The Wall Street Journal Questioned the 4% Rule. So I Called Its Creator. @ErinTalksMoney
The Wall Street Journal Questioned the 4% Rule. So I Called Its Creator.  @ErinTalksMoney
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
Feeling unsure about your financial future? My team at Root Financial can help: learn.rootfinancial.com/erin

Is the 4% rule still safe for retirement?

A recent Wall Street Journal article reported an 81.5% success rate in its retirement withdrawal simulations. But how does its model compare with Bill Bengen’s original research and the updated 4.7% withdrawal rate explored in his 2025 book, A Richer Retirement?

In this video, we compare all three approaches, examining how portfolio allocation, inflation, investment returns, withdrawal timing, and advisory fees affect how long your retirement savings may last.

The WSJ model gradually reduces stocks from 50% at age 65 to zero at age 95.

We explain why that differs from Bengen’s portfolios, what historical backtesting and Monte Carlo simulations actually tell us, and why their success rates aren’t directly interchangeable.

We cover:

• How the 4% rule works with inflation-adjusted retirement withdrawals
• Bill Bengen’s original stock-and-bond portfolio and updated seven-asset portfolio
• The late-1960s retirement starts that faced bear markets and high inflation
• Sequence-of-returns risk and the danger of withdrawing during market declines
• How a 1% advisory fee affects the article’s simulated retirement outcomes
• Flexible withdrawal strategies and retirement spending guardrails

How much can you safely withdraw from a $1 million retirement portfolio? Can you spend more than 4%? And how do you avoid running out of money without spending retirement afraid to enjoy it?

The answers depend on the plan behind the percentage.

00:00 - Intro: The WSJ Questioned the 4% Rule, So I Called Its Creator
01:22 - Why Calling It “the 4% Rule” Is Misleading
02:51 - Same Withdrawal Formula, Different Retirement Plans
04:15 - The Original 4% Rule: Built to Survive the Worst
05:36 - Bill Bengen Interview: What Actually Set the 4% Limit
07:47 - Sequence-of-Returns Risk: Rising Withdrawals, Falling Portfolio
08:51 - From 4% to 4.7%: What Changed in Bengen’s Research
12:15 - The WSJ Portfolio: Why Cutting Stocks to Zero Hurts Retirement
15:37 - History vs. Simulation: What Success Rates Really Mean
18:54 - The 6% Inflation Stress Test: Why 14.6% Isn’t What It Seems
20:25 - The Bad Times Were Already Part of the Test
21:18 - Withdrawal Timing, Bond Details, and What “Success” Means
23:38 - More Stress Tests: Bad Decades, All-Bond Portfolios, and a 1% Fee
24:07 - Three Models Side by Side: What Actually Changed
25:25 - What This Means for Your Retirement Spending
26:01 - Flexible Withdrawals and Guardrails: Spending Without Fear
27:15 - Bill’s Advice: What to Check Before Cutting Your Spending
28:38 - Final Thoughts: Is the 4% Rule Still Safe?
29:27 - Bloopers

Connect with me on LinkedIn for charts & daily retirement insights: linkedin.com/in/erintalksmoney

Some of my favorite books: amzn.to/3KF3tlr
Camera & equipment I use: amzn.to/3Z20lof

Join the family & subscribe to my channel here: youtube.com/c/ErinTalksMoney

Thanks for watching, I appreciate you!

Advisory services are offered through Root Financial Partners, LLC, an SEC-registered investment adviser. This content is intended for informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Viewing this content does not create an advisory relationship with Root Financial. We do not provide tax preparation or legal services. Always consult an investment, tax or legal professional regarding your specific situation. The strategies, case studies, and examples discussed may not be suitable for everyone. They are hypothetical and for illustrative and educational purposes only. They do not reflect actual client results and are not guarantees of future performance. All investments involve risk, including the potential loss of principal.
Comments reflect the views of individual users and do not necessarily represent the views of Root Financial. They are not verified, may not be accurate and should not be considered testimonials or endorsements.
The Wall Street Journal Questioned the 4% Rule. So I Called Its Creator.9 in 10 Households Have Spending Spikes BIGGER Than Income!EQ Predicts Your Salary! College Study Reveals Surprising LinkWhy DIY Investors Need a Backup Plan for Later LifeWill You Retire at the Best Time… the Worst Time… or Somewhere in Between?Tax-Free Income Explained: What’s 100% Exempt Under Federal LawYou Might Need 50% Less to Retire Than You Think — Here’s WhyBrokerage Withdrawal MYTHS BUSTED! Sell Stocks The Smart WayThis Strategy Can Move Your Retirement Up by Almost a Decade (Clip)The 4% Rule: Success or Underspending? Brutal Truth Revealed!What Bill Bengen Says Is Safe for a 40 Year RetirementYour 50s Are the MOST Important Decade for Retirement — Here’s Why
Erin Talks Money | Erin Moriarity |

The Wall Street Journal Questioned the 4% Rule. So I Called Its Creator.

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER