Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
My exchange with the Professional Services Review (PSR) during the December 2025 Senate Estimates only deepened my concerns regarding the integrity of their review process. It is becoming increasingly clear that their 'peer review' is a mere box-ticking exercise, dominated by lawyers rather than the medical peers the legislation intended.
I questioned why lawyers, rather than the doctors themselves, are drafting the reports. While the PSR claims lawyers only "put together" the doctors' views to ensure procedural fairness, it appears to me that the heavy lifting, sometimes over 150 hours of drafting, is done by legal staff, while committee members may spend as little as seven to 10 hours reviewing the final product.
I raised the issue that there is no legal requirement for committee members to share the same subspecialty as the GP under review. A GP in a niche field like aerospace medicine could be judged by practitioners with zero experience in that specific group.
I questioned Professor Dr Dio and Ms. Weichert on the lack of basic legal protections, such as the absence of a presiding judge, the inability to cross-examine the committee on their views of "general body" standards, and the lack of a formal merits review.
Several questions were taken on notice, specifically around providing detailed log of hours spent by both staff and committee members on
reports over the last three years. We need to see if the time spent by doctors
actually justifies calling this a "peer-reviewed" outcome.
— Senate Estimates | February 2026
Transcript: https://www.malcolmrobertsqld.com.au/the-illusion-of-peer-review/
My exchange with the Professional Services Review (PSR) during the December 2025 Senate Estimates only deepened my concerns regarding the integrity of their review process. It is becoming increasingly clear that their 'peer review' is a mere box-ticking exercise, dominated by lawyers rather than the medical peers the legislation intended.
I questioned why lawyers, rather than the doctors themselves, are drafting the reports. While the PSR claims lawyers only "put together" the doctors' views to ensure procedural fairness, it appears to me that the heavy lifting, sometimes over 150 hours of drafting, is done by legal staff, while committee members may spend as little as seven to 10 hours reviewing the final product.
I raised the issue that there is no legal requirement for committee members to share the same subspecialty as the GP under review. A GP in a niche field like aerospace medicine could be judged by practitioners with zero experience in that specific group.
I questioned Professor Dr Dio and Ms. Weichert on the lack of basic legal protections, such as the absence of a presiding judge, the inability to cross-examine the committee on their views of "general body" standards, and the lack of a formal merits review.
Several questions were taken on notice, specifically around providing detailed log of hours spent by both staff and committee members on
reports over the last three years. We need to see if the time spent by doctors
actually justifies calling this a "peer-reviewed" outcome.
— Senate Estimates | February 2026
Transcript: https://www.malcolmrobertsqld.com.au/the-illusion-of-peer-review/










