Strauss vs. Harmonization: Is Harmonization outdated? @LydiaMcGrewChannel
Strauss vs. Harmonization: Is Harmonization outdated?  @LydiaMcGrewChannel
Uploaded December 2022 | Updated September 2026, 6 days ago
Here I continue on the theme that Tim McGrew addressed: Did D. F. Strauss put an end forever to the reasonableness of harmonization?

I will be reading a quotation from Dale Allison accusing harmonizers of "trying to erase knowledge" and being motivated only by an outworn theory of inspiration that was "pulverized by the deists."

On the contrary, the satire by Johannes Ebrard, written within ten years of Strauss's Life of Jesus, "pulverized" Strauss by pointing out how faulty Strauss's methodology really was. In this "war of the quotations," I will be reading and commenting on Allison, Strauss, and Ebrard. Be sure to like and subscribe!

Find the text of Ebrard's satire embedded in this article, here, beginning with the title "Receipt for Writing..."

tertullian.org/rpearse/scanned/strauss.htm

Thumbnail photo: D. F. Strauss
Strauss vs. Harmonization: Is Harmonization outdated?Name statistics argument 13: List of the 12 as a source?Running back to the priors 4: Evidence does not matterAuthorship of John, Part 5: Muratorian CanonDoes Acts Support the Trilemma 4: The Persecution Ramps UpTolkien, Sanderson, World-building, and the GospelsUndesigned Coincidences in Secular History: The prothonotary warblerDeceptions Are Not Devices: Lucians trollingWhen are details suspicious?Authorship of John, Part 6: Irenaeus and the apostle who wrote the GospelThe epistemology of obvious and unobvious miraclesTestimonies to the Truth: Why You Can Trust the Gospels
Lydia McGrew |

Strauss vs. Harmonization: Is Harmonization outdated?

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER