Uploaded July 2025 | Updated September 2026, 1 day ago
Is the Supreme Court broken beyond repair? In this compelling forum, legal scholars, historians, and one of the most respected conservative judges in modern American history gather to examine the mounting constitutional crisis. From eroding public trust to presidential defiance of court rulings, the panel dives into the deep fractures threatening the foundation of American democracy.
The conversation addresses the Supreme Court’s increasing politicization, the dramatic drop in public confidence, and the court’s ethical struggles. As recent rulings spark nationwide outrage and accusations of partisanship, the panel unpacks the historical and structural roots of this legitimacy crisis and what it could mean for the rule of law in America.
The session also features a powerful and sobering address by retired U.S. Court of Appeals Judge J. Michael Luttig, who warns that the Republic may already be lost. His remarks—delivered with unmatched clarity and urgency—challenge viewers to consider the true state of constitutional governance in 2025 and what role the people must play in defending it.
Through lively debate and stark warnings, this discussion illuminates the legal, political, and moral crossroads at which the nation stands. Whether you're a legal expert or a concerned citizen, this video offers critical insight into what may be the most pivotal moment for the U.S. Supreme Court in modern history.
Please like, subscribe and click the bell icon above to get notifications when we post new videos!
Join our mailing list to get advance info on our upcoming programs and to sign up for livestreams: signup.e2ma.net/signup/1887647/1895526
We rely on our donors to keep our programming going, please donate here: vailsymposium.org/donate
Elizabeth Wydra is the president of the Constitutional Accountability Center, a nonpartisan legal think tank and advocacy group dedicated to promoting the progressive promise of the Constitution. A seasoned constitutional lawyer, Wydra brings deep expertise in civil rights, democracy, and the rule of law, often arguing landmark cases and contributing to major legal discourse across the U.S.
Clark Neily is senior vice president for legal studies at the Cato Institute, where he focuses on constitutional litigation and judicial reform. A committed libertarian, Neily previously served as a senior attorney at the Institute for Justice and was co-counsel in the landmark Second Amendment case District of Columbia v. Heller. He is known for his rigorous defense of limited government and civil liberties.
Judge J. Michael Luttig is a former federal appellate judge on the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit and one of the most respected conservative legal minds in modern American history. Though known for his originalist views, he has emerged as a prominent voice warning against threats to the constitutional order, particularly surrounding the events of January 6 and presidential overreach.
Is the Supreme Court broken beyond repair? In this compelling forum, legal scholars, historians, and one of the most respected conservative judges in modern American history gather to examine the mounting constitutional crisis. From eroding public trust to presidential defiance of court rulings, the panel dives into the deep fractures threatening the foundation of American democracy.
The conversation addresses the Supreme Court’s increasing politicization, the dramatic drop in public confidence, and the court’s ethical struggles. As recent rulings spark nationwide outrage and accusations of partisanship, the panel unpacks the historical and structural roots of this legitimacy crisis and what it could mean for the rule of law in America.
The session also features a powerful and sobering address by retired U.S. Court of Appeals Judge J. Michael Luttig, who warns that the Republic may already be lost. His remarks—delivered with unmatched clarity and urgency—challenge viewers to consider the true state of constitutional governance in 2025 and what role the people must play in defending it.
Through lively debate and stark warnings, this discussion illuminates the legal, political, and moral crossroads at which the nation stands. Whether you're a legal expert or a concerned citizen, this video offers critical insight into what may be the most pivotal moment for the U.S. Supreme Court in modern history.
Please like, subscribe and click the bell icon above to get notifications when we post new videos!
Join our mailing list to get advance info on our upcoming programs and to sign up for livestreams: signup.e2ma.net/signup/1887647/1895526
We rely on our donors to keep our programming going, please donate here: vailsymposium.org/donate
Elizabeth Wydra is the president of the Constitutional Accountability Center, a nonpartisan legal think tank and advocacy group dedicated to promoting the progressive promise of the Constitution. A seasoned constitutional lawyer, Wydra brings deep expertise in civil rights, democracy, and the rule of law, often arguing landmark cases and contributing to major legal discourse across the U.S.
Clark Neily is senior vice president for legal studies at the Cato Institute, where he focuses on constitutional litigation and judicial reform. A committed libertarian, Neily previously served as a senior attorney at the Institute for Justice and was co-counsel in the landmark Second Amendment case District of Columbia v. Heller. He is known for his rigorous defense of limited government and civil liberties.
Judge J. Michael Luttig is a former federal appellate judge on the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit and one of the most respected conservative legal minds in modern American history. Though known for his originalist views, he has emerged as a prominent voice warning against threats to the constitutional order, particularly surrounding the events of January 6 and presidential overreach.
