The Is Of Dilemma in Christianity @MCCEastBay
The Is Of Dilemma in Christianity  @MCCEastBay
Uploaded July 2026 | Updated September 2026, 2 weeks ago
- Complete program: youtu.be/VS31Uf-jgPQ
- More Ustadh Dr. Ali Ataie: mcceastbay.org/ataie
- Dr. Ataie's book "In Defense of Islam: Confronting the Christians with their own Scripture by Ali Ataie (2004)": mcceastbay.org/ataie-1
- Dr. Ataie's book "Finding Muhammad in the New Testament - An Orthodox Muslim’s Interpretive Methodological Approach to the Christian Scriptures (Dr. Ali Ataie Thesis (2011): mcceastbay.org/ataie-2
- Dr. Ataie's book "Authenticating the Johannine Injil - Muslim 'Polemirenic' Interpretive Approaches to the Gospel of John (2016)": mcceastbay.org/ataie-3

Dr. Ali Ataie is a scholar of biblical hermeneutics with field specialties in Sacred Languages, Comparative

Dr. Ali Ataie is a scholar of biblical hermeneutics with field specialties in Sacred Languages, Comparative Theology, and Comparative Literature. At Zaytuna College, Dr. Ataie has taught Arabic, Creedal Theology, Comparative Theology, Sciences of the Quran, Introduction to the Qur’an, and Seminal Ancient Texts.

For All New Muslim Women & Men (regardless of when you took your Shahadah): The Being Muslim Bookclub is dedicated to empowering converts and beginning Muslims to live Islam in a practical, sustainable way. This week, we are joined guest speaker Dr. Ali Ataie

Each month, we delve into one chapter to gain clarity on how to live and practice Islam, exploring the foundational elements of what Muslims believe.

This eight-month book club with Ustadh Omar Naisan is for all reverts, regardless of when you took your Shahadah. It is invaluable to those new to their journey in Islam and those returning to faith.

- Watch past recordings of "Being Muslim Bookclub": mcceastbay.org/being-muslim
- More Sidi Omer Naisan: mcceastbay.org/omar

Dr. Ali Ataie is a scholar of biblical hermeneutics with field specialties in Sacred Languages, Comparative Theology, and Comparative Literature. At Zaytuna College, Dr. Ataie has taught Arabic, Creedal Theology, Comparative Theology, Sciences of the Quran, Introduction to the Qur’an, and Seminal Ancient Texts. He received his BS in accounting from Cal Poly State University in 2000. In 2011, he received his MA in Biblical Studies from Pacific School of Religion, and in 2016, his PhD in Cultural and Historical Studies in Religion from the Graduate Theological Union. Dr. Ataie’s PhD thesis, titled “Authenticating the Johannine Injil: Muslim ‘Polemirenic’ Interpretive Approaches to the Gospel of John,” is a faith-based hermeneutic of the Gospel of John in which the entire text is authenticated as being the true Gospel of Jesus Christ mentioned in the Qur’an. Dr. Ataie is a native Persian speaker. He can read and write Arabic, Hebrew, and Greek.

The "is of" dilemma in Christianity refers to the foundational debate regarding the true nature of Christ: is he of the same substance (100% divine and 100% human) or merely a creation with divine attributes? This theological puzzle centers around whether Jesus shares the exact uncreated essence of God the Father.

- More Ustadh Omar: mcceastbay.org/omar

This talk was delivered at the Muslim Community Center - East Bay (MCC East Bay) in Pleasanton, California on Saturday, May 23, 2026.
The Is Of Dilemma in ChristianityYou Should NOT Watch the World Cup as a Muslim‼️🙅‍♂️Spiritual Opportunities in Dhul-Hijjah | Sidi Haseeb SadatBeing Muslim: Monthly Convert Bookclub | Ustadh Omar NaisanA Good Hakim Will Not Give Treatment Until He or She Has First Removed That Which is Hurting YouWhat Did Ismail Say as a Young Boy | Ustadh Haseeb SadatSpiritual & Personal Transformation in Islam | Dr. Mazen AtassiContent of Character | Ust. Hosai Mojaddidi (Monthly Sisterhood Halaqa - Part 3)Sanjays Shahadah (Declaration of Faith) | Qari Amar Bellaha“I found peace in Islam. I found people of peace in a world that’s lacking peace.” | Todds ShahadahPortrait of a Sincere Seeker, Part 2 | al-Suhrawardi’s Life and Lessons | Ustadh Abdullah QureshiThe Distinction Between Knowledge & Action in Islam | Ustadh Feraidoon Mojaddidi
MCC East Bay (Muslim Community Center) |

The 'Is Of' Dilemma in Christianity

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER