Uploaded July 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
Can quantum entanglement send messages instantly across spacetime—or does the no-communication theorem rule it out forever?
In this episode, theoretical physicist Dr. Siddhant Das joins Tim Ventura to explore a deceptively simple question at the foundations of quantum mechanics: when does a quantum particle arrive at a detector?
Arrival-time and time-of-flight measurements are used throughout experimental physics, but there is no single universally accepted quantum prediction for the complete distribution of particle arrival times. Bohmian mechanics, also known as pilot-wave theory, offers a distinctive answer because it describes particles as following definite trajectories guided by the wave function.
Das and his collaborators have proposed an experiment in which spin-polarized electrons travel through a waveguide toward a detector. By repeating the experiment many times, researchers would build a histogram of arrival times and compare it with the sharply different patterns predicted by competing approaches to quantum mechanics.
The larger—and far more controversial—question is whether arrival-time measurements might fall outside assumptions used in standard proofs of the no-communication, or no-signaling, theorem. Could a choice made on one member of an entangled pair change the arrival-time statistics measured at the other end? Could that eventually lead to real-time communication with a rover on Mars or a probe in deep space? Or would detector back-action, decoherence, timing noise, limited supplies of entangled particles and low data rates make the effect unobservable or impractical?
LINKS & RESOURCES:
Siddhant Das — Google Scholar
scholar.google.com/citations?user=FzjNHo4AAAAJ&hl=en
Siddhant Das — LMU profile
math.lmu.de/~qmp/members_alumni_theses.php
Arrival Time Distributions of Spin-1/2 Particles — Das and Dürr, 2019
nature.com/articles/s41598-018-38261-4
This is the foundational open-access paper proposing the spin-polarized particle and waveguide experiment.
Arrival-Time Distributions and Spin in Quantum Mechanics — doctoral dissertation, 2025
edoc.ub.uni-muenchen.de/36747
The most comprehensive account of Das’s arrival-time research, including quantum backflow, relativistic stability and possible single-electron Paul-trap implementation.
Detlef Dürr, Arrival-Time Distributions, and Spin in Bohmian Mechanics — Das, 2023
arxiv.org/abs/2309.15815
A comparatively accessible overview of the history, motivations and central predictions behind the work.
Can We Gauge Quantum Time of Flight? — Scientific American
scientificamerican.com/article/this-simple-experiment-could-challenge-standard-quantum-theory
A general-audience explanation with a useful visual account of trapping, releasing and detecting the particle.
Times of Arrival and Gauge Invariance — Perimeter Institute talk
pirsa.org/21060114
A recorded technical talk by Das on competing approaches to quantum arrival-time distributions.
ADDITIONAL LINKS:
Das and Aristarhov’s response to the measurability objection, 2023
arxiv.org/abs/2312.01802
On the Spin Dependence of Detection Times and the Nonmeasurability of Arrival Times — Goldstein, Tumulka and Zanghì, 2024
nature.com/articles/s41598-024-53777-8
Arrival Times Versus Detection Times — Goldstein, Tumulka and Zanghì, 2024
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10701-024-00798-y
Arrival Time and Bohmian Mechanics: It Is the Theory Which Decides What We Can Measure — Drezet, 2024
arxiv.org/abs/2409.04304
Arrival-Time Distributions as a Probe of the Preferred Foliation in Relativistic Bohmian Mechanics — Amblard and Drezet, 2026
arxiv.org/abs/2604.17507
Absorbing Detectors versus Scattering Theory — Cavendish and Das, 2025
doi.org/10.1103/332p-4nl1
MLL-Kolloquium: Prof. Detlef Dürr
indico.ph.tum.de/event/4161/?print=1
Can quantum entanglement send messages instantly across spacetime—or does the no-communication theorem rule it out forever?
In this episode, theoretical physicist Dr. Siddhant Das joins Tim Ventura to explore a deceptively simple question at the foundations of quantum mechanics: when does a quantum particle arrive at a detector?
Arrival-time and time-of-flight measurements are used throughout experimental physics, but there is no single universally accepted quantum prediction for the complete distribution of particle arrival times. Bohmian mechanics, also known as pilot-wave theory, offers a distinctive answer because it describes particles as following definite trajectories guided by the wave function.
Das and his collaborators have proposed an experiment in which spin-polarized electrons travel through a waveguide toward a detector. By repeating the experiment many times, researchers would build a histogram of arrival times and compare it with the sharply different patterns predicted by competing approaches to quantum mechanics.
The larger—and far more controversial—question is whether arrival-time measurements might fall outside assumptions used in standard proofs of the no-communication, or no-signaling, theorem. Could a choice made on one member of an entangled pair change the arrival-time statistics measured at the other end? Could that eventually lead to real-time communication with a rover on Mars or a probe in deep space? Or would detector back-action, decoherence, timing noise, limited supplies of entangled particles and low data rates make the effect unobservable or impractical?
LINKS & RESOURCES:
Siddhant Das — Google Scholar
scholar.google.com/citations?user=FzjNHo4AAAAJ&hl=en
Siddhant Das — LMU profile
math.lmu.de/~qmp/members_alumni_theses.php
Arrival Time Distributions of Spin-1/2 Particles — Das and Dürr, 2019
nature.com/articles/s41598-018-38261-4
This is the foundational open-access paper proposing the spin-polarized particle and waveguide experiment.
Arrival-Time Distributions and Spin in Quantum Mechanics — doctoral dissertation, 2025
edoc.ub.uni-muenchen.de/36747
The most comprehensive account of Das’s arrival-time research, including quantum backflow, relativistic stability and possible single-electron Paul-trap implementation.
Detlef Dürr, Arrival-Time Distributions, and Spin in Bohmian Mechanics — Das, 2023
arxiv.org/abs/2309.15815
A comparatively accessible overview of the history, motivations and central predictions behind the work.
Can We Gauge Quantum Time of Flight? — Scientific American
scientificamerican.com/article/this-simple-experiment-could-challenge-standard-quantum-theory
A general-audience explanation with a useful visual account of trapping, releasing and detecting the particle.
Times of Arrival and Gauge Invariance — Perimeter Institute talk
pirsa.org/21060114
A recorded technical talk by Das on competing approaches to quantum arrival-time distributions.
ADDITIONAL LINKS:
Das and Aristarhov’s response to the measurability objection, 2023
arxiv.org/abs/2312.01802
On the Spin Dependence of Detection Times and the Nonmeasurability of Arrival Times — Goldstein, Tumulka and Zanghì, 2024
nature.com/articles/s41598-024-53777-8
Arrival Times Versus Detection Times — Goldstein, Tumulka and Zanghì, 2024
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10701-024-00798-y
Arrival Time and Bohmian Mechanics: It Is the Theory Which Decides What We Can Measure — Drezet, 2024
arxiv.org/abs/2409.04304
Arrival-Time Distributions as a Probe of the Preferred Foliation in Relativistic Bohmian Mechanics — Amblard and Drezet, 2026
arxiv.org/abs/2604.17507
Absorbing Detectors versus Scattering Theory — Cavendish and Das, 2025
doi.org/10.1103/332p-4nl1
MLL-Kolloquium: Prof. Detlef Dürr
indico.ph.tum.de/event/4161/?print=1










