Uploaded June 2025 | Updated September 2026, 2 weeks ago

---

Astorflex Dartflex go.strayreviews.com/astorflex-loafers
Grant Stone Traveler go.strayreviews.com/gs-traveler
Beckett Simonon Cohen go.strayreviews.com/cohen-loafer
Thursday Penny go.strayreviews.com/thursday-penny
Jay Butler Cromwell go.strayreviews.com/jb-cromwell

Get the My Favorite Things newsletter go.strayreviews.com/favorites
Was this helpful? Buy me a coffee. go.strayreviews.com/coffee

Are you searching for the perfect penny loafer? In this honest review, I’m comparing the 5 best penny loafers from Thursday Boot Company, Beckett Simonon, Jay Butler, Astorflex, and Grant Stone to help you find your ideal pair. From casual comfort to rugged sophistication, I’ll break down the good, the bad, and the bottom line of each to make your decision easy!

*A Few of My Favorite Things*
Huckberry (Clothes and EDC) go.strayreviews.com/huckberry
Beckett Simonon go.strayreviews.com/beckett-simonon
Grant Stone go.strayreviews.com/grant-stone
Sony ZV-E10 (favorite YouTube camera) amzn.to/3IFRPGb
Sigma 16mm (favorite YouTube lens) amzn.to/4bzeFeg
Shure MV7 (favorite YouTube mic) amzn.to/3QxEDoK

Follow me on Instagram instagram.com/strayreviews

For inquiries: contact@strayreviews.com
#loafers #mensloafers #mensshoes #mensstyle #thursdaybootcompany #huckberry #grantstone #beckettsimonon #astorflex #jaybutler

Some of the links above are affiliate links. Purchases made through these links earn me a small commission at no extra cost to you. It helps support the channel and is very much appreciated. Thanks!

-------------------------------------------------
00:00 - Intro
01:13 - Thursday Boot Company Penny
03:06 - Beckett Simonon Cohen
04:32 - Jay Butler Cromwell
06:06 - Astorflex Dartflex
07:52 - Grant Stone Traveler
10:05 - My Bottom Line Conclusions
-------------------------------------------------