Uploaded April 2012 | Updated November 2026, 2 hours ago
What was really going on here?
The "pronatalism" argument was constructed to take a similar form, fallacies and all, as the "antinatalist" argument. So any argument that was put forward against "pronatalism" can, mutatis mutandis, be applied to "antinatalism" too. The more successful the antinatalists were at shooting down "pronatalism", the more their own argument self-destroyed.
The long and short of it is that both positions are idiotic. They're both stupid, and for the exact same reason. If you can see the stupidity of the pronatalist position, don't pretend you can't see it for the antinatalist one.
What was really going on here?
The "pronatalism" argument was constructed to take a similar form, fallacies and all, as the "antinatalist" argument. So any argument that was put forward against "pronatalism" can, mutatis mutandis, be applied to "antinatalism" too. The more successful the antinatalists were at shooting down "pronatalism", the more their own argument self-destroyed.
The long and short of it is that both positions are idiotic. They're both stupid, and for the exact same reason. If you can see the stupidity of the pronatalist position, don't pretend you can't see it for the antinatalist one.
![Magic tricks!
The flogging shall continue until sense prevails, or I get bored. Whichever happens first.
[grin] Magic tricks!](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/niYu_xDfM30/mqdefault.jpg)









