Uploaded May 2022 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Supernatural Somatic Markers: The Effect of Belief and Analytic Thinking on Physiological Responses
Malcolm B. Schofield, David Sheffield, & Ian S. Baker
University of Derby Kedleston Road Derby, UK
Introduction: The interplay between cognitive processes and implicit supernatural belief may manifest itself as a physiological response in the form of somatic markers. Somatic Marker Hypothesis (SMH) (Damasio, 1994) refers to the changes in the autonomic nervous system brought on by objects or events in a person’s life. A particular representation can trigger this, be it an object, event or idea. The markers themselves can be ‘good’ or ‘bad’, depending on the previous association. Therefore, this study aimed to examine implicit supernatural belief and its effect on explicit supernatural belief by examining the evidence for implicit supernatural belief using context and physiological measures.
Method: Forty-four participants were recruited from the staff and student population of the University of Derby via an opportunity sample. The measures were as follows: ‘Belief in the Supernatural Scale’ (Schofield et al., 2018) to measure belief, MCQ 30 (Wells & Cartwright-Hatton, 2004) to measure unhelpful metacognition, Cognitive Reflection Test – Long (Primi et al., 2015) to measure thinking style, and the Implicit Association Test (Sriram & Greenwald, 2009) to measure implicit association with belief. Heart Rate (HR) and Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) was measured using a continuous, non-invasive cardiovascular Finometer (Finapres Medical System, Amsterdam, Netherlands). Skin Conductance (SC) was measured. The study was split into two parts. The first was conducted online, the second in a laboratory setting.
Results: Path Analysis showed a change in skin conductance between cognitively complex and cognitively simple tasks was positively predicted by mental and psychic phenomena, psychokinesis, and common paranormal perceptions. Psychokinesis is also negatively predicted by (lack of) cognitive confidence and positively predicted by negative beliefs about uncontrollability and danger. Supernatural entities are positively predicted by the need to control thoughts.
Discussion: The findings indicate a somatic marker when looking at people who believe in the paranormal. Further, this marker is activated when a paranormal believer is faced with an analytically complex task. This is in line with the Somatic Marker Hypothesis (Damasio, 1994), which refers to the changes in the autonomic nervous system brought on by objects or events in a person’s life. This marker is based on association and indicates that someone who believes in the paranormal associates thinking analytically as a threat or a ‘bad’ thing. Whether this has to do with analytical thoughts blocking paranormal belief and experience remains to be seen.
---
The Parapsychological Association is an international professional organization of scientists and scholars engaged in the study of psi (or 'psychic') experiences, such as telepathy, clairvoyance, psychokinesis, psychic healing, and precognition. The primary objective of the PA is to achieve a scientific understanding of these experiences.
Find us:
facebook.com/ParapsychologicalAssociation
Twitter - twitter.com/parapsych
Instagram - instagram.com/parapsychologicalassociation
Donations to support the mission of the PA, including the funding of research initiatives, can be made by reaching office@parapsych.org or the Paypal Giving Fund: paypal.com/us/fundraiser/charity/153733
Supernatural Somatic Markers: The Effect of Belief and Analytic Thinking on Physiological Responses
Malcolm B. Schofield, David Sheffield, & Ian S. Baker
University of Derby Kedleston Road Derby, UK
Introduction: The interplay between cognitive processes and implicit supernatural belief may manifest itself as a physiological response in the form of somatic markers. Somatic Marker Hypothesis (SMH) (Damasio, 1994) refers to the changes in the autonomic nervous system brought on by objects or events in a person’s life. A particular representation can trigger this, be it an object, event or idea. The markers themselves can be ‘good’ or ‘bad’, depending on the previous association. Therefore, this study aimed to examine implicit supernatural belief and its effect on explicit supernatural belief by examining the evidence for implicit supernatural belief using context and physiological measures.
Method: Forty-four participants were recruited from the staff and student population of the University of Derby via an opportunity sample. The measures were as follows: ‘Belief in the Supernatural Scale’ (Schofield et al., 2018) to measure belief, MCQ 30 (Wells & Cartwright-Hatton, 2004) to measure unhelpful metacognition, Cognitive Reflection Test – Long (Primi et al., 2015) to measure thinking style, and the Implicit Association Test (Sriram & Greenwald, 2009) to measure implicit association with belief. Heart Rate (HR) and Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) was measured using a continuous, non-invasive cardiovascular Finometer (Finapres Medical System, Amsterdam, Netherlands). Skin Conductance (SC) was measured. The study was split into two parts. The first was conducted online, the second in a laboratory setting.
Results: Path Analysis showed a change in skin conductance between cognitively complex and cognitively simple tasks was positively predicted by mental and psychic phenomena, psychokinesis, and common paranormal perceptions. Psychokinesis is also negatively predicted by (lack of) cognitive confidence and positively predicted by negative beliefs about uncontrollability and danger. Supernatural entities are positively predicted by the need to control thoughts.
Discussion: The findings indicate a somatic marker when looking at people who believe in the paranormal. Further, this marker is activated when a paranormal believer is faced with an analytically complex task. This is in line with the Somatic Marker Hypothesis (Damasio, 1994), which refers to the changes in the autonomic nervous system brought on by objects or events in a person’s life. This marker is based on association and indicates that someone who believes in the paranormal associates thinking analytically as a threat or a ‘bad’ thing. Whether this has to do with analytical thoughts blocking paranormal belief and experience remains to be seen.
---
The Parapsychological Association is an international professional organization of scientists and scholars engaged in the study of psi (or 'psychic') experiences, such as telepathy, clairvoyance, psychokinesis, psychic healing, and precognition. The primary objective of the PA is to achieve a scientific understanding of these experiences.
Find us:
facebook.com/ParapsychologicalAssociation
Twitter - twitter.com/parapsych
Instagram - instagram.com/parapsychologicalassociation
Donations to support the mission of the PA, including the funding of research initiatives, can be made by reaching office@parapsych.org or the Paypal Giving Fund: paypal.com/us/fundraiser/charity/153733










