Uploaded December 2019 | Updated November 2026, 7 hours ago
This video is my take on the question that has been debated since the collapse of the USSR. "How many people did communism kill?" I critically question the current state of research and provoke the viewers to think about the things differently than we are usually told to.
Discord: discord.gg/TyGgUJd
Twitter: twitter.com/Viki1999Yt
Sources:
PragerU on Socialism: youtu.be/nUGkKKAogDs?t=20
JB Peterson on Socialism: youtu.be/rSzpc2vh8Ow?t=81
Stéphane Courtois bias: https://www.dukeupress.edu/red-hangover
Black book of communism: archive.org/stream/TheBlackBookofCommunism10/the-black-book-of-communism-jean-louis-margolin-1999-communism_djvu.txt
Casualties of WW2: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties
Soviet famine of 1921: thevintagenews.com/2017/01/07/the-catastrophic-russian-famine-of-1921-22-killed-more-than-5-million-people
The Kulaks: telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/11/06/kulaks
Holodomor Food production reduction: Davies & Wheatcroft 2010, p. 470, 476.
Holodomor Radicicolous death toll: cambridge.org/core/journals/slavic-review/article/harvest-of-despair-life-and-death-in-ukraine-under-nazi-rule-by-karel-c-berkhoff-cambridge-harvard-university-press-2004-the-belknap-press-xvi-463-pp-appendix-notes-index-illustrations-photographs-tables-map-2995-hard-bound/1C2AC0441D910047790780A08D494FED
Great Chinese Famine: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Chinese_Famine
Terentiy Maltsev: prabook.com/web/terentiy.maltsev/951172
Trofim Lysenko: famousscientists.org/trofim-lysenko
Rise of the mortality rate during German rearmament under the Nazis: ifo.de/DocDL/cesifo_wp800.pdf
Transcript:
Hello everybody,
Today we are going to look at the question. “How many people REALLY died from communism”. I think it’s time that we seriously approach this question from the left. Usually the right wing says “communism killed millions” and the left either stays silent or dismisses this as propaganda. But in this video we won’t do that. We are gonna look at the facts and the figures just as I did in the death toll of capitalism video. And in the end we will come to our own conclusion.
Just for clarification I will operate just like in that video. If a death is the result of the mechanics of the economic system, it is a death I will count. That means if there is an imaginary system in which that death could be avoided it will be counted. Stuff like murder are not the fault of the economic system and won’t be counted. With that out of the way let’s start.
So what we will do is find the highest number we can, which has sources behind it and see how legitimate those claims are. And without wasting any more time. The highest number there is with a source behind it is 100 Million. Yes there are extremely biased pages on the web that claim that Stalin alone killed 60 Million they reach that number by counting every natural death in the USSR and adding the deaths of the German soldiers that invaded the soviet union who where killed by the red army defending Russia.
But the highest somewhat credible number is 100 Million, in total since 1917, worldwide. And to immediately disprove Jordan Peterson: No, that’s not the official estimate. Not even close to be honest. It’s the estimate of Stéphane Courtois. This guy. He is the is a director of research at the “Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS)” excuse the pronunciation.
To be more exact it’s from his book which is called “The black book of communism” it was written by these guys. Courtois was the editor and in charge of many of the conclusions and suggestions of the book. Apparently the other authors didn’t enjoy what he did with their research and every single one of them spoke out against the conclusions Courtois made. One said that Courtois was "obsessed" with arriving at a total of 100 million killed which resulted in "sloppy and biased scholarship". We’ll see what he meant later.
As a full disclaimer I did not actually read the full 900 Page book and only read the chapters that are concerned with the points I am talking about along with external summaries to help me navigate this book. The link to the digitalized archive version of the book is in the description so you can check if I took any quotes out of context or something like that. Oh and also the book doesn’t distinguish between socialism, communism and authoritarianism. Because of this I use socialism and communism interchangeably in this video.
This video is my take on the question that has been debated since the collapse of the USSR. "How many people did communism kill?" I critically question the current state of research and provoke the viewers to think about the things differently than we are usually told to.
Discord: discord.gg/TyGgUJd
Twitter: twitter.com/Viki1999Yt
Sources:
PragerU on Socialism: youtu.be/nUGkKKAogDs?t=20
JB Peterson on Socialism: youtu.be/rSzpc2vh8Ow?t=81
Stéphane Courtois bias: https://www.dukeupress.edu/red-hangover
Black book of communism: archive.org/stream/TheBlackBookofCommunism10/the-black-book-of-communism-jean-louis-margolin-1999-communism_djvu.txt
Casualties of WW2: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties
Soviet famine of 1921: thevintagenews.com/2017/01/07/the-catastrophic-russian-famine-of-1921-22-killed-more-than-5-million-people
The Kulaks: telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/11/06/kulaks
Holodomor Food production reduction: Davies & Wheatcroft 2010, p. 470, 476.
Holodomor Radicicolous death toll: cambridge.org/core/journals/slavic-review/article/harvest-of-despair-life-and-death-in-ukraine-under-nazi-rule-by-karel-c-berkhoff-cambridge-harvard-university-press-2004-the-belknap-press-xvi-463-pp-appendix-notes-index-illustrations-photographs-tables-map-2995-hard-bound/1C2AC0441D910047790780A08D494FED
Great Chinese Famine: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Chinese_Famine
Terentiy Maltsev: prabook.com/web/terentiy.maltsev/951172
Trofim Lysenko: famousscientists.org/trofim-lysenko
Rise of the mortality rate during German rearmament under the Nazis: ifo.de/DocDL/cesifo_wp800.pdf
Transcript:
Hello everybody,
Today we are going to look at the question. “How many people REALLY died from communism”. I think it’s time that we seriously approach this question from the left. Usually the right wing says “communism killed millions” and the left either stays silent or dismisses this as propaganda. But in this video we won’t do that. We are gonna look at the facts and the figures just as I did in the death toll of capitalism video. And in the end we will come to our own conclusion.
Just for clarification I will operate just like in that video. If a death is the result of the mechanics of the economic system, it is a death I will count. That means if there is an imaginary system in which that death could be avoided it will be counted. Stuff like murder are not the fault of the economic system and won’t be counted. With that out of the way let’s start.
So what we will do is find the highest number we can, which has sources behind it and see how legitimate those claims are. And without wasting any more time. The highest number there is with a source behind it is 100 Million. Yes there are extremely biased pages on the web that claim that Stalin alone killed 60 Million they reach that number by counting every natural death in the USSR and adding the deaths of the German soldiers that invaded the soviet union who where killed by the red army defending Russia.
But the highest somewhat credible number is 100 Million, in total since 1917, worldwide. And to immediately disprove Jordan Peterson: No, that’s not the official estimate. Not even close to be honest. It’s the estimate of Stéphane Courtois. This guy. He is the is a director of research at the “Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS)” excuse the pronunciation.
To be more exact it’s from his book which is called “The black book of communism” it was written by these guys. Courtois was the editor and in charge of many of the conclusions and suggestions of the book. Apparently the other authors didn’t enjoy what he did with their research and every single one of them spoke out against the conclusions Courtois made. One said that Courtois was "obsessed" with arriving at a total of 100 million killed which resulted in "sloppy and biased scholarship". We’ll see what he meant later.
As a full disclaimer I did not actually read the full 900 Page book and only read the chapters that are concerned with the points I am talking about along with external summaries to help me navigate this book. The link to the digitalized archive version of the book is in the description so you can check if I took any quotes out of context or something like that. Oh and also the book doesn’t distinguish between socialism, communism and authoritarianism. Because of this I use socialism and communism interchangeably in this video.
