The 3rd Annual Rumcast Fantasy Rum Draft @therumcast
The 3rd Annual Rumcast Fantasy Rum Draft  @therumcast
Uploaded September 2024 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Note: We need your help to make the most of this episode! Go to rumcast.com/vote after listening to help determine the winner of this year's Fantasy Rum Draft. Thank you!

For the third year in a row, we're back with our annual Rumcast Fantasy Rum Draft. In this annual competition, we compete head-to-head to “draft” rums from the selection of a single online liquor store for 10 different rum categories. The goal? To create the superior “desert island” rum bar.

Also, for the first time ever, we welcomed a guest to the competition! Arminder Randhawa from @therumrevival joined us to duke it out for fantasy rum bar supremacy.

Have a listen, and then head to rumcast.com/vote to help us determine the winner!

We "drafted" rums for the following categories from a selection of 400+ rums currently available at Del Mesa Liquor:

Unaged

Lightly Aged (1-4 Years)

Aged (5-12 Years)

Long Aged (13+ Years)

Cane Juice Unaged

Cane Juice Aged (Any Length)

Multi-Country Blend

Non-Caribbean

100% Column

100% Pot

After you listen, head to rumcast.com/vote to access the complete list of picks. You can view the spreadsheet with all the rums here: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1BV3aRZRZDrXll9DGTuCvidSBYR5iaVz8V5aj8M_Zayc/edit?usp=sharing

A few other rules and changes to note:

We each had a budget of $800.

We could each only draft one rum per brand. For example, if John drafted Worthy Park Estate Reserve, he wouldn't be able to draft Worthy Park 109. He could, however, draft Rum Bar Overproof since it is a distinct brand.

We trimmed down the number of categories this year to account for having a third participant.

We introduced the concept or "retired" and "snoozed" rums this year to keep things interesting. If a rum has been picked in the first round two years in a row, it is "retired" and inducted into the Hall of Fame, thus making it ineligible for future selections. Two rums qualified for this honor — Rum Fire and Probitas/Veritas. If a rum has been selected two years in a row (outside of the first round) it is "snoozed" and made ineligible for selection for one year. This year, Wray & Nephew Overproof was snoozed.

Have a listen, and don't forget to vote!
The 3rd Annual Rumcast Fantasy Rum DraftOur Top 6 Rum Predictions for 2023 (and Grading Our 2022 Predictions)10 Cheap Rums That Outdrink Their Price[Free Bonus Episode] Release Rumblings 6: Papalin Haiti, Guadeloupe Rum, Bottled-in-Bond Rum, & MoreThe Story of Dakabend Rum and Aguardiente de Caña in Oaxacas Sierra Norte with Elisandro GonzalezThe Past, Present, & Future of Navy Rum w/ Black Tot Rums Mitch WilsonCreating an Authentic Rum Brand with Marc Farrell, Ten To One Rum Founder/CEO - Episode 1695: Dispatches from UK RumFest and Beyond, with Chris Hassan Francke, Owner of The Green ZoneThe Rumcast Daiquiri Bracket Round 2: Modern DaiquirisBehind The Rums of Mexico Series with Jason CoxThe Rumcasts Favorite Rums of 2024Catching Up with Ben Jones: Rhum J.M, Rhum Clément, St. Lucia Distillers, and All Things Spiribam
The Rumcast |

The 3rd Annual Rumcast Fantasy Rum Draft

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER