Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
The Great Depression is often portrayed as capitalism's greatest failure—a cautionary tale of unchecked greed, reckless speculation, and unregulated markets.
But what if the real culprit wasn't too much economic freedom, but too much government intervention?
In this episode of Check Your Premises, Maggie Anders challenges the conventional narrative of the Great Depression, examining how the prosperity of the Roaring Twenties gave way to economic collapse—and whether government policies turned a financial crisis into a decade of suffering.
What made the American economy roar during the 1920s?
Did capitalism cause the Great Depression, or did government intervention make it worse?
And did Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal actually save the economy—or prolong its recovery?
From Calvin Coolidge's tax cuts and the Federal Reserve's monetary policies to Herbert Hoover's tariffs and FDR's expansion of federal power, Maggie explores the government decisions that shaped one of America's darkest economic periods.
Drawing on Ayn Rand's criticism of the New Deal and her defense of laissez-faire capitalism, she examines the consequences of sacrificing economic freedom in the name of economic security.
Because prosperity isn't created by government control.
It's created by the freedom to produce, innovate, and build a better future.
The Great Depression is often portrayed as capitalism's greatest failure—a cautionary tale of unchecked greed, reckless speculation, and unregulated markets.
But what if the real culprit wasn't too much economic freedom, but too much government intervention?
In this episode of Check Your Premises, Maggie Anders challenges the conventional narrative of the Great Depression, examining how the prosperity of the Roaring Twenties gave way to economic collapse—and whether government policies turned a financial crisis into a decade of suffering.
What made the American economy roar during the 1920s?
Did capitalism cause the Great Depression, or did government intervention make it worse?
And did Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal actually save the economy—or prolong its recovery?
From Calvin Coolidge's tax cuts and the Federal Reserve's monetary policies to Herbert Hoover's tariffs and FDR's expansion of federal power, Maggie explores the government decisions that shaped one of America's darkest economic periods.
Drawing on Ayn Rand's criticism of the New Deal and her defense of laissez-faire capitalism, she examines the consequences of sacrificing economic freedom in the name of economic security.
Because prosperity isn't created by government control.
It's created by the freedom to produce, innovate, and build a better future.










