Uploaded July 2021 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
A fascinating discussion tag originated by Gunpowder, Fiction & Plot youtube.com/watch?v=gTqtnMSPqhI&t=0s&ab_channel=Gunpowder%2CFiction%26Plot
I provide some historical context from my experiences of similar in the late 1970s which informs my approach to Cancel/ Call out culture, which to me are actually two different things.
Then I answer the following prompts informed by that historical context.
1. Tag people. To generate interesting conversation try to tag at least one channel who you think might have a different (either opposing or more radical) opinion to you and one who might have a similar one.
2. What is cancel/call out culture?
3. Is Cancel/Callout culture a positive or a negative force in the booktube/bookstagram/bookish community as a whole? Why do you think this?
4. From mixing fabrics to involuntary cannibalism; what transgressions would you boycott an author over?
5. What does boycott mean to you? Not buy, not read, not promote – all three? How do you boycott – does this depend on the transgression/offence?
6. What books or authors (if any) that you would have otherwise read, do you boycott?
7. When does boycotting a book or author become cancel culture? Are the two even related?
8. How do you think power, money, size of audience, influence etc effect who is cancelling and being cancelled? e.g can a small BookTuber cancel a best selling author, what about a large BookTuber and a tiny author.
9. Do you apply the same standards to the Booktubers you watch? Have you ever called out, confronted, privately messaged or unsubscribed from somebody over their opinion?
10. If cancel culture is a destructive force; a constructive force might be to highlight talented authors and excellent books from communities “victimised” by anybody you boycott. Please highlight some authors and recommend us some books
Other related videos
Deborah Lipstadt V David Irving, how to take on a Holocaust denier youtube.com/watch?v=t7zSR7BGbuQ&ab_channel=HallCenter
Do Writers' Personal Lives Matter To Their Reputations? youtube.com/watch?v=oFyDaknmBOE&t=134s
A fascinating discussion tag originated by Gunpowder, Fiction & Plot youtube.com/watch?v=gTqtnMSPqhI&t=0s&ab_channel=Gunpowder%2CFiction%26Plot
I provide some historical context from my experiences of similar in the late 1970s which informs my approach to Cancel/ Call out culture, which to me are actually two different things.
Then I answer the following prompts informed by that historical context.
1. Tag people. To generate interesting conversation try to tag at least one channel who you think might have a different (either opposing or more radical) opinion to you and one who might have a similar one.
2. What is cancel/call out culture?
3. Is Cancel/Callout culture a positive or a negative force in the booktube/bookstagram/bookish community as a whole? Why do you think this?
4. From mixing fabrics to involuntary cannibalism; what transgressions would you boycott an author over?
5. What does boycott mean to you? Not buy, not read, not promote – all three? How do you boycott – does this depend on the transgression/offence?
6. What books or authors (if any) that you would have otherwise read, do you boycott?
7. When does boycotting a book or author become cancel culture? Are the two even related?
8. How do you think power, money, size of audience, influence etc effect who is cancelling and being cancelled? e.g can a small BookTuber cancel a best selling author, what about a large BookTuber and a tiny author.
9. Do you apply the same standards to the Booktubers you watch? Have you ever called out, confronted, privately messaged or unsubscribed from somebody over their opinion?
10. If cancel culture is a destructive force; a constructive force might be to highlight talented authors and excellent books from communities “victimised” by anybody you boycott. Please highlight some authors and recommend us some books
Other related videos
Deborah Lipstadt V David Irving, how to take on a Holocaust denier youtube.com/watch?v=t7zSR7BGbuQ&ab_channel=HallCenter
Do Writers' Personal Lives Matter To Their Reputations? youtube.com/watch?v=oFyDaknmBOE&t=134s










