Uploaded December 2025 | Updated November 2026, 7 hours ago
Can nation-states survive the modern era?
For over two centuries, the concept of the nation-state has shaped how people understand identity, citizenship and culture. But in a rapidly changing world, many wonder if this political system works for the benefit and protection of average citizens or if it must evolve.
In this town hall at the @BradfordLiteratureFestival in the United Kingdom moderated by Malika Bilal, expert guests and youth from across the globe explore impactful questions of nationhood and national identity.
đź’¬ Join the conversation in the comments.
Town hall guests:
- Dr. David Engels: Historian and philosopher
- Dr. Wael Hallaq: Avalon Foundation Professor in the Humanities at Columbia University
- Dr. Shashi Tharoor: author, politician and former UN Under-Secretary General
⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰
00:00 Intro
05:05 Defining Home?
8:57 Defining Identity
12:25 Abandon Nations?
15:49 What Does "Palestinian" Mean?
21:01 The Modern State
23:58 Exile or Liminality
30:01 Nationalism, The Idea
34:26 Patriotism vs Nationalism
39:01 Identity is Multilayered
45:13 Faces On The Stage
50:37 Violence and Nation-States
54:42 What If Nation-States Ended?
58:15 Do We Dare Not Dream?
1:00:37 Deciding Identity In Nation States?
1:05:13 What Is Community?
1:09:44 Wael Begs To Differ
1:15:46 Shashi Pushes Back
1:19:15 Europe Is Stuck
1:24:42 Wael's Last Remark
1:27:15 Last Thoughts
â–şâ–ş Subscribe & join the conversation: bit.ly/38fuJjZ
Don’t Settle for a Divided World. Think. Debate. Act. Let’s find solutions to the world's most pressing problems.
Doha Debates engages a vanguard of intellectually curious truth-seekers to constructively debate differences in order to build a better future.
We emphasize unity over division, encouraging conversations that bring us together rather than drive us apart. Learn more: dohadebates.com
Can nation-states survive the modern era?
For over two centuries, the concept of the nation-state has shaped how people understand identity, citizenship and culture. But in a rapidly changing world, many wonder if this political system works for the benefit and protection of average citizens or if it must evolve.
In this town hall at the @BradfordLiteratureFestival in the United Kingdom moderated by Malika Bilal, expert guests and youth from across the globe explore impactful questions of nationhood and national identity.
đź’¬ Join the conversation in the comments.
Town hall guests:
- Dr. David Engels: Historian and philosopher
- Dr. Wael Hallaq: Avalon Foundation Professor in the Humanities at Columbia University
- Dr. Shashi Tharoor: author, politician and former UN Under-Secretary General
⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰⏰
00:00 Intro
05:05 Defining Home?
8:57 Defining Identity
12:25 Abandon Nations?
15:49 What Does "Palestinian" Mean?
21:01 The Modern State
23:58 Exile or Liminality
30:01 Nationalism, The Idea
34:26 Patriotism vs Nationalism
39:01 Identity is Multilayered
45:13 Faces On The Stage
50:37 Violence and Nation-States
54:42 What If Nation-States Ended?
58:15 Do We Dare Not Dream?
1:00:37 Deciding Identity In Nation States?
1:05:13 What Is Community?
1:09:44 Wael Begs To Differ
1:15:46 Shashi Pushes Back
1:19:15 Europe Is Stuck
1:24:42 Wael's Last Remark
1:27:15 Last Thoughts
â–şâ–ş Subscribe & join the conversation: bit.ly/38fuJjZ
Don’t Settle for a Divided World. Think. Debate. Act. Let’s find solutions to the world's most pressing problems.
Doha Debates engages a vanguard of intellectually curious truth-seekers to constructively debate differences in order to build a better future.
We emphasize unity over division, encouraging conversations that bring us together rather than drive us apart. Learn more: dohadebates.com










