Strong Gods vs. Weak Gods: The Battle for Western Civilization @EducatingForLiberty
Strong Gods vs. Weak Gods: The Battle for Western Civilization  @EducatingForLiberty
Uploaded April 2026 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
Are the "strong gods" returning to American life — and what does that mean for politics, Christianity, and civilization?

In this episode of Project Cosmos, host Johnny Burtka is joined by a distinguished panel of scholars to discuss NS Lyons' essay on the long 20th century and the Return of the Strong Gods — building on Rusty Reno's influential work.

Guests:
Tom West — Paul Ermine Potter and Dawn Tibbetts Potter Endowed Professor of Politics
Khalil Habib — Allison and Dorothy Rouse Professor in Politics, Associate Professor of Politics
Miles Smith IV — Assistant Professor of History
Daniel O'Toole — Assistant Professor of Politics
Rich Bacigalupi — Director, Deany's Days Foundation

Timestamps:
0:00 – Introduction: NS Lyons & the Return of the Strong Gods
0:19 – Why the left calls conservatives "fascists"
3:58 – Malcolm X, identity, and strong gods on the left
8:08 – The structure of progressive movements: weak gods as the ideal
26:43 – Is traditional Christianity making a comeback?
43:09 – Two versions of Christianity & the immigration debate
1:08:37 – AI, Silicon Valley & the political realignment
1:09:24 – AI as a threat to elections and public opinion
1:31:19 – Can the republic be saved? The role of the statesman

Project Cosmos is a production of ISI — the Intercollegiate Studies Institute. Visit isi.org to learn more about our educational programs on Western and American civilization.
Strong Gods vs. Weak Gods: The Battle for Western CivilizationPeople Are Disappointed In the Current Education SystemSohrab Ahmari: Why Americans Feel So Powerless TodayAfter the Boomers, who will be the next most influential generation?How Christian Was Machiavelli?New Project Cosmos episode out now!Education For Its Own SakeWhy the Baby Boomers Were So InfluentialWhat kind of food should the government be funding?What can Government do to Help Poverty?Disenchantment is the Loss of StoryIs There An AI Bubble?
Intercollegiate Studies Institute |

Strong Gods vs. Weak Gods: The Battle for Western Civilization

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER