Uploaded December 2021 | Updated November 2026, 2 hours ago
How do rate and review what I read? Watch this video to discover that I don't even know. π€
Original Tag is from Gunpowder Fiction & Plot: youtube.com/watch?v=IuynyN67WI4&t=0s
I was tagged by Courtney Ferriter: youtube.com/watch?v=Rua3YM6xUOM
I tag:
π Jen the Librarian youtube.com/c/JentheLibrarianreads
π Margaret Pinard youtube.com/c/MargaretPinard
Other channels mentioned
π₯ Remembered Reads youtube.com/c/RememberedReads
π₯ MercysBookishMusings youtube.com/user/MercysBookishMusings
π₯ Rick MacDonnell youtube.com/c/RickMacDonnell
π₯ insert book pun here youtube.com/c/insertbookpunhere
Questions:
1. Tag folks.
2. How do you know youβve just finished a good book? Is it a thinking or a feeling response?
3. When you begin to form your review/rating - what is the first question you ask yourself?
4. Do you do star ratings? Why? Why not?
a. If YES
i. Explain your star rating system β what does a good book get in your rating system?
ii. Is your star rating consistent? i.e. are all your 5 star books better than all your 4 star books?
b. If NO
i. What language do you use to convey the quality of a book in your reviews?
ii. Does this form an informal rating or ranking?
5. Do you believe every book has its perfect reader? Does this contradict the idea that a book can be βbadβ?
6. What book that you hated have you recommended?
7. What makes a book good, bad or great by your evaluation?
8. When evaluating the quality of a book do you have specific criteria or aspects of the book, such as character development, that you consider? Does this change if you are writing an in-depth review vs. just thinking about the book for enjoyment?
9. Do you consider star ratings or average ratings when choosing books to read/add to your TBR?
10. Who on BookTube does reliable and interesting reviews of books that you know you can use to decide if a book is for you or not? What makes their reviews so good?
11. Does that/those Booktuber(s) use different language than you to evaluate and review the overall quality of a book?
If you are new here, welcome! My name is Melissa and my pronouns are she/her.
Let's be internet friends!
π· Instagram: @fully.booked.melissa
π Goodreads: goodreads.com/melissafulton
π The Story Graph: melissafulton
How do rate and review what I read? Watch this video to discover that I don't even know. π€
Original Tag is from Gunpowder Fiction & Plot: youtube.com/watch?v=IuynyN67WI4&t=0s
I was tagged by Courtney Ferriter: youtube.com/watch?v=Rua3YM6xUOM
I tag:
π Jen the Librarian youtube.com/c/JentheLibrarianreads
π Margaret Pinard youtube.com/c/MargaretPinard
Other channels mentioned
π₯ Remembered Reads youtube.com/c/RememberedReads
π₯ MercysBookishMusings youtube.com/user/MercysBookishMusings
π₯ Rick MacDonnell youtube.com/c/RickMacDonnell
π₯ insert book pun here youtube.com/c/insertbookpunhere
Questions:
1. Tag folks.
2. How do you know youβve just finished a good book? Is it a thinking or a feeling response?
3. When you begin to form your review/rating - what is the first question you ask yourself?
4. Do you do star ratings? Why? Why not?
a. If YES
i. Explain your star rating system β what does a good book get in your rating system?
ii. Is your star rating consistent? i.e. are all your 5 star books better than all your 4 star books?
b. If NO
i. What language do you use to convey the quality of a book in your reviews?
ii. Does this form an informal rating or ranking?
5. Do you believe every book has its perfect reader? Does this contradict the idea that a book can be βbadβ?
6. What book that you hated have you recommended?
7. What makes a book good, bad or great by your evaluation?
8. When evaluating the quality of a book do you have specific criteria or aspects of the book, such as character development, that you consider? Does this change if you are writing an in-depth review vs. just thinking about the book for enjoyment?
9. Do you consider star ratings or average ratings when choosing books to read/add to your TBR?
10. Who on BookTube does reliable and interesting reviews of books that you know you can use to decide if a book is for you or not? What makes their reviews so good?
11. Does that/those Booktuber(s) use different language than you to evaluate and review the overall quality of a book?
If you are new here, welcome! My name is Melissa and my pronouns are she/her.
Let's be internet friends!
π· Instagram: @fully.booked.melissa
π Goodreads: goodreads.com/melissafulton
π The Story Graph: melissafulton

![Booktube Prize Quarterfinals: Nonfiction Group D [ CC]
Overly, I think this was a great group of nonfiction books. What did you think of them?
π₯ Results from this round:
https://youtu.be/jIWSv8AYiw4?si NuHaShrBXhUTptm
π Books mentionedπ
The Dictionary People by Sarah Ogilvie
Flee North by Scott Shane
The Lumumba Plot by Stuart A. Reid
The Wager by David Grann
We Were Once a Family by Roxanna Asgarian
Wifedom by Anna Funder
β¨β¨β¨β¨β¨
she/her
The Socials:
π· Instagram: @fully.booked.melissa
π Goodreads: https://www.goodreads.com/melissafulton
π The Story Graph: melissafulton Booktube Prize Quarterfinals: Nonfiction Group D [ CC]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/keJql3lokNc/mqdefault.jpg)

![Family Secrets & Trees | Greenwood by Michael Christie [CC]
Readers keep pushing the apocalyptic aspect of this book and Im not sure why...
β¨β¨β¨β¨β¨
she/her
The Socials:
π· Instagram: @fully.booked.melissa
π Goodreads: https://www.goodreads.com/melissafulton
π The Story Graph: melissafulton Family Secrets & Trees | Greenwood by Michael Christie [CC]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/l7_wb-uT1T8/mqdefault.jpg)



![Reflections on 3 Years of Booktube + Q & A announcement! [CC]
Im usually not the begging type, but I am begging you to post questions and to come to the livestream if you can, as it would really cheer me up... On my actually birthday (which happened after I recorded this video), I was rejected for a job that was tailor-made for my skillset/experience, that I desperately wanted, and honestly... that I desperately needed. Suffice it to say, it ruined my birthday for me. So, to move on from my crappy real birthday, Id love to celebrate my booktube birthday with as many booktube buddies as possible. β€οΈβ€οΈβ€οΈ Reflections on 3 Years of Booktube + Q & A announcement! [CC]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/myBWAU-WbSc/mqdefault.jpg)


