The BGG Weight Problem @Shelfside
The BGG Weight Problem  @Shelfside
Uploaded February 2024 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
How complex is a game rated on BGG? What does heaviness even mean? We dive into the community ratings of "weight" on boardgamegeek, where people vote between 1-5 on how they think this tabletop game makes them feel in terms of complexity and rules. From John Company 2nd edition to even Candyland, we go through what a heavy game feels like to play, and some weirdness with voting. Maybe Geekscore voting systems can be implemented, like a Bayesian average? We even go through the BGG top 100 and see which games we think are accurately rated! What are ways to improve this for all games (including party games and war games) to help out veterans and newcomers?

Support us:
patreon.com/shelfside
ko-fi.com/shelfside

Play Ascension.gg for free: ascension.gg/new-arrival/s9

Games featured: Twilight Imperium 4, Twilight Imperium 3, Prophecy of Kings, Dune Imperium, Twister, Candyland, Telestrations, Cards Against Humanity, John Company 2nd Edition, War of the Ring 2nd Edition, Star Wars Rebellion, Dune Imperium, Arkham Horror LCG, Spirit Island, Brass Birmingham, Catan, Ticket to Ride, Rising Sun, Eldritch Horror, Battlestar Galactica

Table of Contents:
Intro - (0:00)
Ascension.gg - (0:53)
Polling the BGG Weight - (1:48)
Heavy, Light, and Medium Examples - (2:32)
Inaccuracies in polling - (5:39)
Potential reasons for weirdness - (7:29)
Some suggestions to help - (10:30)

Our Website!
shelfside.co

Purchase Games We’ve Reviewed! (Paid Link)
amazon.com/shop/shelfside

Shelfside Social Media:
twitter.com/ShelfSideYT
instagram.com/shelfsideboardgames
facebook.com/ShelfsideYT
discord.gg/U7QQKqYT62

Links to our other stuff:
Ashton's Channel: youtube.com/ashtonwu
Daniel's Channel: youtube.com/user/doyduh2

Stuff used:
Upbeat Funk Background by Infraction [No Copyright Music] / Step Club
youtube.com/watch?v=YJTPA4Wgrhs

#boardgames #tabletop #tabletopgames
The BGG Weight ProblemMaster of Orion: Ad Astra Prototype Review — Space 4X Ive Been Waiting for!I was filming Grimcoven and...I try 10 Bay Area Board Game StoresTI4 Codex IV: First Impressions!Secret Societies Prototype Review — Deep Euro Bidding!Trying to rank the last 10 years of Board Games (2015-2024)How’s a Board Game COFFEE Table?Backer Booster let me win TI4!Bloodwork ▸ Shelfside PlaysArmy Painter Speedpaints Changed My LifeFighting a Boss in Frosthaven Digital!
Shelfside |

The BGG Weight Problem

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER