The Old Fashioned: You Are Doing It Wrong @TheMoodyBartender
The Old Fashioned: You Are Doing It Wrong  @TheMoodyBartender
Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
The Old Fashioned is one of the simplest cocktails ever made.
Whiskey. Sugar. Bitters. Water.

👉 Support The Moody Bartender on Patreon: patreon.com/moodybartender

So why have we become obsessed with making it faster, smoother and more “consistent”?

Today I’m going back to the classic Old Fashioned and making it the way I’ve always preferred it — with Sugar rather than Sugar Syrup.

And yes… this might annoy a few bartenders.

Sugar Syrup is faster. It’s easier. And in a busy bar, I completely understand why it’s used.

But does every sip of an Old Fashioned really need to taste exactly the same?

In this episode, I make both versions side by side, look at where the Old Fashioned actually came from, and explain why sometimes efficiency behind the bar doesn’t necessarily mean a better drinking experience.

I’m not saying you should never use syrup.

I’m saying:

Make the classic first.

Understand it.

Then start changing it.

Let me know in the comments — Sugar or Sugar Syrup?

CLASSIC OLD FASHIONED

60 ml / 2 oz Bourbon or Rye Whiskey
1 Sugar Cube or 1 tsp Sugar
2–3 dashes Angostura Bitters (i prefer 6- 8 dashes)
Small splash of Water
Orange Zest

Add the Sugar, Bitters and Water to the glass and gently muddle.

Add the Whiskey and Ice, then stir until chilled and appropriately diluted.

Express the Orange Zest over the drink and garnish.

Cheers.

VIDEO CHAPTERS:
00:00 The Old Fashioned argument
00:30 What an Old Fashioned actually is
01:15 Why it became “Old Fashioned”
02:05 My problem with Sugar Syrup
02:28 Making the classic Old Fashioned
03:25 Why Orange Zest and Not Lemon Zest
04:58 Why I prefer Sugar
05:29 Making the Sugar Syrup version
07:10 Sugar vs Sugar Syrup
07:42 Stop fixing what isn’t broken

MY BAR TOOLS
🔶 Multi Measurement Jigger [UK] - amzn.to/3kLKwib (paid link)
🔶 Multi Measurement Jigger [US] - amzn.to/3bhAfa8 (paid link)
🔶 Tattoo Boston Shaker: amzn.to/3az52hm (paid link)
🔶 Tattoo Jigger: amzn.to/2O5eLo1(paid link)
🔶 Tattoo Bar Spoon: amzn.to/36JgeXE (paid link)
🔶 Tattoo Strainer: amzn.to/3tnTVQR (paid link)

DISCLAIMER:
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases and get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

#OldFashioned #Cocktails #TheMoodyBartender

Get vidIQ to grow your channel faster! 🚀
vidiq.com/GeorgiPetrov
The Old Fashioned: You Are Doing It WrongThe Busker Irish Whiskey | Monday Dram | Just Shake or StirSpiced Apple Pie Cocktail - Instagram Cocktails DecodedFilming Day Disaster #shorts #bloopers #cocktailvideosSazerac Cocktail - the way I like itParmesan Espresso Martini. Yes. its a thingWE ARE CLOSING!!! Last Cheers with Pacifico CocktailThe Best Ginger Old Fashioned You Will Ever Make 🫚Espresso Mintini 👌The Night Orchard: My New Favorite Autumn CocktailHow to Make the Best Coffee Orange Old Fashioned Ever!Campari Cocktail Recipes you should try | Just Shake or Stir
The Moody Bartender |

The Old Fashioned: You Are Doing It Wrong

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER