped with GPS and an Enhanced Ground Proximity Warning System end up colliding with terrain? That is the critical question.

In this video, Magnar explains:
- The ATR 42-500’s navigation and terrain warning systems.
- The ILS Runway 21 approach procedure into Makassar.
- Minimum altitudes and why they matter.
- Weather conditions, including cumulonimbus clouds and rain.
- Possible factors such as situational awareness, ATC instructions, and weather avoidance.

At this stage, there is no confirmed cause. Technical malfunction, human factors, weather, or a combination of all three remain possible. Only the Flight Data Recorder and Cockpit Voice Recorder will provide definitive answers.

This analysis is not speculation or blame — it is an educational, professional look at how accidents unfold and why investigations take time. Aviation safety depends on careful analysis, patience, and learning from every event.

If you are a pilot, aviation enthusiast, or someone interested in how real-world accident investigations work, this video provides valuable insight from someone who has flown and instructed on the ATR aircraft.

👉 Subscribe for more professional aviation analysis
👉 Like & share to support aviation safety education
This ATR 42 Should Not Have Been Here — What Happened?ATR systems - Primary Flight Display (PFD) part 3 - ILS approach | TutorialAI Is Getting Aviation WRONG (And It’s a Problem)TCAS has a serious limitation #aviation #atraircraftATR 72 Emergency Landing: Uncover Essential Electric System Tips for Pilots!Shocking ATR 72 Incident: Wheel Falls Off During Takeoff in Nigeria!Flying ATR 72 when the sun is not shining in the MaldivesATR systems - Primary Flight Display & Autopilot part 1 - From power up to take-offHow a Symmetrical Wing Generates Lift: The Physics ExplainedWhy do some pushbuttons in ATR aircraft have amber borders?Why Flight Oversight Matters: ATR 72 Landing Incident at Gran Canaria Explained!This aircraft landed on the nose wheel ! ATR 72 instructor explains
Fly with Magnar |

This ATR 42 Should Not Have Been Here — What Happened?

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER